Legend of Sawney Bean

* Warning - Details of a Graphic Nature

I'll try to keep the details of this legend in simple terms and not get flashy with adjectives, since the Legend of Sawney Bean involves cannibalism and violence.

Alexander Sawney Beane - or Bean:

In late 15th or early 16th Century Scotland it is said that Sawney Beane was head of a 48-member clan, many members of which, Sawney shared his inclinations toward violence with.

The source for this legend is indisputably questionable, and many historians say that Sawney Beane never did exist, however, even if he did not ever truly exist, this legend is an extraordinary tribute, then, to the strength of Scottish storytellers.

Sawney Bean Was Notoriously Lazy and Fantastically Cruel

Though Alexander Sawney Beane was born to regular, hard-working folk, in East Lothian, he found out early on that he didn't share his father's drive for honest labour. He tried ditch-digging and hedge-trimming - trades that his father was skilled with, but Sawney just didn't have the gumption to exhibit any stick-with-it-ness!

He left home early either with a like-minded woman or he found his vicious female partner very shortly after leaving home. Right away, the pair turned to crimes, petty and otherwise, to eke out a living, and they made their home in a cave near Galloway.

Apparently, Bean and his partner lived in the hard-to-access cave for about 25 years, during which time they had children, then more children, and built a population of over 40 in their unwholesome clan. Some of the children and grandchildren were, of course, products of incest and rapes, and included 6 daughters, 8 sons, 14 granddaughters and 18 grandsons.

Without instruction in the arts of honesty and labour, the entire clan turned to crimes in order to survive. They conducted regular ambushes of travellers in the region and would murder individuals - and later, once the clan was larger, larger groups - and bring their victims back to their cave.

At the cave, they would dismember the victims, eat choice parts of their bodies, then often discard the rest, so that in the region, bodies with missing parts - or missing parts of bodies, were often found by local villagers and even authorities. If any extensive investigations about missing people were ever conducted, then the clan was so well hidden in their cave they were never found for around 25 years. The clan only committed their crimes at night, the old storytellers say, and 48 cannibalistic murderers were seemingly untouchable for the longest time.

Home Video, Tour of Sawney Beane's Cave

Growth of the Clan

Naturally, as the clan grew in number, so did their attacks on people. More clan members meant more mouths to feed - and feed, the clan did, until hardly anyone in the Galloway area could ignore that something was terribly wrong near Galloway.

Finally, several very extensive searches were organized, in order to find out who was murdering people and dismembering them at such a rate. At one point, the Sawney Beane-clan cave was probably located, but those who entered the cave and saw what state it was in concluded that nobody would actually live in such a place.

Hysteria and fear overtook the villagers around this time, and with the searches providing no answers, some lynching of innocents took place. Soon after, people noticed that the killings and human disappearances just kept right on happening, and from there, many inn-keepers were bothered incessantly while people suspected THEM of the grisly murders and unexplained disappearances.

Pointing the finger at Inn-Keepers seemed the logical next step, since Innkeepers were often the last ones to see people alive right before their partly mutilated bodies turned up near the sea or discarded outside of town.

The Clan's Bungled Ambush

Fortunately for the nearby villagers of Galloway - unfortunately for the clan, an ambush didn't turn out as planned one night when some of the clan members choose to attack a certain married couple who were travelling through the area on horseback, after having visited the fair during the daytime. Unbeknownst to the attackers, the husband was highly skilled in the arts of combat, and had with him on this night, a sword as well as pistol.

Although the husband's wife fell during the ruckus - and the clan mauled her to death, the man kept fighting bravely for his life and soon, a group of travellers happened along, took stock of the very disturbing scene, and rushed to the area, saving the now lone traveller.

The clan simply fled from the situation but with such a scene, their general location was revealed and reports of this location went all the way to the authority of the King. The King launched a massive manhunt, deployed at least 400 armed and trained men, along with hounds, and it was a very short time until the clan's hideout cave was uncovered.

The cave found found by the King's men was, indeed, the one which had already been looked upon but discarded as too unfit for human habitation. Finally, the Sawney Bean clan was apprehended. It is said that the entire clan was captured alive, chained together, and taken a jail while the cave left behind was found to be littered with human remains. It was hard to imagine the hundreds of murders and cannibalistic events which must have taken place there.

Fear Incorporated Performs/Tells Sawney Beane Legend in Song "Sawney's Cave"

Have You Heard This One?

Have you encountered the Legend of Sawney Beane Before?

See results without voting

More by this Author

  • Categories of Folklore

    Folklore is a term with tremendous numbers of sub-set categories. Types of oral tradition, kinds of folklore stories and narratives are just some of the considerations involved when discussing...

  • Paul Bunyan

    As with many mythical heroes, the birth of this hero is a trip into the fantastical, the unbelievable. Paul Bunyan is said to have been delivered to his parents via stork! Actually a normal baby would be delivered by...

  • Social Constructions

    Marriage, Gender, Manners, Religion... a perspective on social constructions.

Comments 30 comments

mistyhorizon2003 profile image

mistyhorizon2003 7 years ago from Guernsey (Channel Islands)

I remember reading of this legend many years ago, but you have refreshed my memory and my interest greatly. I wonder if it really did happen to be true, or if it is simply a fascinating legend!

melfitz 7 years ago

Grew up with that legend...just down the road!!!!!!

spryte profile image

spryte 7 years ago from Arizona, USA

I had never heard this legend...*shiver*...but that would keep me in for the night if I had.

