In my views, I would have to state that the top 5 civilizations of all time would be:
1). Persia (Expansion, Tribute System)
2). Egypt. (Cultural Diversity)
3). Rome. (Citizen Soldiers, Road Infrastructure)
4). Great Britain. (Industrial Revolution)
5). Greece/Macedonia. (Rise of Hellenism, Sharing of scientific and moral ideas)
Share with me, what do you think? Any more, maybe take one away, switch it up.
You didn't include China. Many advances in science, agriculture, medicine, etc.
The British EMpire was bigger (by land and population) than any other 'civilization.' They also gave up there empire with less trauma than any other, doing a lot of good in the process (though there is no denying that a lot of that good came undone very quickly).
The Inca empire was far better organized and run than any other empire in history and it was big by any standard. It is the only civilization ever, anywhere, any time, that eliminated hunger universally. Most of its expansion was without a great deal of bloodshed.
I think these two 'civilizations' were the greatest but because they were so different they can not be compared to one another.
I don't think the term "western civilization' means something specific enough to count as a separate entity.
Various about the British, esp James Morris's trilogy
Various about the Incas, esp Garcilaso de la Vega, El Inca, Royal Commentaries (history of the Inca Empire)
Although based on slavery, ancient Greece was the place wherein was religious freedom. Some of the present administrations have learnt much from this period. And some never will, particularly which country has the power to , as a USA general once said " We have the power to blow up the world a 1000 times", Such ignorance is highly dangerous to his country.
With you on that Cags! The Incas and Mayans weren't smart enough not to sacrifice or start wars either.
Again you two seem to only want to look at this question one sided. Yes did they kill, sure did. But they were mathematical geniuses. There is no denying their contributions to civilization.
The original poster didn't ask for the "perfect" civilizations only the greatest. Huge differences!!! I would rate your twos opinion as only accepting the "perfect" & not the greatest. When you rate something as great you take into account the overall good with the bad. In my humble opinion the civilizations that i listed, good out ways the bad. Now if we are to judge something as perfect.... well that's entirely different set of standards. Hence you two are being extremely shortside on this topic. Technically your standards don't even apply here. Nobody is perfect, not even you two.
I'm not looking at the question one-sided. I am answering the question based on objectivity, which apparently you cannot see.
No one is denying their contributions to humankind. But, that still doesn't make them to have greatness.
Really? Oh, I am glad you told me. Now I know.
It's not like I didn't to begin with. And, I didn't mention anything about a "perfect" civilization. I did however mention being civilized, which you are not reading or comprehending.
And, you should know something IntimatEvolution- "perfect" isn't something any civilization, even as a collective can obtain. So, why bring it up to begin with. Greatness? Only works for individuals, NOT as a collective, unless you want reach civilized living. Got it?
I can see just fine thank you. I got it alright. You aren't being "objective" your being closed minded and insensible about the subject matter in which is clearly over your head.
So what's too see? Your arguments about greatness when your standards are quite clearly set as judging a collective based off perfections? Why pay attention to nonsense that isn't even on topic? No thank you, I will pass.
Over my head? You're kidding right?
Put it this way, if you are going to give credit to a specific civilization for specific contributions and call them great, then you obviously lack understanding of LIFE in and of, itself.
GET OFF "perfections". Do you NOT comprehend words written?
You're the one bring up junk and making it appear as if a singular contribution makes them great. How pathetic is that?
To answer your email- None!
How would you rate "greatest" when it comes to civilizations?
None of the were actually civilized.
Edit: None are now either.
So what do you think makes a civilization great? What is a Civilization?
If I truly could answer your question, I would rule or run the world.
I only know of one civilization. It's the collective Human species and ALL should lead by example, by showing people how civilized they can be.
None in history has ever shown that quality, as a group or as an entire species.
I think much could be learned from the Babylonian, Mayan, and Inca's Empires.
Many people could learn from themselves, much less learn from others. The learning from others is what is the problem already.
Oh yes, the Mayan, inca, and Babylonian cultures all displayed emmaculant studies in astronomy and mathematics, and Babylon created a law system that is still in use among many Arab countries today.
What's so humerous? I think your opinion is extremely shortsided. I hardly think that's funny... Concerning yes, lol funny... I think not.
Short-sighted? Not at all. You want to give credit for greatness, to people who simply haven't actually earned it.
How nice of you. So, yes, it's funny.
Well cagsil, if you can't give credit to one particular nation or empire, then what great philosophers lived within what countries and why do you think their great?
