Emmys 2009: Predicting the Winners

Who is the most overdue for an Emmy win?

  • Steve Carell ("The Office")
  • Jon Cryer ("Two and a Half Men")
  • Michael Emerson ("Lost")
  • Hugh Laurie ("House, M.D.")
  • Sandra Oh ("Grey's Anatomy")
  • Mary-Louise Parker ("Weeds")
  • Elizabeth Perkins ("Weeds")
  • Kyra Sedgewick ("The Closer")
  • Charlie Sheen ("Two and a Half Men")
  • Vanessa Williams ("Ugly Betty")
  • Chandra Wilson ("Grey's Anatomy")
  • Rainn Wilson ("The Office")
  • other
See results without voting

Next Sunday (September 19), the Primetime Emmy Awards will take place. As is tradition with my family, we will all watch, and we will each attempt to guess who we think will when what in certain categories. Of all the awards shows my family and I participate in, the Emmys are by far the most interesting, because the winners are typically much harder to call. There is no way I can analyze everything (there are many, many, MANY categories in the Emmys), so I'm just narrowing my selection down to the things that should appear on television, including the guest acting spots.

But before I begin, I just want to get on my soapbox for a second and question why voters refused to nominate two of the best shows from this past television season: Friday Night Lights and The Shield. I haven't seen Battlestar Galactia yet (because I'm sure I'd include it), but both of the aforementioned programs embodied excellence, and they deserve much more than what they got.

Now with that out of the way, here are my predictions. . .

MAD MEN - Drama Series
MAD MEN - Drama Series
DAMAGES - Actress in a Drama (Glenn Close)
DAMAGES - Actress in a Drama (Glenn Close)
GREY'S ANATOMY - Supporting Actress in a Drama (Chandra Wilson)
GREY'S ANATOMY - Supporting Actress in a Drama (Chandra Wilson)
CSI: NY - Guest Actor in a Drama (Ed Asner)
CSI: NY - Guest Actor in a Drama (Ed Asner)
LAW & ORDER: SVU - Guest Actress in a Drama (Brenda Blethyn)
LAW & ORDER: SVU - Guest Actress in a Drama (Brenda Blethyn)
30 ROCK - Comedy Series
30 ROCK - Comedy Series
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER - Supporting Actor in a Comedy (Neil Patrick Harris)
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER - Supporting Actor in a Comedy (Neil Patrick Harris)
PUSHING DAISIES - Supporting Actress in a Comedy (Kristin Chenoweth)
PUSHING DAISIES - Supporting Actress in a Comedy (Kristin Chenoweth)
THE OFFICE - Directing for a Comedy
THE OFFICE - Directing for a Comedy
GREY GARDENS - Made for Television Movie
GREY GARDENS - Made for Television Movie
GENERATION KILL - Miniseries
GENERATION KILL - Miniseries
KING LEAR - Actor in a Miniseries or a Movie (Ian McKellen)
KING LEAR - Actor in a Miniseries or a Movie (Ian McKellen)
LITTLE DORRIT - Supporting Actor in a Miniseries or a Movie (Tom Courtenay)
LITTLE DORRIT - Supporting Actor in a Miniseries or a Movie (Tom Courtenay)
HOUSE OF SADDAM - Supporting Actress in a Miniseries or a Movie (Shohreh Aghdashloo)
HOUSE OF SADDAM - Supporting Actress in a Miniseries or a Movie (Shohreh Aghdashloo)
THE AMAZING RACE - Reality Competition Program
THE AMAZING RACE - Reality Competition Program
THE DAILY SHOW - Variety, Music or Comedy Series
THE DAILY SHOW - Variety, Music or Comedy Series

DRAMA SERIES: (Mad Men) ~ It's got too much momentum, too many nominations and too much good buzz not to repeat for a second year in a row.

LEAD ACTOR IN A DRAMA SERIES: (Bryan Cranston, Breaking Bad) ~ It's really ridiculous that Hugh Laurie has not won yet, but Cranston's character is complex and sympathetic, and that's hard not to reward.

LEAD ACTRESS IN A DRAMA SERIES: (Glenn Close, Damages) ~ Unless Kyra Sedgewick manages to get an amazing amount of surprise votes (and I doubt she will), this is Glenn's to lose, and she won't lose.

SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A DRAMA SERIES: (Michael Emerson, Lost) ~ Really, this should be Walton Goggins' trophy, but since he is decidedly absent, I do believe Mr. Emerson is worthy in his own right.

SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A DRAMA SERIES: (Chandra Wilson, Grey's Anatomy) ~ The only threat I see is last year's winner Dianne Wiest, and with two nominations this year, I think this is Chandra's best shot yet.

GUEST ACTOR IN A DRAMA SERIES: (Ed Asner, CSI: NY) ~ I thought Ernest Borgnine was fantastic in ER, but his screentime was short, and I just have a feeling Asner will ultimately take this one.

GUEST ACTRESS IN A DRAMA SERIES: (Brenda Blethyn, Law & Order: SVU) ~ It's between her and Ellen Burstyn, and from what I saw of Blethyn in a prison jumper, she's got the slight advantage.

DIRECTING FOR A DRAMA SERIES: (Mad Men, "The Jet Set") ~ I don't see the other nominees as competition at all, and it's the leading drama contender, so there you go.

WRITING FOR A DRAMA SERIES: (Mad Men, "Meditations in Emergency") ~ Let's see, 4 out of the 5 nominees here are from Mad Men, and many felt the finale was the best episode yet. Done deal? I think so.

COMEDY SERIES: (30 Rock) ~ The easiest award of the night to call. Everyone else, good night. Thanks for playing.

