Backward Advances: Rear-Facing Trombones Throughout History

Trombones have gone through more permutations than some people may realize. Not only has history seen soprano, alto, tenor, bass, contrabass, and valve trombones, but an intriguing permutation of the instrument, called the rear-facing or over-the-shoulder trombone, pops up frequently in pictures and occasionally in museum holdings; e.g., here. For a YouTube clip of someone playing such an instrument, see here. (I prefer rear-facing as a descriptive term, since over-the-shoulder does not distinguish from the standard trombone, which already has a rear bow of tubing that extends over the player's shoulder.)

The very earliest examples of this instrument likely reflect the working-out of the shape of the trombone; the standard trombone almost certainly evolved, after all, as a "bent" version of the original straight trumpet. The exact manner and shape it was bent was probably not immediately standardized, and it is likely that there was some experimentation along the way.

Later, beginning in the late 18th century, there was a more general trend among all brass instruments toward over-the-shoulder instruments (see Boston Brass Band example, below). Trombones were part of this trend, which is said to have been at least partially the result of the desire for better ensemble balance (i.e., they were generally softer).

Historian David Guion categorizes over-the-shoulder trombones as "no more than a temporary vogue" (Guion, A History 66). I'm not sure I completely agree. It depends on how you define temporary, of course. There are nine images from pre-1800 alone. Even if you discount those nine early examples, you're still left with a long, steady stream of iconography after that: 59 additional images from 9 different countries spanning a full century. That is really too long and too widespread to be considered a "temporary vogue."

I would probably characterize it something like this: Iconography suggests that the over-the-shoulder trombone, which can be seen in a handful of images before the 19th century, became relatively widespread in the 19th century. Use of the instrument eventually appears to taper off, but not until the end of that century. Although there is significant variety in iconography, many of the images originate in France, and a large number of them depict military usage.

For additional historical context and full citation of sources, see Trombone History Timeline.

c. 1405—Paris, France: A grotesque from the Hours of Charles the Noble plays what is perhaps a proto-rear-facing trombone. There is no slide, obviously, so it is not a true trombone, but the similarity in general shape is obvious and could be seen as an early experiment in the direction of rear-facing brass instruments (see below image; public domain) (RIdIM/RCMI Inventory No. 8, p. 21).

1503-1529—Spain: A painting by either Joan Gascó or Gabriel Guardi includes an angel-trombonist playing what appears to be a rear-facing instrument. The first detail, below, shows the rear-facing bell, partially obscured by the halo, circled in red. The second detail shows more of the image, providing a view of the other halos and the materials nearby. Finally, the third image is the full painting (public domain image) (Ballester; French National Library).

c. 1504—Perpignan, France: A painting on an organ shutter (since relocated to the wall opposite the organ) in the Perpignan Cathedral (Cathedral Basilica of Saint John the Baptist of Perpignan, or Basilique-Cathédrale de Saint-Jean-Baptiste de Perpignan) depicts musicians at the Feast of Herod, including a rear-facing or over-the-shoulder trombone. Although there are some improbable aspects of the trombone, including the shape of the slide and the general configuration of the tubing, it seems unlikely that the artist would have misjudged the actual direction of the bell (see below detail; public domain; special thanks to Jean-Jacques Herbin).

1570—Waiting for the Princely Guests, an image depicting wind musicians in a balcony atop a triumphal arch, shows trombone, trumpets, bombard, and positive organ, as they prepare to play for a prince’s arrival (see below image; public domain) (Carter, Renaissance 278; Nuremberg, Stadtbibliothek).

1578—Antwerp, Belgium: A set of masses by George de La Hele includes a print–an initial D in front of a group of cherub musicians–that features a rear-facing trombone being played by a cherub (also rear-facing) (see below image; public domain; Wangermée vol. 1 167).

c. 1615—Cislago, Italy: The Church of Santa Maria della Neve contains an anonymous frescoed lunette featuring several angel musicians, including a trombonist playing a rear-facing instrument (see below image; public domain) (Morandi; Farioli).

c. 1660—Pierre Paul Sevin’s drawing of a performance of a mass for 4 choirs includes what appears to be a group of 3 trombones. At least one of them is a rear-facing instrument; the other 2 pictured do not have clearly visible bells (see detail and full image below; public domain) (Marx, The Instrumentation of Handel's Early Italian Works).

