Frontier thesis in American History:what Historian Frederick Jackson Turner suggested

Source

Frederick Jackson turner, a historian of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, according to the PBS website on The West “, …laid the foundation for modern historical study of the American West. “The existence of an area of free land, its continuous recession, and the advance of American settlement westward explain American historical development His Frontier Thesis continues to influence historical thinking.

Turner’s Background

Turner was born in the city of Portage, Wisconsin in 1861. His father was a journalist with a deep interest in history. Turner graduated from the University of Wisconsin in 1884 after deciding to become a professional historian he went on to John Hopkins University in 1890 where he got his Ph.D. His thesis was on the Wisconsin fur trade. He went back to the University of Wisconsin to teach from 1889 to 1910. He then went to teach at Harvard. In 1924 he retired. While he was a history professor Turner influenced a large number of students who went on to dominate American history programs for much of the 20th century. His own reputation was such that by 1010 he had the reputation of being one of the most influential historians in the country. He had what Wikipedia refers to as an “encyclopedic knowledge” gained from his research.

Frontier Thesis

Turner gained influence in the history field from his interpretive theories. These he published in articles. The “Frontier Thesis and the” Sectional Hypothesis,” were the most influential. What has become known as his Frontier Thesis was a scholarly paper presented in 1893 titled “The Significance of the Frontier in American History, ”which he read to the American Historical Association. It was during the Chicago Worlds fair.

The westward expansion of the United States, he contended, led to the spirit and success of the country. It was something of West vs. East. Turner believed that it was the West where the characteristics of the American developed. Pioneers moved across the west and gradually “abandoned useless European practices, institutions and ideas,” according to wikipedia. Characteristic that seem to have evolved from the frontier experience are those of informality, violence, crudeness, democracy and initiative. Characteristic that the world may think of as being American.

In the field of religion, William Warren Sweet of the University of Chicago Divinity School has noted that the frontier experience created new denomination such as the Mormons, the Church of Christ, the Disciples of Christ, and the Cumberland Presbyterians. Revivals, camp meetings and itinerant preaching have also been looked upon as resulting from the frontier experience.

According to wikipedia the term frontier referred in the United States to”…the transition zone where explorers, pioneers and settlers were arriving.” since the expansion in the United States was mostly from the east to the west the terms frontier and west were much the same.

During the frontier era Turner seems to believe that every generation of Americans went back to primitive conditions and repeating the stages of development from primitive to industrial. These stages have been considered to be from hunters to trading to pastoral (ranching) using the soil to raise crops without rotation, to rotated crops in sparsely settled communities, intensive culture of farm settlements to the final stage of manufacturing.

Turner felt that “…promotion of individualistic democracy was the most important effect of the frontier…”would be”…simply too scornful of rank to be amenable to the exercise of centralized political power.” I wonder what he would think of things now.

For Turner the significance was in what this all meant for the development of American character.

According to PBS “Turner’s contribution to American History was to argue that the frontier past best explained the distinctive history of the United States.” His idea did not get immediate acceptance and was ignored at first. Eventually it became influential that “…a contemporary scholar has called it ‘the single most influential piece of writing in the history of American history,’” the PBS article states.

The timing of his thesis followed a U.S. Census Bureau announcement three years earlier, which claimed that the contiguous frontier line had disappeared. It is also what influenced Turner to reflect on the influence the frontier had. PBS explains.

The cultural traits that Turner found in the frontier were ‘…restless turn of mind, quick to find expedients; nervous energy, that dominant individualism” were due to the frontier influence. According to the PBS article, Turner thought that with the closing of the frontier the “…first period of American History has also closed.

Oscar Micheaux, a Black filmmaker and novelist in the 1910’s to the 1940’s used turners Frontier thesis in his work, where he promoted the idea that the West was a place blacks could find economic success by hard work and perseverance, according to wikipedia.

Richard W. Slatta, "Taking Our Myths Seriously." Journal of the West 2001 argues that the widespread popularization of Turner’s frontier Thesis influenced popular histories, motion pictures, and novels, which characterize the west in terms of individualism, frontier violence, and rough justice, as quoted in wikipedia.

Although more than a century has passed since Turner first gave his frontier thesis it is still a subject of debate for historians. His critics deny just about everything about his assumptions and details of his argument, according to PBS.They go on to say that the mainstream of the history profession has discarded his assumptions of the frontier as key to American History. They argue that such things as the civil war, slavery, immigration and the development of industrial capitalism. Even in the specialties of frontier and western history more historians are challenging his approach.

