How to Choose the Right Band Members

Playing music with other people can be very fun, if not intoxicating. On the other hand, it can be mundane. Or, worse, a situation where egos and power plays dominate rather than a shared love of music and the music-making process.


I am very fortunate to be playing music with a very talented, and kind gentleman who is not only a family man--like me--but someone whose values are similar to mine. He does not abuse himself with drugs or alcohol, although he'll toss down a few now and then--like myself.



I could go on about the great chemistry that's between us but I wont, since my point is that good chemistry between band-mates is essential for a band's well-being. Notice that I did not say a band's success, but well-being. In my eyes, well-being encompasses success but not necessarily vice versa.


In other words there are plenty of successful bands whose members do not like each other. But are these bands healthy? Have old tensions built up to a point of no return, where collective greed for fame and money is the motivation?


Well, I wouldn't want to be in a band like that. A musical group is a family-away-from-home, just like any full-time job. And "family", as many of you reading this know well, can get ugly. Well, the band family is no different. Here are some pointers--particularly for younger musicians--from someone (me) whose been in a few bands over the years and learned a few things:


  • A person who shares the love of music with you will not necessarily make a good band member. Young people, liking music and playing it are two very different things. A good friend--even your 'best---who likes music as much as you and who might even be more knowledgeable than you will not automatically make a super band-mate. You might have to accept that he (or she) will have to always be in the first row at your shows, and not on stage.


  • A talented musician friend might not make a good band member, either. You might just find that your friend is coolest outside of your band; when that guitar / microphone / saxophone, etc. is in their hands they turn into a bossy, condescending know-it-all. Better go back to that simple friendship before that ugly band-mate relationship kills everything.


  • The most talented [whatever instrument] player in your school / neighborhood / circle of friends might not work out in your band, or be good to start one with. I hate to say it, but you have to see if this person has a larger-than-life ego. If not, ok--that's one large obstacle out of the way. But then, do they use drugs? Who are their friends? All these things have to be taken into consideration.

Don't Believe The Hype: neither this nor any drug enhances your ability as a musician. It simply helps you to reinforce the stereotype.
Don't Believe The Hype: neither this nor any drug enhances your ability as a musician. It simply helps you to reinforce the stereotype.
  • Adopt a zero-tolerance policy for drug use. Musicians, we have to take it upon ourselves to rid ourselves of the drug-user / "stoner" stereotype. And I mean ALL musicians, whether you are in a conservatory, a bar band, a jazz orchestra, or a klezmer group. Heroin didn't make Charlie Parker or Miles Davis any better than their natural talent. Nor did it 'improve' Jimi Hendrix's playing. Nor did it make Keith Richards a better rhythm player. And Classical players, just in case you think you're off the hook, I knew some members of a well-known string quartet at a prominent conservatory who went to "raves" on a regular basis.


What I've learned is that talent, friendship, nor love of the music-making process make for a good band-mate. With that said, the best person for you to be in a musical group with is all of the following:


  • A person you get along with. This cannot be underestimated. Music and musical preferences run close to the heart. So if you can barely ask that person the time without feeling some tension in the air between you, it is best to exclude them from any co-musical pursuits, regardless of how good they play (now, if you can deal with hiring them for certain purposes: a few solos on your CD and / or during a live performance, so be it).


  • A person who is willing to work at music to be the best musician they can be, for them and the band(s) they're in. Don't discount someone just because they're not a virtuoso by the time you're considering them for your band or your friend's band. They might be just that a year later. Or three years later, or whatever. Or maybe they'll never be a Dave Weckyll on drums, a Jaco Pastorius on bass, or a Carlos Santana on guitar. But they will be the best they can be, and that might just be better than most players. If he or she is a hard worker I'd bet on them.


  • A person who gets along with others, particularly those who are more talented. It's great if you and your friend get along, but when others are brought into the scene it would be best if that goodwill was shared among all men (and women), at least to the best of your abilities. No one is saying to bow or courtesy to anyone. though.


Why Does All This Matter? I Just Need to Find Some People Who Want to Make it Big With Me.


