Shark Finning and Dumping at Sea or Landing the Catch Debate

There are many good reasons why shark finning at sea, and dumping the carcases overboard should be continued and equally good reasons why it is better to land the whole shark catch.

Many, many people have taken up the issue of shark finning, because so many are killed each year to supply the largely Chinese demand for the highly-prized shark fin soup, that many sharks have become endangered species.

But is shark finning at sea better or worse than landing the whole catch, and finning the sharks on dry land?

The shark ends up dead either way.

The trouble with shark fishing is that while their meat and oils are used in many industries, the prices at market are comparatively low.

While sharks fins can reach upwards of $500 a kilo, the other parts of the shark are lucky to reach $10/kilo.

There is debate over this, and I intend to present both sides of the argument.

landed shark in harbour
landed shark in harbour | Source

Reasons Why Shark protection bodies want the catch landed

Central and North America have introduced laws to prevent shark finning at sea, and the EU is expected to bring in a total ban soon.

The main reasoning behind their push against shark finning at sea, is that fishermen are catching more sharks than they are allowed to, and the hope is that by forcing them to land their catch, less sharks will be killed.

When a fully loaded shark fishing boat arrives back in harbour, it is impossible to count how many fins he has on board.

Fins represent only a tiny percentage of the weight of the total shark, and small sharks have small fins.

Different breeds have sharks can also have different sizes and weights of fins, and in many places, while the current regulations allow fishermen to land fins weighing up to 5% of the weight of their total (shark) catch, this has created a loophole allowing them to fin far more fish than they land.

As steps have to be taken NOW, to avoid losing several severely endangered species of sharks completely with the next 10 - 20 years, shark protection bodies want an end to all finning at sea, and whole sharks landed as catch instead.

They hope this will result in:

  • Less sharks killed.
  • Greater accountability of the actual number of sharks killed.

shark fishermen
shark fishermen | Source
shark finning
shark finning | Source

Reasons why shark fishermen want to fin at sea

Hardly anyone ever looks at this argument from the fisherman's point of view, but the first thing you have to remember is that fishermen have one of the most dangerous jobs in the world.

They are out their in their boats in all weathers, working long hours, facing storms, floods, whirlpools, constant danger, not to forget the very real danger to their physical well-being from a newly-caught shark which has some very damaging rows of teeth.

If we want to have fresh fish on our tables, we need the fishermen to keep working.

The overheads on fishing boats are very high. Between nets costing $10,000 or more, that can and are frequently lost simply by snagging on the sea bottom, to buying and maintaining computer navigation systems costing thousands, to the boat and engine itself, which could cost millions, every trip to sea is hugely expensive.

Every crew member on a fishing boat works hard. These boats carry no passengers. Fishermen have to physically strong, and they work very long hours.

Their pay is normally determined on how much the boat makes on each trip. Overheads have to be paid for first. The amount of fuel they go through is enormous, and they do not get many miles to the gallon.

Fish are normally gutted at sea, rinsed and placed in long fish boxes and then covered with ice to keep them fresh until the boat returns to port. The remains are thrown overboard, which is why you always see those sea scavengers, seagulls, swirling and diving around fishing boats.

Enter the shark fisherman.

He has all the same work as other fishermen, only he would just have dumped the carcass of the shark overboard, as it is simply not worth bringing into harbour.

  • The not inconsiderable weight of sharks adds to his fuel costs.
  • They also take up a lot of space.
  • Still living sharks are a danger on board to anyone near them.

big sharks eat smaller sharks
big sharks eat smaller sharks | Source

Sharks eat sharks

There is another environmental concern regarding sharks that have been caught, whether for finning at sea or on land.

Sharks finned at sea and dumped overboard get eaten by other sharks and marine animals.

It is sad that many are still alive at this point.

In nature, sharks do hunt and kill other smaller and weaker of their own species. That is a fact. Some sharks only survive their gestational period by eating their baby siblings while still inside their mother.

Every sea creature needs to eat to survive, the same as those of us on land.

Landing all the sharks caught at sea, denies a huge amount more of food.

If man really does not want the shark meat and oils caught as a by-product of those precious fins, then leave them at sea.

If man wants them, then more will have to be paid for them, to make it worth the fisherman's while to land it.

Do You think sharks should be finned at sea, and another way found to reduce the number of sharks fished?

  • Yes
  • No
See results without voting

More by this Author

  • List of Types of Sharks in British Waters
    18

    If you've ever wondered what types of sharks live in British waters, you might be surprised to learn just how many there are. Read about those sharks, a little about their normal habitat, and whether or not they are...

  • Mediterranean Shark Attacks
    12

    This is a list of all reported shark attacks that took place in the Mediterranean Sea, including the Adriatic and Tyrrhenian Seas, since 1868. According to the ISAF database, there have been 55 attacks and 36 deaths.

  • EDITOR'S CHOICE
    How to Build a Greenhouse Made From Plastic Bottles
    211

    Recycling plastic bottles are all the rage, and what better way to make use of them, than by building yourself a greenhouse? Learn how to build a greenhouse made from plastic bottles.


Comments 6 comments

Global-Chica profile image

Global-Chica 4 years ago from New York, NY

Thank you for writing about this. I personally think that shark fin soup should be illegal and so should any kind of finning - it's just so cruel and unsustainable.


IzzyM profile image

IzzyM 4 years ago from UK Author

Most people want it stopped, but that isn't going to happen any time soon, when the biggest nation in the world demands the fins, unfortunately. Even if they could be persuaded to change their minds, it will take so long, it will be too late for the sharks. Perhaps just making shark fishing illegal might solve the problem, especially if all western nations agreed? That would leave Asian fishermen only doing the finning.


Gordon Hamilton profile image

Gordon Hamilton 4 years ago from Wishaw, Lanarkshire, United Kingdom

You make some good points, Izzy. As a lifelong sea fisherman, however, it may surprise you that I agree completely with Global-Chica and advocate a total ban on shark finning at sea. Our oceans are in a desperate state with some marine species so much in decline that the damage man has done may soon be irreversible. If people want to spend a hundred dollars or more on a bowl of shark's fin soup, that is of course their prerogative but the lunacy this represents should not be an acceptable excuse for raping our oceans.

The way I see it, sharks caught for shark fin soup should be landed whole and all parts of the shark put to some form of appropriate use. This will help with conservation, drive the price of the "Soup" through the roof and hopefully put to an end once and for all to this cruel, barbaric and wholly unnecessary practice.

Just my tuppence worth... :)


IzzyM profile image

IzzyM 4 years ago from UK Author

Yes I see your point about it forcing the price yet further up. Half the problem has come about because although sharks fins are very expensive, China's wealth has risen at a higher rate, making it more affordable to all. But fishermen have to make a living too. It's striking a balance here. It's also true to say that sharks are now being starved at sea, which explains why some have migrated north into cooler waters than normal. We are overfishing the seas. The bluefin tuna is facing extinction, along with many other sea fish/mammals. It's actually a really difficult problem.


Anil and Honey profile image

Anil and Honey 3 years ago from Kerala

Shark finning , Good hub.I had see it in TV(discovery channel) but these type of article is first. Thank you for sharing .


IzzyM profile image

IzzyM 3 years ago from UK Author

You're welcome :) It's a difficult topic because there are so many arguments on all sides. At the end of the day, it is cruel, but then again, maybe so is raising cows for food?

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working