Movie review: Saving Mr Banks

One of the things that the film Mary Poppins is most know for these days is the dreadful job Dick Van Dyke does with a London accent; whenever he opens his mouth it's as if it's where vowels go to die a horrible death. But back in 1964 it was a very big deal for Walt Disney.

Not only did it win an impressive five Oscars, it was nominated for thirteen in total. It was also a big hit with audiences, and therefore the box office, with its eventual takings hitting well over the hundred million dollars mark. No need for a spoonful of sugar there.

All this would have been music to Walt's ears, especially when you consider how difficult it was to get Mary Poppins off the ground in the first place.

When his children were growing up Walt Disney (Tom Hanks) was constantly told by them how wonderful the book Mary Poppins was. He agreed and loved it so much that he wanted to make a film version. So he wrote a letter to its author Mrs P.L Travers (Emma Thompson), asking for the rights. She turned him down.

He then wrote to her the following year. She turned him down. And then the year after, and the year after that. Undeterred, Disney continued asking for over eighteen years, until Travers finally succumbed and said yes.

This would have been a time to rejoice, but it came with a hefty caveat – she would have final approval on everything, otherwise the rights would remain hers. Amazingly, Disney accepted her terms. He then flew her over to Hollywood; if he thought that the last eighteen years had been tough, nothing could prepare him or his creative team for the incredibly hard, uphill struggle ahead of them with the belligerent Travers at the peak of it.

As this film comes from the House of Mouse, you were only ever going to get one side of Walt Disney. The caring, charming, productive genius behind all things Disney. As you would expect, Hanks can pull this kind of role off in his sleep. He makes it look all so effortless, but that should belie his performance.

He couldn't do what he does without Thompson acting as the perfect foil; Her Travers is a no-nonsense kind of woman, who not only expects things done a certain way – her own – she expects all those around to confirm to her expectations too. Again, Thompson has had so much practice with characters with this kind of make-up that it could hardly have been a stretch for her. Still, the scenes in which the pair are together are easily the best.

Unfortunately, a secondary story isn't so much weaved into proceedings but brutally crow-barred. It concerns the relationship Travers had with her father Robert (Colin Farrell) back in her native Australia as a child. It would have worked as one brief flashback, but sadly director John Lee Hancock (who also directed the insipid Oscar winner The Blind Side), uses far too many pointless flashbacks as a crutch for his film. In doing so, it doesn't just break the rhythm created by Hanks and Thompson, it almost brings proceedings to a standstill. Hancock should give the audience a little more credit; we get it, her dad screwed her up – move on already!

These scenes don't just ruin the relationship of the central characters, it takes a very positive shine off of the whole film. Paul Giammati 's Driving Miss Travers sub-story is incredibly sweet, and the scenes that feature Jason Schwartzman, B.J. Novak and Bradley Whitford as the Disney creative posse, bring a nice line of gentle humour to proceedings. All slightly ruined by far too many Outback flashbacks.

It's a surprise and disappointment that given the talent at his disposal, and a compelling enough story as it is surrounding Disney and Travers, Hancock was compelled to devote so much of the film to a dull and irritating non-plot plot.

Saving Mr Banks had real potential, possibly even worthy of a golden statue or two like Mary Poppins itself, but by losing its focus, prevents it from being truly supercalifragilisticexpialidocious.

3 booms

More by this Author


Comments

No comments yet.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working