The Magnus Effect

Table tennis is a sport where spin of the ball is essential element of a game.  (source: corbisimage.com)
Table tennis is a sport where spin of the ball is essential element of a game. (source: corbisimage.com)


A corner kick in association football is widely understand as very promising opportunity for a score . Quite often defending side is outsmarted. Corner taker crosses the ball to some of the attacking players to head into the goal. This is the most common tactics. However, it is possible to score a goal directly from a corner! This is possible due to the known fact that spinning balls change direction.

In football this turn of ball is no so obvious because the ball is relatively heavy. However, in table tennis this is essential element of the game. But why the spinning ball swerve? Briefly, the answer is because of the Magnus effect. This article describes the underlining physics of this phenomenon that causes the Magnus force. This phenomenon is so named in honor of the German physicist H. G. Magnus (1802 - 1870).


Do it yourself! Make a paper cylinder and check the theory on Magnus effect (see the video bellow). (source: flysky)
Do it yourself! Make a paper cylinder and check the theory on Magnus effect (see the video bellow). (source: flysky)

Experiment in Your Home


Imagine a tennis ball rolling down the slope table (see figure). When leave the table, the ball will free fall. As we know the trajectory of that falling ball will be some parabola. Easily we can convince ourselves in that fact (see video). However, let instead of tennis ball be a paper made cylinder. What would be the trajectory in this case? Since we probably haven't some experience with such a situation we can be in dilemma... The answer is that the cylinder will turn towards behind of the table, as the figure shows.

In an variation of this experiment the table is leave horizontal. On one table edge we fixed elastic rope. The paper cylinder should be coiled on that elastic. Now the elastic with cylinder is tighten and than released. This causes the two motions. The cylinder will move horizontally, drown by elastic. In the same time, cylinder will rotate, since the elastic was coiled around it. What would be the trajectory of cylinder? Might unexpectedly, the cylinder will be significantly lifted. This is in line with the previous experiment. Here will have the opposite rotation, so the Magnus force has the opposite direction.


The Magnus force appears according to the Bernoulli effect, because of the difference in pressure between the two sides of the body. (source: flysky)
The Magnus force appears according to the Bernoulli effect, because of the difference in pressure between the two sides of the body. (source: flysky)

Explanation of the Swerve


Firstly, note that this effect couldn't be observed in an empty space (without atmosphere). For example on a planet or a moon without atmosphere. The effect is observed when a body is spinning in a viscous fluid. Due to the viscosity, fluid particles around the body will also rotate. If the body is stationary, the particles will rotate as faster as closer to the body. Nothing special will happen in this case.

Both rotation and fluid flow are crucial for the effect. Namely, in this case there will be the difference in the speed between particles underneath and above the body. On the side where rotation and fluid flow has the same direction, the speed will be higher (according to the basic mechanics). As the consequence of this difference the difference in pressure appears, according to the Bernoulli effect.


The Magnus Force


A spinning body move through some fluid having the velocity v the angular velocity ω. The Magnus force F is a force caused be the pressure difference between two sides of the body. It holds

F = S ( ω x v )

where x denotes the vector cross product. The unit S depend on the air resistance across the surface of the body. This is the general relation. In particular, for spinning ball in the air it holds:

F = ½ φ v2 A CL,

where φ is the density of fluid, v is the velocity of ball, A is area of ball and CLis lift coefficient. The lift coefficient can be determined experimentally, based on Reynold numbers and spin ratios.


The Magnus Effect - in medias res

Application


The Magnus effect is very present in sports with ball. In addition the the mentioned football and table tennis, it works in baseball, golf, tennis and other sports. When the ball rotate backwards from the direction of movement - with horizontal axis of rotation, there is a vertical force that acts against gravity, which enable the ball stay in air a little longer. When the axis of rotation is vertical than the ball has a drift. An example is a goal from the corner in football (see video).

The same principle is applied in case of flying machines in order to additionally lift the plane.

In astronomy, rotating celestial body when moving through a medium like solar wind are exposed to the Magnus force action.


A Goal Directly from a Corner


  • In association football, goals from a corner were authorized in 1924 by International Football Association Board (source: Wikipedia, the article 'corner kick').
  • An unbelievable example date back in 1950 when Celtic's player Charlie Tully scored from a corner. However the referee annulled the goal because Tully was outside of the arc. In the repeated kick, directly from the corner, Tully scored again! (source: Wikipedia, the article 'corner kick')
  • Blaž Slišković, a Bosnian football player was one of the best players of the former Yugoslavia country. He was nicknamed "Balkan Maradona” and he was widely known for his scores from a corner.


A short quiz - check your knowledge!

Summary


  • A rotating ball changes its direction because of Magnus effect.
  • As the air molecules stick with a rotating body, it's coming up the difference in pressure between two sides of the body.
  • The Magnus force is a consequence of this pressure difference (for details see Bernoulli effect).
  • On the side of slower windspeed there is higher pressure, on the side of faster windspeed there is lower pressure.


More by this Author

  • Buoyancy and Archimedes's principle
    2

    Firstly, we describe how Archimedes discovered the law nowadays known as Archimedes's principle. Buoyancy is explained in detail, qualitatively and quantitatively and illustrated with some remarkable examples. Related...

  • Fluid mechanics-have you ever drunk mis mash cocktail?
    0

    How came that wine and orange stay unmixed in mis mash cocktail? Why we don't drop in the show when having snowshoes? What is the physical principle behind hydraulic press? The article gives answers on these and similar...

  • Univariate and Multivariate Linear Regression
    6

    The article is written in rather technical level, providing an overview of linear regression. Linear regression is based on the ordinary list squares technique, which is one possible approach to the statistical...


Comments 2 comments

AverageWriter1 profile image

AverageWriter1 3 years ago from California

This is a very informative and interesting piece. I enjoyed reading it.


flysky profile image

flysky 3 years ago from Zagreb, Croatia Author

Thank you very much, AverageWriter1! This phenomenon is relatively unknown, but very present in everyday life i.e. in sport. It's fantastic how rotation can change the direction of a body...

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working