Thanks (I think) for sharing that.

Christoph Reilly profile image

Christoph Reilly 7 years ago from St. Louis

Cool story.

Paper Moon profile image

Paper Moon 7 years ago from In the clouds

Oh I am an instant fan!

mythbuster profile image

mythbuster 7 years ago from Utopia, Oz, You Decide Author

Christoph Reilly - thx for the comment. Yes, it's a cool story.

spryte - when I made the hub, I stayed up long past my bedtime because I was spooked by the information lol

I hope you will come back and comment, melfitz, and let me know the version of Sawney Beane that you heard!

Sufidreamer profile image

Sufidreamer 7 years ago from Sparti, Greece

Great Hub, mythbuster.

I studied in Stirling, Scotland, and there is an Indian restaurant there called 'Sawney Beane's'. It served good curry!

cindyvine profile image

cindyvine 7 years ago from Cape Town

And what meat was in the curry, Sufi? Interesting story and quite gruesome. I have heard that the Scots were the most savage though, like little Scottish terriers. This just goes to prove that you must never trust a man who wears a dress.

Sufidreamer profile image

Sufidreamer 7 years ago from Sparti, Greece

Luckily, I am veggie, so never found out. Apparently, it tasted like pork :/

The Scots certainly were a tough bunch - must be the cold!

nazishnasim 7 years ago

That sent chills down my spine. Plus, I am an instant fan - you know whose obviously *evil grin*

cindyvine profile image

cindyvine 7 years ago from Cape Town

But Mel Gibson did look his best when he was a Scot!

Sufidreamer profile image

Sufidreamer 7 years ago from Sparti, Greece

I was there for the premiere, and saw all of the stars. Mel Gibson really is a tiny, tiny little man. I could have put him in my pocket :D

mythbuster profile image

mythbuster 7 years ago from Utopia, Oz, You Decide Author

Glad you were able to feel a bit of nostalgia for Scotland after reading the hub, Sufidreamer. I'm surprised at the number of people who've mentioned that the story brings back memories or that they've not heard this legend for a long time. I had never heard of it before researching for the hub! I am still gathering some research together to place on the hub.

Cindyvine - luv your comment about a man in a dress. Exposed errr knees must make for a much higher constitution and instinctual preservation of the errr knees and bare spots in a man with a dress on, I suspect!

nazishnasim - thx for your comment - glad you enjoyed the Sawney Beane legend.

amethyst 7 years ago

hi there i had never heard of this legend before until today i purchased a dvd called hillside cannibals and on the reverse it said it was based on the true story of sawney beane so i decided to look it up and found ur article its very interesting x x

boogie man  6 years ago

not scary but a would have loved to experience it as i am only 11 years old and have saw the film there for believe in all that stuff

mythbuster profile image

mythbuster 6 years ago from Utopia, Oz, You Decide Author

I'm glad the legend wasn't too scary for you, boogie man

mythbuster profile image

mythbuster 6 years ago from Utopia, Oz, You Decide Author

amethyst - I will look up the movie title and see what it's all about.

Peter C Armstrong 6 years ago

Most likely based on fact.See bellow.

http://tarlton.law.utexas.edu/lpop/etext/newgate/b... I had been told a story like this. The tale attached deeds to the Armstrong Clan in the Debatable Lands.

twogunbob 6 years ago

I wonder if there are any women left of the bloodline of that clan... :> sounds like we could have some fun evenings

mythbuster profile image

mythbuster 6 years ago from Utopia, Oz, You Decide Author

Haha - twogunbob - and if you find one of these women, are you going to ask her out on a date? Bring the BBQ sauce, perhaps?


Thanks for the comment.

KenWu profile image

KenWu 6 years ago from Malaysia

An interesting legend or myth. Doubt that this is true.

mythbuster profile image

mythbuster 6 years ago from Utopia, Oz, You Decide Author

Hi KenWu - I don't know how much of the Sawney Beane legend is true. I have had a great deal of trouble tracking down legitimate sources for info on the Sawney Beane story. I think there might be a lot of "cautionary tale" bits in the legend, however - many Europeans I have spoken to about this legend say it is a valid legend - plausible - and that it's true.

cant tell you 6 years ago

i fot i saw a video just like this but in coler

mythbuster profile image

mythbuster 6 years ago from Utopia, Oz, You Decide Author

Hey cant tell you - where did you see the video at?

cant tell you 6 years ago

subisiling at animal planet.com

JY3502 profile image

JY3502 5 years ago from Florence, South Carolina

Great story myth, I didn't know you had written it and wrote one myself.

√©lida seixas 4 years ago

bacana gostei ^^

Rachael 4 years ago

very very interesting and scary. My family members have went to try and find. It quite dangerous. I am to scared.freeks me out

Gipsy Dianic profile image

Gipsy Dianic 19 months ago

How bloody gruesome and fascinating!

mythbuster profile image

mythbuster 16 months ago from Utopia, Oz, You Decide Author

Yes, totally gruesome, Gipsy Dianic! Thanks for stopping by to read and comment! :)

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article