Direct TV vs Comcast - Which is Better?

Comcast is the United States’ largest cable provider while Direct TV is their biggest satellite television provider. For someone living in an area where cable service is being offered by both companies, the task of choosing one is difficult because both advertise many tempting deals. Therefore, it is beneficial to pit Direct TV vs Comcast in areas of the service and price.


Services Offered

Comcast is a provider of cable TV, high speed internet, and telephone lines. They present attractive deals like the triple play that provides all of the above services for a flat fee of $99 per month. This may seem very tempting but in most cases, the price for this deal is only available for the three months to one year. In addition, the services offered may be those available at the lowest level of the packages. For instance, one deal only involves channels available on basic cable, the slowest internet speed package, and a regular telephone line.

For some, getting all three services from one company may seem to be a great idea. However, many people have complained about poor service. In most cases when a company tries to specialize in many different services, it causes the quality of service to be negatively affected. Direct TV, on the other hand, has been rated as a provider of quality service by its customers. This may due to the fact that they only specialize in providing satellite television and hence, have more time and energy to spend perfecting this service area.

One thing to remember though when comparing DIRECTV vs Comcast is that the former uses satellite dish technology while the latter a last mile network to each home. Some prefer not to have a satellite dish mounted on the side or back of their home.


Comparing Direct TV and Comcast Prices

Most people use the price as the deciding factor when trying to choose between services provided. Certainly that is an important factor when comparing Direct TV vs Comcast. Where you live definitely affects the price you pay for cable but on average, the Comcast Starter cable package costs approximately $54 each month.

This package includes a great variety of popular networks that involve sports, news, kid’s programming, and music. The digital converter box, digital music channels, on-screen guide, local channels, and the remote control come with this package too. Other offered packages are the Digital Preferred, Preferred Plus, and Digital Premier.

Each have more channels than those in the starter cable package but of course, it comes with a higher price, topping out at $119.99. One advantage Comcast does have now is the Visa rebate card program, where if you commit for two years you can get some cash back in the form of a debit card.

Direct TV has a package for $29.99 called the Family package; it only has the basics. But the Direct TV Choice package is comparable to the Starter Cable package. This package has more than 150 audio and video channels and is offered at $34.99 a month during the first year. Other packages include Choice Xtra and Premier packages, which are comparable to the Digital Preferred and Digital Premier, respectively. When the price of service is compared outside of the promotional periods, Comcast is up to $20 more.

If you do not want to be hassled with several bills from different companies offering internet, phone or cable, Comcast may be the better choice. However, if you want quality service for less, Direct TV is the provider of choice for you.


More by this Author

  • Cox Cable vs Direct TV
    2

    Comparison of Cox Cable and Direct TV satellite service. Get the basics before you commit to Cox or Direct TV by clicking here to find out what each has to offer...

  • Suddenlink Digital Cable
    1

    Review of Suddenlink digital cable television service. With more than a million customers spread across several states, Suddenlink is a full service provider, offering hundreds of cable TV networks

  • DIRECTV vs BrightHouse
    1

    Click here to read a comparison of DIRECTV satellite service vs BrightHouse cable. Both will offer you a full slate of cable channels, but there are other considerations such as high speed internet


Comments 7 comments

christopher 5 years ago

I think the equipment is what DISH stands out from both Comcast and DirecTV. Working at DISH Network I keep track of what all providers are offering, and all providers, cable and satellite have made some great technology releases in the last few years. There is of course the online access for one, integrating the internet into the cable box, and so forth. But Although all those options make it possible to watch TV content online, or on demand, the one piece of technology that stand out in my head is the Sling Adapter, available through DISH or through sling itself, the place shifting technology allows users to watch the TV they pay for, live, where ever they are, streamed to their mobile device or laptop.


kas 13 months ago

good research and information


meh 12 months ago

an updated review would be nice, Mr. Big Balls


Ceci 11 months ago

thanks for the info


tyo 8 months ago

This is quite good actually


RP 8 months ago

Any updates on this article


DB 4 months ago

This article is severely out of date at least for the DirecTV side as DirecTV was bought out by AT&T recently and now offers TV, Phone, Internet and Cell Phone bundle packages. I cannot speak for the Comcast side as it is not offered in my area so I have never had it.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Comcast or Direct TV

    If you have tried both providers, which do you prefer?

    • Direct TV
    • Comcast
    See results without voting
    Click to Rate This Article
    working