LEAD ACTOR IN A COMEDY SERIES: (Alec Baldwin, 30 Rock) ~ Personally, I'm ready for Steve Carell to win, but I think 30 Rock's got too much momentum in its favor.

LEAD ACTRESS IN A COMEDY SERIES: (Tina Fey, 30 Rock) ~ In addition to being on a very well-respected comedy, she's incredibly well-liked and respected herself. Toni Collette is a possible upset.

SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A COMEDY SERIES: (Neil Patrick Harris, How I Met Your Mother) ~ I don't think hosting hurts his chances at all. Rainn Wilson could win, too, but I think Neil's got this one.

SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A COMEDY SERIES: (Kristin Chenoweth, Pushing Daisies) ~ She should have won this last year. Plus, how cool would it be for last year's nomination presenters (Harris and Chenoweth) to win on the same night?

GUEST ACTOR IN A COMEDY SERIES: (Steve Martin, 30 Rock) ~ He should win for the way he said "That paint is drying. .weird" alone.

GUEST ACTRESS IN A COMEDY SERIES: (Tina Fey, Saturday Night Live) ~ I wouldn't mind if Jennifer Aniston won, but no one can deny how perfect Tina was as Sarah Palin.

DIRECTING FOR A COMEDY SERIES: (The Office, "Stress Relief") ~ I would think a consistently well-directed show like Flight of the Conchords would win, but everyone's saying this, so I will, too.

WRITING FOR A COMEDY SERIES: (30 Rock, "Apollo, Apollo") ~ Well, pretty sure it's gonna be 30 Rock. I don't have much clue as to which episode, so I'll just stick with this.

MADE FOR TELEVISION MOVIE: (Grey Gardens) ~ Should win quite handily, unless Prayers for Bobby is much more admired than I think.

MINISERIES: (Generation Kill) ~ This better win. It's one of the most engaging miniseries I've ever seen; better than Band of Brothers. Oh yeah, it is.

LEAD ACTOR IN A MINISERIES OR A MOVIE: (Ian McKellen, King Lear) ~ I'd love it if either Kevin Bacon or Brendan Gleeson won, but I think the respectability and the meaty performance of Sir Ian are too much to pass over.

LEAD ACTRESS IN A MINISERIES OR A MOVIE: (Sigourney Weaver, Prayers for Bobby) ~ I actually think Drew Barrymore stands a very good shot, but as soon as Prayers hit, unanimous buzz followed Sigourney, and it never went away.

SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A MINISERIES OR A MOVIE: (Tom Courtenay, Little Dorrit) ~ No idea. He was great in Doctor Zhivago (from 1965). Sounds good enough to me.

SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A MINISERIES OR A MOVIE: (Shohreh Aghdashloo, House of Saddam) ~ Great actress who probably should have won an Oscar in 2004. I don't think she has much competition here.

DIRECTING FOR A MINISERIES OR A MOVIE: (Generation Kill, "Bomb in the Garden") ~ War types seem like directing win shoo-ins, and this one's great. I'd be very surprised if it lost.

WRITING FOR A MINISERIES OR A MOVIE: (Grey Gardens) ~ I figure the love will be split between the top miniseries and the top movie, so here's where the other should prevail.

REALITY-COMPETITION PROGRAM: (The Amazing Race) ~ Second easiest category to call. This always seems to win. Always.

HOST FOR A REALITY-COMPETITION PROGRAM: (Tom Bergeron, Dancing with the Stars) ~ I know Jeff Probst won last year, but I have a feeling Dancing's host will walk away with the trophy this time.

VARIETY, MUSIC OR COMEDY SERIES: (The Daily Show with Jon Stewart) ~ This always wins, but I think any of the nominees could this year, particularly Saturday Night Live or Real Time with Bill Maher.

VARIETY, MUSIC OR COMEDY SPECIAL: (Kathy Griffin: She'll Cut a Bitch) ~ No idea. Kathy's won an Emmy before, and I think she's funny. The end.

SPECIAL CLASS PROGRAM: (81st Annual Academy Awards) ~ This is a new category, so I doubt anyone else knows for sure. With the big dance number and past nominees acknowledging new ones, I think the Oscars should be an Emmy winner.

More by this Author


Comments 2 comments

Kamini 7 years ago

We have similar predicts! My differences are:

Lead Actress, Drama: Kyra Sedgwick (I think it might be her year, although Glenn has the better tape.)

Supp. Actor, Drama: William Shatner (Goodbye win for Boston Legal)

Supp. Actress, Drama: Hope Davis (Just a hunch...plus In Treatment is baity as hell!)

Directing, Drama: Damages (Mad Men wasn't even nominated here last year and just like The Sopranos, I feel that they will struggle to win a Directing award for whatever weird reason. Damages has flashy direction, so I think it might win...if not, then Boston Legal).

Supp. Actress, Comedy: I would love for Kristin to win (especially after Pushing Daisies took home 3 Creative Arts Emmys this weekend) and I think there is a strong chance. This award though has gone to slightly older actresses though, so I think Elizabeth Perkins might suprise everyone and end up winning.

Lead Actor, Movie: Kevin Bacon (although, Ian McKellen's never won before, but its not a traditional tv performance, so not sure how they will feel about that).

Lead Actress, Movie: Drew Barrymore (there is a lot of love in Hollywood for her and I hope she wins, but you could very well be right about Sigourney though).

Lastly, I hope you're right about Shohreh Aghdashloo...the source of my Persian Pride in Hollywood, haha. Let's have an Iranian take home an Emmy win!!!

Overall, you have great predictions and we'll see what happens next SUNDAY!!!!!


Mandy 7 years ago

P.S. Have you watched DWTS? He's maybe my least favorite reality TV show host, and I watch a lot (too much) reality television! :) Let me know when you need input on those categories! ha

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working