1689—The Netherlands: An etching by Dutch engraver Romeyn de Hooghe titled L’Europe Allarmée pour le fils d’un Meunier includes what appears to be a rear-facing trombone (see upper-left of full image). The print is a satire against James II (see below detail and full image below; public domain).

1732—Prague, Czech Republic: Upon restoration of the Strahov monastery, monk-artist Siard Nosecky paints a fresco on the refectory ceiling that includes what appear to be two rear-facing trombones along with two horns and a tromba marina (see detail and full image below; public domain).

1781-1854—Amsterdam, Netherlands: Military Music, a catchpenny print produced by Erve H. Rijnders, includes a rear-facing trombone (see below detail; public domain image) (Catchpenny Prints of the Dutch Royal Library).

c. 1795—France: Trombonist André Braun publishes his method book, Gamme et Méthode pour let Trombones, which includes a position chart showing a rear-facing trombone (Weiner, Braun; Weiner, Braun Revisited; Dudgeon 194).

c. 1800—Germany: A print of military musicians entitled Turkische Musick der K. Baierischen Grendier Garde, now held in the Germanisches Nationalmuseum, includes a rear-facing trombone (see below detail; public domain).

c. 1800—Frankfurt am Main, Germany: Philipp Jakob Döring publishes a sheet of cut-outs of military musicians that includes a rear-facing trombone (see below detail; public domain) (German National Museum).

1801-50—Munich, Germany: A print illustrating various musical instruments includes a rear-facing trombone (see below detail; public domain) (German National Museum, graphic collection).

Source

1805—Netherlands: A watercolor labeled Batavian Republic (now the Netherlands) and dated 1805 features trombonist in military uniform playing a rear-facing instrument (see below image; public domain) (New York Public Library Digital Gallery).

1806—France: An image depicting several French military musicians includes a rear-facing trombone (see below center); also included is another now-obsolete instrument, the serpent (see below right) (public domain image, source: New York Public Library Digital Gallery).

1807-08—Germany: Christoph and Cornelius Suhr, in their book on military uniforms in Hamburg (Abbildung der uniformen aller in Hamburg), depict musicians from the Dutch military in Hamburg from the years 1807-08. Included is a musician with an awkwardly-rendered rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain).

1810-40—Strasbourg, France: An image by artist Boersch Thiébaut (1782-1861) that is part of set of figurines executed between 1810 and 1850 features musicians of the 14th Regiment, including 2 rear-facing trombones (see below image; public domain) (Paris, musée de l’Armée).

c. 1815—Munich, Germany: Musik der Bürger-Garde der Haupt u. Residenz-Stadt München, a print by J.C. Hochwind, includes players of both traditional and rear-facing trombones (see detail and full image below; public domain) (Ryan 202).

c. 1820—France: An etching titled The French Garrison, probably set in Normandy, depicts a group of French soldiers mingling with villagers. A fiddler and a regiment trombonist with a rear-facing instrument provide music for dancing while standing on a makeshift stage (see top-right of below image; public domain) (Fromrich 24).

c. 1820—Paris, France: An anonymous illustration of a French military band includes two rear-facing trombones (see top row of below image; public domain) (Camus, Military Musicians).

1820—An engraving entitled Banda Militare includes 2 rear-facing trombones (see below detail; public domain) (Oberlin Conservatory Special Collections).

1820-39—Rotterdam, Netherlands: A catchpenny print by T.C. Hoffers and A. van Alphen depicting several different military instruments includes 2 rear-facing trombones, one of which has a dragon-head bell (a type of trombone often called a buccin) (see below detail; public domain; Catchpenny Prints of the Dutch Royal Library).

1821—Italy: A depiction of a carpenter and 3 musicians from the Italian grenadiers includes a musician with a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (Melegari 147).

1824—Belgium: A pen and ink drawing of a Belgian military trombonist depicts a player in full military regalia playing a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (New York Public Library Digital Gallery).

c. 1825—France: Pellerin, publisher of French popular prints, publishes an image titled Musique d’Infanterie Francaise, which includes a soldier with a rear-facing trombone (see below detail; public domain) (Paris, Museum of Civilization in Europe and the Mediterranean).

