" Order is the first need for any society—only then can liberty and justice be reasonably secure"
Why do you agree or why don't you agree?
To answer this question, I must first look at another quote by Russel Kirk: “If you want to have order in the commonwealth, you first have to have order in the individual soul.” In this quote one may feel that "order in the individual soul" implies a "moral code", but this is only conjecture. Consequently, when we look at the statement you are referring to, I cannot see in either quote any indication that Kirk included "moral code" in his concept of "order". Order does not necessarily imply a moral code, as order can be found in the Konzentrationslager, the tax collectors office, or a house of whores. Considering this, I would disagree with his statement, and will amend as follows:
"A moral code is the first need for any society to bring about a social order—only then can liberty and justice be reasonably secure. To institute order without a moral code not only invites tyranny, but guarantees it! "
How about this from his First Principle - "That order is made for man, and man is made for it: human nature is a constant, and moral truths are permanent."
But human nature is not a constant, and moral truths are never permanent nor universal.
May I take your order?
What is order based On?
"Social order in sociology, history and other social sciences, referring to the conduct of society." Wikipedia
The conduct of society is based on what?
The desire for Harmony?
or something else?
One of the major differences between Conservatism and Liberalism is which came first, the chicken or the egg.
Conservatives believe that society came first and out of that came the Rights of Man as that society deems fit to give (this includes the religious society)
Liberals believe the Rights of Man came from a "state of nature" which existed before society formed, be it a clan or a nation.
Liberals believe these Rights are "inalienable" while the Conservatives believe they are "alienable" (yes, there is such a word)..
by Rad Man4 years ago
I have written a hub on this subject and I recently came across this video. It's part 3/3, and I didn't take the time to what the first 2 parts yet, but it's fascinating.http://youtu.be/fm-bTW3FhL0
by Dennis Pace6 years ago
I have been interested in this topic for some time, and recently decided to write articles about it. However, as part of my research I would like to know your opinions. What will life be like? How do...
by CASE1WORKER2 years ago
There are some writers here that seem to glorify in making somewhat controversial posts which often result in obnoxious replies that border on direct attacks.It seems to me that these prolific posters do not need to be...
by Kathryn L Hill2 years ago
Questions:!. How are Morals established in a Society.2. Are good and decent actions fostered in the youth through training and guidance? 3. Are morals and boundaries natural to a human being and built within his nature...
by Julie Grimes6 years ago
As written by, and believed by- British philosopher Bertrand Russell. Who wrote the 1927 pamphlet, Why I Am Not A Christian."He writes;"Religion is based, I think, primarily and mainly upon fear. It is...
by Greatest I am4 years ago
Like it or not, God is immoral.This clip shows how man has defined morality. I generally agree with it as it closely resembles the morality shown in all the holy books. I see them as closely resembling the golden...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.