The Spell Check Debate

Check This

Eye used spell Czech four this art tickle. It is a price less tulle that yelps me fined miss takes in my righting be four I sub mitt to pub lush.

When used properly, spell check can help people improve their writing and communication. But when misused, spell check is a detriment to language acquisition and thinking skills.

For the first time this year, the Oregon Department of Education allowed students to use spell check on the annual state writing test. Whether you agree with this decision or not, there are valid points that can be made both in favor of and in opposition to this change.


Here are some of the most powerful arguments being made for and against the use of spell check by students.

Pro

Spell check is a tool that students can be taught how to use properly. It has applicable uses just like a calculator in math class, the periodic table in science class, and a map in social studies.

Students can use spell check on every other writing sample they produce (with a word processor) except the state writing test. Therefore using spell check on the test is more reflective of their normal writing conditions.

When evaluating writing, it is important to look at content rather than context. The meaning of the words is more important than the presentation.

Conventions scores on the state writing test count twice, so students can meet every other standard and still fail the test if they do not meet the conventions standard which includes spelling, grammar, and punctuation.

Spell check can help students learn to identify words they commonly misspell.

Con

Con

Learning to spell is a foundation of acquiring vocabulary, understanding language, and communicating with others.

Students using spell check will be less likely to learn the difference between homophones and commonly mistaken words.

Spell check does not correct punctuation, like misused apostrophes, semicolons, or commas. Despite spell check, students can still fail to meet the conventions standard on the state writing test by making egregious mistakes in grammar and punctuation.

Spell check creates bad habits, allowing students to rely on the program and discouraging them from looking up the correct word.

Spell check cannot be used on other tests like the SAT and ACT. Therefore, students need to be able to function without it.

Should students be allowed to use spell check on their writing tests?

See results without voting

More by this Author


Comments 2 comments

Tom Vogler profile image

Tom Vogler 5 years ago from The Shenandoah Valley

You make a strong point and a great demonstration of the danger of spell check with your opening paragraph. Great technique! :-)


cindy.dauer profile image

cindy.dauer 5 years ago from Oregon Author

Thanks, Tom. I think spell check is tremendously helpful, but we still have to teach kids how to spell.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working