1825-1850—Strasbourg, France: The Wurtz and Pées family produces paper figurines of various military units. Among them are numerous military musicians, including several with rear-facing trombones (see below 4 images; public domain).

1826—Broek, Netherlands: March of the Cavalry, a “catchpenny” military print that features numerous musicians, includes a man playing a rear-facing trombone on horseback (see below detail; public domain).

1828—France: An image from the Vinkhuijzen collection of military uniforms includes a trombonist on horseback playing a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (New York Public Library Digital Gallery).

1828—Paris, France: Caricaturist J. J. Grandville depicts a country dance in his lithograph, Sundays of a Good [Middle-Class] Citizen. At the front-center of the orchestra is a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (Fromrich 29).

c. 1830—Vienna, Austria: K.k. Österreichischer Militair Leichen-Conduct, lithograph no. 8 from a series edited by Michael Tretsentsky, shows a military band that includes trombones. The configuration is somewhat unusual in that it includes both traditional and rear-facing trombones (see below image; public domain) (Pirker).

1830—Strasbourg, France: Sometime before this date, a print by Jacques Perlasca of a mounted chasseur band illustrates both a standard rear-facing trombone and a rear-facing buccin (see detail and full image below; public domain) (Ryan 23).

1831—Belgium: A lithograph titled Musiciens d’infanterie belge, or “Belgian infantry musicians,” portrays a military musician holding what appears to be a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (Bibliotheque royale Albert I; Wangermée vol. 2, 264).

1832—Belgium: A print by Belgian artist Jean-Baptiste Madou titled Officier Garde Civique Premier depicts an officer of the Belgian Civil Guard. Behind the officer stands a military musician who appears to be holding a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (New York Public Library Digital Gallery). For a similar image, see 1831 (above).

1834–Paris, France: In his trombone method book, Grande Méthode de trombone, Vobaron includes a graphic showing a rear-facing trombone from both sides (see below image; public domain).

1837—Paris, France: Jean-Georges Kastner, a French composer and theorist, writes his orchestration treatise, Traité Général d’Instrumentation. The treatise includes a rear-facing valve trombone with a fingering chart (see below image; public domain).

c. 1839—Fribourg, Switzerland: Musica militaris, a print depicting musicians of the boarding school of Fribourg, features a percussionist and a trombonist with a rear-facing bell (see below image; public domain) (Bovet and Curchod 28).

1845—Prague, Czech Republic: A drawing satirizing the Prague music conservatory (Satira na prazské hudební konzervativce) includes at least one rear-facing trombone (see upper-left of below image), and probably two (see upper-right) (public domain image) (Volek, pl. 315).

1847—Paris, France: An article in the periodical L’Illustration titled “Le Pupitre de Palestrina” (“The Desk of Palestrina”) is accompanied by an image by Henri Valentin that includes a rear-facing trombone in what appears to be an attempt at a historical representation of a Palestrina-era performance (see far left of below image; public domain) (L’Illustration, vol. 9, May 1, 1847, p. 137).

1848—Paris, France: Georges Kastner’s treatise on military music, Manuel Général de Musique Militaire, features illustrations of a number of different types of trombones used in military music, including rear-facing valve trombone (see below image; public domain) (Kastner, Militaire Pl. XVII).

c. 1850—Bassano del Grappa, Italy: The firm Remondini publishes a print of military infantry and bandsmen. The band may represent Austro-Hungarians. Included among the band is a rear-facing trombone (see detail and full image below; public domain) (Ryan 385).

c. 1850—Turnhout, Belgium: Troupes de differentes nations, a print published by Brepols, probably copied from several slightly earlier prints by Pellerin, includes a depiction of French soldier on horseback playing a rear-facing trombone (see detail and full image below; public domain) (Ryan 440).

c. 1850—Bassano del Grappa, Italy: The firm Remondini publishes a print, probably representing an Austrian band, that includes a rear-facing trombone (see detail and full image below; public domain) (Ryan 382).

1850s—Vienna, Austria: K.K. Ungar: Regiments Feldmusik, a print published by Anton Paterrno, includes both a traditional trombone and a rear-facing trombone (see detail and full image below; public domain) (Ryan 419).

1851–Boston, Massachusetts: A woodcut from Gleason's Pictorial Magazine (August 9, 1851) depicts the Boston Brass Band, which utilizes exclusively over-the-shoulder brass instruments (including trombones; see left side of below image) (public domain image).

