Top Movie Directors-John Ford

Top Directors - John Ford

John Ford was born John Feeney on 1st February 1894. He was the son of Irish immigrants who lived in Cape Elizabeth, Maine.

He followed his brother Francis to Hollywood, just as California was taking over from New York as the centre of the film-making industry.

After a brief spell as an actor in his brother's directed movies; they swapped roles. John became a director, preferring a life behind the camera to one in front of it. Francis would do less directing but enjoy a prolific career as a bit-part actor, appearing in over 500 movies.

In this article, I will look at John Ford's career through a select number of movies rather than his entire canon, which is, to be honest, just too vast to cover in one article.

I hope movie buffs will forgive me this indulgence and I that I can still do justice to his talents in the movies I have chosen.

Orson Welles was once asked to name his top three directors and he responded thus; "That's easy, John Ford, John Ford and John Ford."

He admired John Ford so much that before making Citizen Kane, he watched Stagecoach (1939) 40 times in a row. He was looking at a classic to enable his own talents to develop from those of John Ford. The sincerest form of flattery is imitation.

Welles went on to direct one of the greatest movies of all time.

Great Director - John Ford
Great Director - John Ford
Henry Fonda, one of John Ford's favourite actors
Henry Fonda, one of John Ford's favourite actors
A still from The Grapes of Wrath
A still from The Grapes of Wrath

John Ford's The Grapes of Wrath

"Ain't you the preacher?"

"Not no more, I lost the spirit."

When Tom Joad (Henry Fonda) returns from prison, having served a sentence for manslaughter and happens upon the town preacher, Jim Casey (John Carradine) drinking by the side of the road, he knows immediately that things have changed in his home town since he's been away.

He finds his folks in a desperate state unable to grow crops after their land has become no more than a dustbowl due to drought.

Henry Fonda is young, lean and intense in the movie as we see him try to lead his folks to the promise of a life in California.

Along the way, we are party to the truly desperate sights of work camps set up to 'help' the disenfranchised, homeless of Oklahoma.

Will Tom be able to leave his past and discover a better life in the West?

The movie is one of John Ford's collaborations with his cinematographer Greg Toland so on the one hand we have this amazing expanse in the scenery, backgrounds and vistas but in the foreground we have Ford's characters with Ford's directing at its best, there with the people telling us their stories.

John Ford's conservatism in sharp relief to Toland's vast countrysides.

Isn't that why we love John Ford's movies though?

Does he do Steinbeck's novel justice?

Well, he tells the story in a cinematic way without punching any of his own idealism on the movie. It is a story about workers rights, poverty, respect and freedom - he tells it.

Walter Pidgeon
Walter Pidgeon | Source
Maureen O'Hara
Maureen O'Hara | Source

How Green Was My Valley

John Ford did have a bit of a reputation for being sentimental (on screen anyway!) and this movie can be sentimental at times but Ford took a wonderful novel by Richard Llewelyn and told its story on screen in just the way it was intended.

The story of a Welsh coal mining family living in a small mining village has all of Ford's masterful direction and cinematography again. He has to cover 50 years in the family's life and he does this by concentrating on the growing up of the youngest member of the family as we see unionisation, mine safety, war and the family's highs and lows throughout the movie. Ford gives us How Green Was My Valley like a photograph of the novel. He is true to all of its aspects and the movie beat Citizen Kane to the Best Movie Oscar.

Why? Because the watching public like to see how a family survives through life's events. We are all nostalgic for parts of our own past - How Green Was My Valley made audiences feel warm inside. Ford gave us beautiful Welsh valleys, grimy Welsh pitheads but most of all, as in all of his movies, he gave us people and all of their strife and triumph. This is a big part of his magic.

John Wayne and Robert Montgomery
John Wayne and Robert Montgomery | Source
John Wayne in uniform (but never in real life)
John Wayne in uniform (but never in real life) | Source
Robert Montgomery
Robert Montgomery | Source

They Were Expendable

John Ford had just returned from active service himself when he was asked to direct the movie. He jumped at the chance, wanting to show some realism in the movie. At the time it was released in December, 1945, the US public had had enough of war movies and this tale of men frustrated by their inability to win because they were horribly outnumbered was out of step with the victorious mood in a now post-war United States.

John Ford worked with cinematographer John H August and although shot in black and white, the movie has a very fluid energy with the ocean, sun and on land shots all given equal artistry by August. The shots of the PT boats in the water are tremendous and this is an exciting movie because of the reality of those shots.

John Ford stuck to his guns in making a human story; John Wayne's frustrated sailor wanting to see battle always in conflict with his commanding officer played by Robert Mongomery.

Montgomery worked very closely with Ford to get the action just right. He had also just returned from serving in World War II. Ford respected Montgomery's contribution and listended intently when Montgomery made suggestions for his role.