Sectionalism


The Significance of Sections in American History is a collection of Turners essays and won a Pulitzer Prize in History in 1933.The theory on sectionalism was almost as influential among historians as was his Frontier Thesis. However, it was not as well know with the general public. Different ethno-cultural groups had distinct settlement patterns, which showed in politics, economics and society is the basis of the theory.

Civil War Influence

The west of the movies and books which we associate with “Cowboys” or the “western” genre stretches from the Civil War period to about the turn of the 20th Century. In my observation it seems that the Civil war had its effect on the western experience in America. For some of the following reasons:

· Many Confederate soldiers with nothing to go back to went west or stayed there.

· Many former slaves went west to find opportunity.

· The Civil War had upset the accepted social order of the time.

New Theories in 1960’s


Historians of the 1960’s and after became more aware of women, Indians and minorities. These are some of the things that they felt Turner ignored. As a result they tended to ignore or dispute turners theories. The critics complain that he neglected regionalism.

Turner ideas, according to wikipedia,” never really disappeared indeed they influenced the new field of environmental history.’ By applying new statistical methods and data sets many of Turners suggestions about population movements have proven correct.

My Observations

In my own observations of the study of history and western frontier history is that academic people who I think are competitive and make a reputation coming up with theories to combat former theories write history. I think that some new ideas in the 1960’s led to more study of what is called “social history” which I find most interesting. My own college professor of American History was a social historian and woke up my interest in history. He said that one thing that was discovered in the 1960’s was that there were Indians, women and black people in American history. Funny no one noticed them before.

I think that it is normal for new theories and research to come up with new perspectives. However, that does not mean that everything was wrong with the old ideas. In one way or another I think Turners ideas were right in that the frontier had to have an influence on American Culture, just the same as the Depression and World War II had an influence on my early childhood development.

Critics are probably right in that Turner thesis did not account for such things as the Indian populations in the frontier west.

The frontier and western images are part of American culture. President Kennedy ran on a slogan involving the New Frontier, popular Sci-Fi show Star Trek used outer space as “the final frontier.” Cowboys persist in country music and rodeo, which is a modern celebration of the round up of the old west round up. And lets not forget the Marlboro man.




Sources


Much of the information used here came from the Wikipedia article on Frederick Jackson Turner.

PBS-The West- article on Frederick Jackson Turner


More by this Author


Comments 22 comments

Peggy W profile image

Peggy W 5 years ago from Houston, Texas

This is an interesting account of Turner's writings and influence on the history of the American frontier. We will always have frontiers as long as we strive to learn about the unknown. Space and even our seas have only begun to be explored. Voted up, interesting and useful.


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 5 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

Hi Peggy W.The reason I wanted to bring Turner to readers attention is to examine the reasons behind our mythologizing the West and the Cowboy in American culture. I think the "western" is part of our mythology.Part of the reason they are not so popular is partly because writers and filmmakers have started to confuse the myth with history.Thanks for being the first to comment.


GClark profile image

GClark 5 years ago from United States

Interesting and informative Hub. Believe more emphasis should be placed on teaching history in our schools. Have always been fascinated by history and amazed at the challenges of early settlers. My ggrandfather came to the US from Scotland in 1854 after graduating from Glasgow University as an engineer. A couple of years after arriving in the east ended up driving a wagon train to Oregon. Again, thanks for sharing. GClark


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 5 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

Hi GClark.Thanks for commenting.History is important and it should be taught as accurately as possible.What many people don't realize is that history is a subject that has to be interpreted. Jackson's theories gave us one way to interpret our history, his critics give us another.Thhey both have their points.


Brian Leekley 5 years ago

See also:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Settler_colonialism

http://tequilasovereign.blogspot.com/2011/03/why-s...

I find fascinating that the frontier experience was conceptualized before it began. Settlement took the pattern it did because of concepts of land ownership, of surveying, of such political forms as the county and the township. People didn't just wander off into the woods and prairies. The government sent surveyors behind the explorers and fur trappers.

The Homestead Act was an act of American Indian tribes removal. One of my great-grandfathers homesteaded in Michigan. Here is the process by which Michigan was created:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_Territory


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 5 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

Thanks for commenting.


Storytellersrus profile image

Storytellersrus 5 years ago from Stepping past clutter

Hi da, did not know about Turner but I did know women existed throughout history, despite them being chattel, lol! It wasn't just Turner who disputed this, evidently. I wonder what kind of history the Taliban would write, if they won the battle.

Nice job!