Again, you're attempting to nail it down.
Why? Yes, there are exceptional individuals, but there has never been exceptional collective, which is my point.
Well if there could be a collective of 5 exceptional individuals that could rule a nation, beside yourself of course, who do you think that would be?
Why do you keep changing the dynamics of your original post to fit the needs of one poster? He hasn't given you a decent public answer yet. Why conform your original post to fit the needs of one complicant hubber, who was only baiting you in the firstplace?
Stand your ground for petesake. You asked a very good question. Now all your wishy-washy around has muddled your original question, all for not. What end will you go to gain acceptance from them? Get a clue he was trolling and baiting you. He does that.
That's the point. There isn't nor has there ever been exceptional individuals who could work together long enough to develop a great civilization. Otherwise, humankind would have already developed a civilized great nation, completely united under one specific collective view.
Cags I am not going to debate this topic with you. Your standards are clearly not within the realms of reality here. You want perfection. Greatness is not perfection. So us debating semantics here is absurd. Now when you want to debate on topic I would love too. But until then your points are mute because they are irrational and so I choose to pass. Thanks though, but until you are on point with the original posters requirements I am not going to debate this with you.
If you are judging something based off perfections then you should really start your own thread based on that.
Thanks again Cags but......
Next? I know I would love to read what you hubbers have to say is your view on other "great" civilizations of our past history.
Todays civilizaions should be considered the greatest! At no time has education , technology, communication , global politi-zation , political unity or multi cultural -religious understanding, and global media been stronger or clearer and potentialy closer than before.
Thanks again Cags. But again I see how you don't want to contribute anything of worth on the subject matter...... yet again!
Thanks for proving my point.
Oh by the way your idiosyncratic responses are hijacking this thread.
What are some greatest civilizations of all time? Not perfect but great.
You know, I am not attempting to claim any civilization is perfect, but NONE of them are great, including today.
If we're so great....then why so much killing? why so much poverty? why so much homelessness? why so much disease?
Please...greatness value people are putting on a civilization is ridiculous.
Cagsil, World Media and communications alone make todays civilization the greatest. Be serious , past civilizations had the ability to rule with the definate lack of these. They could hide behind the ignorance of the mass populations . If you were a Roman , what did you know of the Mayans , or native American what did you know of France or Greece. All civilizations today are at least somewhat accountable to the rest of the world. Hitler ruled most of Europe before the media actually convinced anyone else to hold them accountable. AND, what do we know of history except what was written by the victors in any case. Personally , I would vote for another time too, but I'm prejudiced by my disdain for man in modern times.
Thank you everyone for posting your opinions, I appreciate everyones feedback from both ancient civilizations to modern civilizations and how influence and mass media has caused heavy changes in accountability factors
The most advanced civilisations have also been the cruelest. Ancient Rome brought modern technology and fine works of art to all outposts of their empire. Yet, it also enslaved many people and enjoyed the most blood-thirsty entertainments. The British Empire was the biggest empire the world has ever known, with one quarter of the world's population being ruled by Britain. This time is considered to be the height of British culture and civilisation, yet it was an empire based on slavery and the theft and destruction of many native cultures. And whilst Britain became rich from its empire, most of the British population were living in unimaginable poverty. So, it depends what you mean by greatest civilisation.
Egypt, coz when other civilization still make some cooking tools they already made piramids >.<, they also had calender and astronomy
by glendoncaba6 years ago
Atheists are looking for evidence to attack the story of Jesus and have been all over the internet saying that Christians stole the myth of Horus.Here is a good article which debunks the lie. Read it and...
by JasonChevez4 years ago
I understand now that the greatest lie that I have been thought to believe is that God doesn't believe in you. Don't get me wrong. There are many other lies in the world. But this one is by far the one that effects your...
by Cybermonk6 years ago
Am into hunt of articles for preparing a seminar regarding ancient world civilization. please suggest me some good hubbers thanks..
by Dan Harmon6 years ago
My local paper this morning has an article on possible evidence of early American life. Seems that an archeologist by the name of David Jenkins previously found fossilized excrement with human proteins and/or DNA...
by Cagsil6 years ago
Hey Hubbers,Seriously, I'm doing a little added research for a Hub I am writing and need a little input.When you were younger - Your parents guided you.As you got older - You were guided by school.Here in between - If...
by ironking6 years ago
What do you think is the greatest achievement of human civilization?
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.