Magnetic Disk Therapy, A Method for Alternative Pain Relief

Magnetic Jewelry

This magnetite ring is used to lessen pain in the finger joints and wrist area.  Does it work or is it only a placebo?
This magnetite ring is used to lessen pain in the finger joints and wrist area. Does it work or is it only a placebo? | Source

An Introduction to Magnetic Therapy

Despite its muted reputation as quackery, magnetic therapy has continued to convert non-believers into magnetic testimonials.

Sports enthusiasts, the elderly, and sufferers of low back pain say that while magnetic disk therapy is not a cure all, it helps alleviate pain, discomfort, sore joints, grinding spinal disk pain and other ailments associated with aging and intense levels of physical activity, like professional athletes and trainers.

Magnetic therapy using magnetic products are a major alternative health industry. Rarely covered by traditional health plans, the folklore belief in magnetic therapy make it a popular over the counter health aid. Its effectiveness still remains unproven.

Science and Mathematics

Gauss, a child prodigy, contributed greatly to many mathematical fields of study including geometry, astronomy and physics.  A primary scholar, he is shown here on the 10 Deutschmark bill, discontinued in 1993.
Gauss, a child prodigy, contributed greatly to many mathematical fields of study including geometry, astronomy and physics. A primary scholar, he is shown here on the 10 Deutschmark bill, discontinued in 1993. | Source

How Does it "Work"?

Magnetic Theory

Since magnetic fields attract and repel, the principle of blood flow repulsion is at work, here. The blood protein hemoglobin is mildly dia-magnetic. Long term exposure to the magnets is exercised with the goal of pushing the concentration of blood from the pain point allowing freedom of movement, lessening of pain and relief of pressure due to applying the magnets to pain points in the body.

The Gauss Rating

The Gauss rating is a physical measurement measuring the surface of an area, like the skin, or the earth's surface as opposed to the muscle mass below the skin or the earth's layers. In choosing a suitable magnet, the internal Gauss rating is usually stated but the surface Gauss rating will be much less. The principal of penetration is at work here - can the magnet effectively reach the bio-chemical-electro level to the blood stream and muscle mass? The magnet must be strong enough to make a difference in recharging the body to a higher circuitry level. So the theory says.

Scientifically Unproven

Does it Really Work?

Those who say that Magnetic Therapy is a hoax claim that the magnetic fields present in the disks are too weak to affect any long term (or intermediary) effect. A placebo effect, they say, is the reason for the improved health.

Every year, Americans alone invested $33.9 billion dollars (annually!) on alternative medical products. Included in that total is an estimated $500 million spent just on magnetic therapy by Americans. Worldwide, the number is estimated at $5 billion for international consumption of pain-relieving magnets.

Magnetic therapy remains scientifically unproven. Control groups show improvement, depending upon the ailment. Historically, magnetic bracelets were first used in ancient China around 3000 B.C.

What Magnets Do and Cannot Do

Magnetic therapy was shown to relieve pain in control groups, where both magnetized disks and a placebo "dummy object" were used so wearers wouldn't know the difference.

Those who had the "real magnets" stated a nearly 70% improvement in knee joint pain, pain in the pelvis, and those suffering from fibromyalgia.

Fibromyalgia is a condition which causes fatigue and difficulty sleeping. With symptoms similiar to chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), it was shown to respond well to magnetic therapy.

Unfortunately, suffers of Low Back Pain, as well as Carpel Tunnel Syndrome (wrist and forearm pain) do not show a marked effect from the magnetic therapy disk treatment.

A study of women, who suffered with the embarrassing condition of urinal incontinence improved after being given bi-weekly magnetic stimulation to the pelvic floor area. An impressive 58% claim that the magnetic therapy helped them.

Another control group was given magnetic belts to place around hips 24 hours a day. In a period of only four weeks, a large percentage of the wearers reported a significant reduction of pain in the pelvic area.

Do magnets help cure cancer? At this point and time, despite claims to the contrary, it appears that the answer to this sticky question remains a resounding "NO".

Magnetic Products

Magnetic Jewelry

Bracelets, rings, wrist and ankle straps are intended to alleviate arthritic pain in the joints.

Bedding

Mattresses, blankets, pillows which are intended to improve blood circulation, revive the muscles and reduce pain and discomfort while the patient sleeps. The pillow is usually shallow and is designed to alleviate neck pain (from too many hours sitting at the computer, for example).

Other Products

Creams and Supplements can be applied internally or externally.

Magnetic Therapy Poll

What is your opinion on Magetic Therapy?

See results without voting

More by this Author


Comments 2 comments

JayeWisdom profile image

JayeWisdom 4 years ago from Deep South, USA

It may work for some people, but it didn't work for me (and I really wanted it to!)


EuroCafeAuLait profile image

EuroCafeAuLait 4 years ago from Croatia, Europe Author

Hi Jaye, I'm not sure (the jury is definitely out on this one!) - but I think it depends on what part of the body we're talking about. My dad had chronic knee pain and said they helped him - a LOT. I have low back pain and I have heard they don't help much for that area. What was your experience?

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working