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 5 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

Storyllersrus thanks for commenting.I don't think Turner disputed that women exist5ed. My professors point had to do with the fact that history had usually been written from the view point of politicians and military leaders.Turner,I think, made a breakthrough in that he focused on the idea of the ordinary people. He did not write a lot of history as he was more interested in the methodology of historical study.

To a lot of people history means wars, or presidents and kings-sometimes a queen.What the 1960s people did was look into such things as oral history and what was going on with ordinary folks.Novelists are another source of information for the social historian.

The Taliban have several hundred years of history to catch up on as it is.


WillStarr profile image

WillStarr 5 years ago from Phoenix, Arizona

"My professors point had to do with the fact that history had usually been written from the viewpoint of politicians and military leaders."

I would have thought it was written from the point of view of scholars, and today, those scholars have more of a revisionist, left wing point of view.


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 5 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

Hi Will, I would say that both statements are true.When we studied history when I was young we heard about presidents, kings. Maybe some business leaders but next to nothing about ordinary people.

You are right in the sense that it is written by mostly college professors and professional historians.However, an example of the newer breed of historians might be Dee Brown, although he is not that new anymore.Anyhow, he has written about Indians and pioneer women etc.Since the left wing dominates the Universities their influence is there as well.

Thanks for your observations.


mathira profile image

mathira 5 years ago from chennai

Good and informative article about Turner. We turn away from history thinking it to be drab and boring and miss out a lot of useful information about great people and great events.Good one, dahoglund.


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 5 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

mathira.Thank you for the comment. Even though Turner's thesis of the frontier has challenger I think he has contributed to our understanding.


prasetio30 profile image

prasetio30 5 years ago from malang-indonesia

Very interesting hub and I found another greatest American history from this hub. Brother, your passion always "on fire" and I really love your work here at hubpages. Your useful information make us want to read more and more. Well done, brother. Vote for all buttons, expect funny. Have a good day!

Prasetio


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 4 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

Thank you Prasetio, your comment is appreciated.It is part of my own attempts to understand history.Thanks for the votes.


tammyswallow profile image

tammyswallow 4 years ago from North Carolina

Excellent Dahoglund. I love learning history with you. I am also glad I wasn't born in that time frame in history. They just don't make people like they used to. I watched the "History of Us".. you would probably love it. It showed how the pioneers struggled to survive. I just love your hubs.


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 4 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

Hi tammyswallow. Thank you for the comments. I think that whether on agrees with Jackson's theories or not he had an important influence on how we see the American past.I am learning more as I write about history and research it.


Joseph Price 4 years ago

Can someone help me. I need to know what was the significance of the frontier to Fredrick?


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 4 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

Basically turner considered that the frontier was responsible for the"distinctive egalitarian, democratic. aggressive and innovative features of American character." This is from the article on "Frontier thesis" in Wikipedia. You can look there for more details.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frontier_Thesis


cam8510 profile image

cam8510 3 years ago from Columbus, Georgia until the end of November 2016.

This was a very interesting article. As I read, I could see how I need to understand the historical development of America better. I find myself writing more and more fiction about early American history and the only way to write convincing historical fiction is to know history. Makes sense to me. Thanks for the education. Good hub.


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 3 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

My daughter, I think, expressed it well when she said that history is like a big jigsaw puzzle and each piece adds to our understanding of the puzzle. I think I might have been a history major if my interest and understanding had evolved sooner than it did. Thanks for reading and commenting.


ajwrites57 profile image

ajwrites57 3 years ago from Pennsylvania

dahoglund, historians, like all of us, are influenced by education and environment. In Turner's day, women had not been afforded the right to vote, blacks were still fighting antebellum disenfranchisement and Indians were driven to the point of near extinction. No wonder these three groups were afforded less attention in his theories. It is a good thing that these three groups have been given their due in their efforts to tame the West. It is one thing to clear up historical inaccuracies and another to engage in historical revisionism. There are those that want to erase history and reinterpret it according to their own historical biases. (Sorry for rambling.) I had never heard of this fellow and his theories--my professors did a good job of erasing him from my study of history. You have the unique ability to uncover hidden gems of history and presenting them to us in a new way. Thanks!


dahoglund profile image

dahoglund 3 years ago from Wisconsin Rapids Author

aj, I never had much of an education in conventional history.The one professor that I took several courses from would use literary works as well as history and other fields. Often we would compare views of writers from different fields. That suited me well, although some students left class in a daze. I appreciate your compliment about my finding hidden gems. Mostly it is just things that happen to capture my interest. Thanks for your comments.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working