Movie review: How I Live Now

After The Last King of Scotland picked up an Oscar in 2006 for Forest Whitaker's incredible performance as Idi Amin, its director, Scot Kevin MacDonald, has been struggling to find a rhythm in mainstream filmmaking.

Since then he's only directed 2009's State of Play and 2011's The Eagle, neither of which were more than average.

Can having one of the coolest and impressive talents around, in the shape of Irish actress Saoirse Ronan, star in his latest film How I Live Now, strike a more positive note with audiences?

Elizabeth (Ronan) is a fine example of a troubled teen, but she does have her reasons; she's been sent by her dad in the USA to spend the summer with his sister Penn (Anna Chancellor) and her three children, Edmund (George MacKay), Isaac (Tom Holland) and piper (Harley Bird).

As soon as she arrives she points out to 14-year-old Isaac (who has been sent to pick her up on his own in the Land Rover) that she doesn’t want to be referred to as Elizabeth, but Daisy. She also makes it perfectly clear that she has no intention of either having fun or being fun for her duration.

Back at the countryside retreat, she only has the briefest of chats with her Aunt, before she flies off to Geneva with work; she's a high profile analyst and is needed due the current political climate.

With her away, Daisy and her cousins are on their own until the au pair shows. But the au pair never arrives, as the country is suddenly the target of a nuclear attack. The youngsters soon find themselves having to deal with coping with war, on their own grassy door step.

It's fair to say that McDonald has a good eye for making the British countryside look pretty. What he lacks however, is the ability to create any sense of drama. The premise certainly doesn't help. Sure, the notion of a group of kids learning how to cope with a nuclear attack sounds like perfect fodder for a drama, but it's just not the case here. Instead McDonald manages to make the outbreak of war nothing more than an inconvenience for a far too predictable love story to flourish between kissing cousins Daisy and Edmund.

Imagine 28 days Later without the zombies, and you pretty much have How I Live Now. The first half of the film sees Ronan moping like your clichéd teenager. The second half of the film sees her wandering around various foliage in the hopes of not being spotted by the military or locals. Her motivation is love, but the relationship takes off so quickly it's difficult to take Daisy all that seriously.

You'd also have to be concerned about her father's judgement; the film offers no news as to whether the USA is involved or not, so it looks that Daisy's dad has sent his daughter to a country on high terrorist alert for the summer, which doesn't seem that responsible. Mind you, she is an annoying teen.

If you accept the fact that the central relationship is a bit too flaky, the rest of the film's story soon comes tumbling down.

McDonald gets some sweet performances from his young cast, but that's about it. His film lacks pace, drive and most importantly, a reason to watch it from beginning to end without going AWOL.

3 booms

More by this Author


Comments 2 comments

KarinthiaCeres profile image

KarinthiaCeres 3 years ago

It seems like your describing the book almost to a T. I was hoping the movie would be a better adaption and more interesting. I will still watch it to compare the 2 but after your review I am happy I didn't spend money to see it in theaters.


Boomuk profile image

Boomuk 3 years ago from London, UK Author

It is a little disappointing, particularly when you consider the director and Ronan, who is one of the most diverse talents in Hollywood at the moment. Good decision to wait until its home release. Let us know what you think of it when you do see it though, and how it compares to the book, as we'd be interested in your opinion.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working