John Wayne did not join up during WWII and John Ford was often critical of Wayne in this matter. The movie credited all of the actors with their rank in the armed forces. Wayne's stuck out like a sore thumb because he had no rank. Montgomery on the other hand had seen a lot of active service.

The movie has all of Ford's trademarks - great actors filmed at close enough quarters for us to see their eyes (he really believed all stories were told through actors' eyes, regularly filming from below or above actors to gain an insight into their thoughts), wonderful human stories- Wayne and Donna Reed fall in love but it is far from perfect, conflict is always there between Montgomery and Wayne and we have amazing action sequences with the PT boats ripping through the water protecting the Phillipines (actually shot in Florida).

The cinematography and direction are superlative and the movie didn't really become popular until years after it was made. It is thought that Stephen Spielberg was influenced by They Were Expendable and Battle of Midway when creating the opening sequences of Saving Private Ryan.


Poster for John Ford's Fort Apache
Poster for John Ford's Fort Apache
Poster for John Ford's She Wore A Yellow Ribbon
Poster for John Ford's She Wore A Yellow Ribbon

'Fort Apache' & 'She Wore A Yellow Ribbon'

The first and third of John Ford's cavalry trilogy, these two movies see him at his cinematic best in two movies with men in uniforms but with a Western theme.

John Ford has two of his favourite actors, Henry Fonda and John Wayne pitched against one another in a tale of the glory and sanctity of the US Armed Forces.

Ford put his own views on show too in regard to his belief in the mistreatment of the Indians and especially in the way they are portrayed in history books.

Fonda is brilliant as Thursday, a cavalry commander in charge of everyone and everything in his life; a man who believes in class distinctions and loses many of his men in battle because he is too stubborn to listen to Captain York (John Wayne).

Wayne is, as always the best cowboy there's ever been and he even pulls this off in cavalry twill.

She Wore A Yellow Ribbon

Award-winning photography by Winston C Koch in glorious technicolor gives She Wore A Yellow Ribbon an immediate appeal and John Wayne's acting is also rather good as Captain Brittles, a cavalry officer who leaves his fort to make peace with the indians at their reservation and in so doing, gains his men's respect.

Sounds unexciting but it is another of John Ford's looks at human nature in a historic context.

What John Ford always seems to achieve is an understated realism; telling the story through the eyes again.

When Wayne's men honour him upon his retirement with a pocket watch, he readjusts his spectacles to read the inscription and Ford lets us see Wayne's tear filled eyes and feel his emotions just for that moment when he feels both proud of his career and sentimental for his guys.

I defy anyone not to get a lump in their throat at that scene.

The third part of the trilogy, Rio Bravo is another Wayne movie, also successful.

Beautiful, red-haired and Irish, Maureen O'Hara
Beautiful, red-haired and Irish, Maureen O'Hara
Wayne and O'Hara
Wayne and O'Hara | Source

The Quiet Man

She Wore A Yellow Ribbon had its fair share of sentimentality but in general, it was a story of a man being principled in the name of peace whilst wearing a cavalryman's uniform.

In The Quiet Man, John Ford gives us his favourite actor and actress in the same movie; John Wayne and Maureen O'Hara.

The movie is a sentimental tale of an Irishman, boxer Sean Thornton returning to his hometown after killing a man in the ring so straight away, the audience is rooting for this man, hoping he will find his way back to a good life from the hell going around in his head.

He buys the cottage in which he was born, incurring the wrath of local man Red Will Danaher but is then at odds with Danaher's sister, Mary-Kate , played in true redhaired and angry Irish style by Maureen O'Hara.

The countryside is like another character in the movie and beautifully shot by John Ford in one of his best movies.

Irish director, Neil Jordan has called The Quiet Man 'a cliche of Ireland' but we forgive John Ford anyway. John Wayne revels in one of his most physical roles and the boxing ring scenes are second to none, John Ford at his best.

John Wayne is such a likeable character that it is inevitable that he will eventually get the girl but John Ford takes us through the torture of Wayne's torment, his redemption through his desire for O'Hara (though she puts up a good fight) and his conflict with Walter McLaglen is always there in the background to keep us on the edge of our seats.

I never get tired of this film, my favourite lazy Sunday afternoon movie.

John Ford's amazing framing - John Wayne with Monument Valley in the distance.
John Ford's amazing framing - John Wayne with Monument Valley in the distance.
John Wayne in The Searchers
John Wayne in The Searchers
Natalie Wood with there Indian husband.
Natalie Wood with there Indian husband.
Ford behind the camera, pipe in hand.
Ford behind the camera, pipe in hand.

The Searchers

And finally....I bring you to The Searchers, arguably John Ford's greatest movie.

John Wayne, once again plays a troubled former soldier, Ethan Edwards, returning to the bosom of his family with his own secrets safely stored in his mind and his stolen Yankee gold.

John Ford certainly seemed to revel in movies with flawed heroes and there are none more flawed than Edwards.