1852—Paris, France: A print by Janet-Lange entitled The Elections in England, published in a French illustrated newspaper, includes a rear-facing trombone among a small group of musicians (see detail below; public domain) (L’Illustration, July 17, 1852, p. 33).

1853—Paris, France: The illustrated newspaper L’Illustration publishes a graphic, “La danse aux camps,” depicting a military celebration with a four-man dance band in the upper-left that includes what appears to be a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (L’Illustration, vol. 22, July 23, 1853, p. 64).

1854–Paris, France: Moderne Musik, a print satirizing current trends in classical music, appears in the periodical Journal pour rire. Among the musicians is a trombonist with a rear-facing instrument. It's interesting that the artist would choose a rear-facing trombone to represent modern music, when a traditional front-facing trombone would have blasted more directly into the symbolic "public ear" (see detail and full image below; public domain) (Worbs 191).

1855—New York, New York: Theodore Benecke's illustration, Sleighing in New York, includes a band performing from the balcony of Barnum’s Museum. The trombonist in the band plays a rear-facing trombone (see below detail; public domain) (Eno Collection of City Views, New York Public Library; Bowles, Timpani 295).

1856-1900—The Netherlands: The publisher Glenisson & Sons publishes a print of military musicians that includes 2 rear-facing trombones (see below detail; public domain) (Catchpenny Prints of Royal Dutch Library).

1860—A drawing for the cover of the piano-vocal score for Jacques Offenbach’s operetta, Les deux aveugles, features a man holding a rear-facing trombone, with a similar trombone along the border nearby (see below image; public domain) (source: Wikimedia commons).

1861—Paris, France: A print published in the periodical L’Illustration, after a drawing by Rogier, depicts the entry and reception of European Commissioners in Damascus. Among the instruments in the brass band is a rear-facing trombone (see below detail; public domain) (February 23, 1861, p. 119).

1865—Paris, France: A satirical graphic titled Domestic joys of parents whose daughters take part in women’s orchestras, published in Le monde illustré, includes a woman playing a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (Le monde illustré, 9, no. 442; Sept 30 1865).

1865—Paris, France: A print by caricaturist Honoré Daumier depicting a group of country musicians (Musique de Fete Champetre) includes a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (Brandeis University Collection; Gartenberg 42).

1866-1897—The Netherlands: Printer Franciscus Anthonius Beersmans publishes a woodcut, "Ten strijde!" (“To battle!”), that features several Dutch military musicians, including one with a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (Catchpenny Prints of the Netherlands Royal Library).

1869—Paris, France: A print by Alfred-Henri Darjou entitled The Entertainers Behind the Barracks appears in the French illustrated newspaper, L’Illustration. Four musicians–flute, rear-facing trombone, ophicleide, and drums–rehearse together at a makeshift table, while others rehearse their own roles or complete various chores (see below image; public domain) (L’Illustration vol. LIV, July 24, 1869, p. 60).

1871—Paris, France: A lithograph titled A propos de la crise monétaire (“about the currency crisis”) from a series of prints by French caricaturist B. Moloch (B. Colomb) called Les Silhouettes de 1871 depicts a woman playing a rear-facing trombone, along with a well-dressed man wearing a sign asking for pity and donations (see below image; public domain).

1871—Paris, France: Léonce Schérer depicts a man with a rear-facing trombone in the caricature, Souvenirs de la Commune (see below image; public domain) (Victoria & Albert Museum).

1871—Paris, France: An illustration by Alfred-Henri Darjou entitled De Paris a Meaux pendant l'Armistice is printed in the periodical L'Illustration. One of the musicians in the back appears to be playing a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (L’Illustration vol. LVII, March 18, 1871).

1875—New York: F.S. Church's engraving, Breaking up of Our Summer Concert, is published in Harper's Weekly. The picture includes a rear-facing trombone among several other instruments (see below image; public domain).

1875-1900—Epinal, France: French Music (Dragoons), a print published by Pellerin in the last quarter of the 19th century, depicts a group of military musicians on horseback, including one playing a rear-facing trombone (see below detail; public domain image) (Museum of European and Mediterranean Civilization).