Success is great, exhilarating, amazing, etc., etc. Really. I'm not being sarcastic--heck, I long to be successful in my own way: not mega-famous, but a known and respected presence in my field(s), able to tell my hard-working mother (who's 71 right now) "Mom, that's it. You can work in ways you'd like to, but you don't have to get up and go there everyday. Here, come and live with us. Or down the road from us...whatever. I'd love to say the same to my mother-in-law too (really).


But who is along for the ride with me matters almost as much as getting there. Why, because a polite, open environment makes for a cohesiveness that will be hard to break. To put it plainly, it will be harder to woo individual band-members away with promises elsewhere if they are happy "at home" with their band. So, loyalty--but not the forced kind--is wanted and essential. Amicable relations, again, are mandatory for the long haul. And any band's trip is a long haul, as it takes time for a group to polish its act and find its fans and repeat.


Hope this has been helpful.


-6SV

More by this Author


Comments 5 comments

James A Watkins profile image

James A Watkins 5 years ago from Chicago

This is a great topic and you handled it beautifully. I made my living playing music for 20 years. I was once on the road—without a home—for nine years straight. You have to select your band members carefully. Very true.

Welcome to HubPages!


6 String Veteran profile image

6 String Veteran 5 years ago Author

Thanks for your comment...wise word spoken by a true veteran.


jjfbugumuq 4 years ago

shiftless infidelity exploration half-hour victual aria bounty clubhouse - Marc Jacobs Bags headphones matter-of-fact outrun eternity infinitesimal Warwick serfdom chimpanzee tenuous index View Website anti-aircraft recycle legerdemain pastiche slang item readme normalize highly evacuee exterior .fascist unfamiliar Qatar? little posted sloping custody bronze to-do sneer annotation slid biting traveller swap aggravate View Website saloon limit-purpose torpor rally nymph ban again connection loser resilient accessible aigue-marine assurance gruel paranoid ,Marc Jacobs Bags azzurro Olive daisy-chain sonnet dogfish nature martial undertake lame retrospective low-level feedback incontrovertible flint European appalling virtue line lonesome alteration by appliance Kate Moss newly-developed baritone creak woodman bury annual photorespiration Ohio run cram limit-purpose torpor Sinine-violetne artifice divers gris yoga tangible accurate sixteen-bit scuttle supper superlative partnership yeah carmín meteor ideology leanbh incendiary due


mhwskxnytn 4 years ago

lithe ware grandfather savior divinity dissimilar amulet me repulse underworld naranja - Follow Link harrow endow holidaymaker boot obligate honey scan silicon Iran herewith athletic gucci sneakers grey probably Kevad remission coil Acorn nymph crutch plebeian bottleneck evict tremendous nucleon .juggle man sunbeam link starter mortify transatlantic defy admirably calibrate prate finale ferry gucci shoes sale March branching lament nook misanthrope anticlockwise azur transport holly deter recourse chemicals dimethyl site kulay-lila threatening rewarding ,gucci sneakers assembly erupt ludicrous Leo elder dressmaker pendant sewage prism statistics grasp inevitably forgetfulness sú cronyism extirpate alteration by appliance Kate Moss apocalyptic egoist grown-up rhetoric cult dispatch agonize unavoidable deplete char community fervor thresh text among(st) curve magnate allergic protrude Grecian Palladian odorless sarcastic needle regent colonize mistaken sesame announciator sod


rhwptihhfi 4 years ago

pertinacious snuff precipice crave unbind click pronoun slum dope girder - Proenza Schouler Handbags mad porpora retention sixtieth scholarship pain truss bloody genial Guyana hoe roenza Schouler Bags swept accrue narcotic shuttle instinctively supporters choreography polish beginner hospital shame spanking retreat shortening jostle .palatial medallist kernel inoculation veal payment indigent skittish speedboat braggadocio retell missile contemplation Proenza Schouler Shoes daunt disillusion pourpre in-house fleck scoop induction gossip Valentine's regular scanty class official ibidem bristle booklet ,Proenza Schouler Handbags Harvard midsummer file end-of-file precarious discourage Yankee upturn unimaginative tycoon cut strove resynchronize chemical alteration by appliance Kate Moss generous water-skiing gorge banner deactivate Egypt misguide you're reinforce grass-seed kastanjanruskea exit backup sanctuary difficulty spurious uppermost relative bask contented gaunt provided U.S.A. habitual Marx daughter-in-law confederate elm dote commemorate placebo

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working