The Searchers would spawn lots of imitators in the sixties and seventies but it stands alone as the ultimate redemption movie - a man in search of his niece but also in search of himself.

We will watch the whole tale from the edge of our seats as once again Wayne gets in the saddle and takes on the Indians but he won't find his way back from the man he has become this time.

Ford imbues The Searchers with a historical realism where no punches are pulled - this time the ending of the movie is ambiguous, Ethan saves the girl but not himself.

Of course, that's never enough for John Ford. In The Searchers we get to see him be puppet master of Wayne's tormented Ethan, trapped inside his own head, a man who despises the Comanches but even in saving his niece considers taking her life because she is not 'white', the influence of the Indians on her has been so pervasive.

John Wayne was unafraid to play Ethan Edwards in an unheroic, deeply flawed way. He is a man difficult to like, an anti-hero but Ford is always in charge of the outcome in this movie.

The beautiful Monument Valley is the backdrop for much of the film but Ford uses amazing character framing to remind us that in this place, man is dwarfed by his landscapes and Ethan Edwards is a man both at home here but also lost.

Wayne's portrayal is amazing testament to his often underrated acting talents.

You will dislike this man thoroughly but you will understand how his own experiences, in life, in the civil war, in the pursuit west, in his hatred of the indians and in fighting off his enemies has shapes his life.

The Searchers is a brilliant movie and John Ford was a top movie director. Perhaps his talents have yet to be bettered?

Many thanks for reading.

More by this Author


Great Film Directors-John Ford Comments 10 comments

Jools99 profile image

Jools99 5 years ago from North-East UK Author

Cheers Rob, thanks for your comments. Ford and Wayne had an interesting relationship; they both respected one another's work but didn't always see eye to eye. Wayne was famously a life-long, staunch republican whilst Ford was a liberal democrat. In political matters, they agreed to disagree! Ford was also upset that Wayne didn't sign up during WWII.


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 5 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY

Hi Jools; Great tribute to one of the greatest directors ever. I'd put him in the top 5 of all time. My favorite films of his were "My Darling Clementine" with Henry Fonda, and "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance" with John Wayne and James Stewart. Great stuff.

I read that when John Wayne directed his first film, "the Alamo", John Ford was on set to make sure everything went OK for Wayne, but Wayne was intimidated by having his mentor around while he was trying to direct.

Excellent hub. well done.

Rob


Jools99 profile image

Jools99 5 years ago from North-East UK Author

Flora, thanks for your comments. How Green Was My Valley is close to my heart because my ancestors hail from a mining town in North Wales, though I suspect the movie doesn't do justice to the real level of poverty and hardship. I do quite like Westerns and war movies so with Ford, I'm spoilt for choice.


Jools99 profile image

Jools99 5 years ago from North-East UK Author

Laura, thanks for commenting. If you do get the chance to see the others, try to watch them in chronological order, The Searchers should be seen last of these for a better understanding of Ford's developing talents.


Jools99 profile image

Jools99 5 years ago from North-East UK Author

Steve, thanks for your comments. Of the ones omitted that you mention, I almost included The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance which is a personal favourite but I worried that it would become a hub just about that movie so I stayed away.


Jools99 profile image

Jools99 5 years ago from North-East UK Author

Cogerson, thank you for your comments. I also love The Quiet Men but have only ever seen it on TV or VHS. A link would be much appreciated so thanks for that! I look forward to reading your hub when it's ready.


FloraBreenRobison profile image

FloraBreenRobison 5 years ago

Of the films you discuss in detail, I am most familiar with How Green Was My Valley and it is my favourite of those discussed. I normally do not watch westerns or war films. However, I am a Robert Montgomery fan so I've seen They Were Expendable. I've also seen the Grapes of Wrath and The Quiet man.


laurathegentleman profile image

laurathegentleman 5 years ago from Chapel Hill, NC

This is a wonderful Hub! I love old movies, and the only one of these that I've seen is The Grapes of Wrath, but I loved to read about the others!

Voted up, up, and away! :)


Steve Lensman profile image

Steve Lensman 5 years ago from London, England

Another great director hub Jools, good work.

The one I'm least familiar with is How Green was My Valley, I watched it once a long time ago.

The Searchers is my favourite Wayne western. Great film and like you say John Wayne was underrated. I remember reading when John Ford saw John Wayne in Howard Hawks Red River he was quoted as saying "I never knew the son of a bitch can act!" :)

Three of my favourites missing from your list are Stagecoach, My Darling Clementine and The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. All superb westerns.

Voted Up.


Cogerson profile image

Cogerson 5 years ago from Virginia

Excellent hub. Great selection of some Ford's best films. Of the ones you wrote about I would say that The Quiet Man is easily my favorite. It needs to be on Blu-Ray as the DVD copies out there are horrible. I liked the quote from Orson Wells that you included. Voted up and awesome and I will be sure to link this hub to a John Ford hub that I have been researching whenever I write that hub.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working