1880–Paris, France: Léo Taxil's Calotte et calotins, histoire illustrée du clergé et des congrégations includes an illustration, signed Frid'Rick and entitled "Le Ciel" ("Heaven"), that features an angel playing a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain).

1883—New York: The Great Rival Advertising Shows to “Boom Up” Stocks, a print by Bernhard Gillam, is published in Puck (v. 14, no. 339). It shows three advertising sideshows, one of them represented by a man playing a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain).

1884—Paris, France: A print from G. Bruno’s Le tour de la France, depicting the principal musical instruments of the time, includes a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (Bruno 53).

1889—Stuttgart, Germany: The periodical Neue Musikzeitung publishes an illustration by C. Zopf accompanying a poem about a serenade-gone-bad. The illustration includes a musician with what appears to be a rear-facing trombone (see below image; public domain) (vol. 10, p. 121).

1890—New Orleans, Louisiana: An anti-jazz cartoon by F. Bildestein, published on the cover of the newspaper The Mascot, depicts a rear-facing trombone with a jazz group (see detail and full image below image below) (public domain image; source: wikimedia commons).

Locations of Rear-Facing Trombones

show route and directions
A markerParis, France -
[get directions]

B markerAntwerp, Belgium -
[get directions]

C markerCislago, Italy -
[get directions]

D markerVienna, Austria -
[get directions]

E markerFribourg, Switzerland -
[get directions]

F markerPrague, Czech Republic -
[get directions]

G markerBrussels, Belgium -
[get directions]

H markerBoston, Massachussetts -
[get directions]

I markerNew Orleans, Louisiana -
[get directions]

J markerStuttgart, Germany -
[get directions]

More by this Author


Comments 11 comments

Mentalist acer profile image

Mentalist acer 6 years ago from A Voice in your Mind!

It seems the back facing trombone would be great in a concert or orchestral settings,not so good in outdoor or marching and parade settings;)


kimballtrombone profile image

kimballtrombone 6 years ago Author

Yeah, it's kind of paradoxical that it caught on in military settings, which are mostly outdoors, but not in indoor concert settings.


msorensson profile image

msorensson 6 years ago

Wow..delightful, educational and well presented. Thank you!!

Great job. Thank you for sharing.


allpurposeguru profile image

allpurposeguru 6 years ago from North Carolina

I stand in awe of your collection of illustrations. It seems to me, though, that the last two you present here show "hand me down" instruments. Neither street beggars nor the earliest jazz musicians would likely to have new instruments. They would be very likely to wind up with instruments that no one else wanted any more, wouldn't they?

I had no idea that there were any rear-facing trombones between the establishment of the basic shape of the trombone and the 1790s. The time when they were most extensively used seems to be between then and the middle or end of the 1860s.

Again, excellent work. I'll bet folks here would enjoy the dragon-head bells, too!


kimballtrombone profile image

kimballtrombone 6 years ago Author

David,

Thank you for your insightful comment.

Concertmasters around the world play on "hand me down" violins, and I play on an excellent "hand me down" Conn 6H jazz horn, but I think I see where you're coming from, and I agree that the heart of the instrument's usage is probably the span you cite above. Thanks for your comments and encouragement. I appreciate it!


kimballtrombone profile image

kimballtrombone 6 years ago Author

Update--I just added another image, this one from Stuttgart in 1889. It's noteworthy because of the late date and because it's the only one I've been able to locate from Germany.


kimballtrombone profile image

kimballtrombone 6 years ago Author

2nd update--Added another image, this one from 1854 satirizing modern music.


kimballtrombone profile image

kimballtrombone 6 years ago Author

3rd update--Added another image, this one also relatively late: an 1880 drawing from Paris. It's satirical, but so are many trombone images in general from this time period.


kimballtrombone profile image

kimballtrombone 6 years ago Author

4th update--Added another early example, a second image from Prague (1732). I would say it would appear more and more likely that the rear-facing trombone was more than a "temporary vogue."


kimballtrombone profile image

kimballtrombone 6 years ago Author

Yet another update--This one, by artist Alfred-Henri Darjou, is from 1871 in France, a somewhat late example.


kimballtrombone profile image

kimballtrombone 5 years ago Author

It's been a while, but I just added 3 more images: one relatively early example (1781-1854) and two relatively late examples (1866-1897 and 1875-1900).

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working