Which is better,Star Trek or Star Wars?
This is deadly serious
Forget your football rivalries, forget petty party political differences of are they too left wing? or are their policies too draconian. As a fan of both Sci-Fi television/movie program I am about to open the Pandora`s box of debates " Which in my opinion is better Star Wars or Star Trek?"- This is a subject I have not taken lightly ( okay a bit lightly) and i am sure I will receive abuse back about this(its all feedback!!). Which TV show is the king of space based escapism, Is the light sabre mightier than the phaser. Well as fan I have devised a series of tests to show which show format is the worthy master of the genre. And for the record this hub came about due to a few too many beers after work!
DISCLAIMER : These shows are fiction until proved otherwise!
Now I was born in 1978 and my early memories of childhood involved the Christmas holidays and watching either Star Wars or Star Trek at some stage of the festivities. I was the typical 1980`s child with X-wing models, Several Luke Skywalker figures and a box full of the special edition figures that you had to send the tokens off for!( I had a nice collection of figures, until my younger brother bit their heads off and buried them in the back garden) As I hit my teenage years I found myself drawn and almost obsessed with the Star Trek :Next Generation. Before then the only Star Trek I had really seen was the motion pictures and re-runs of the 1960`s series. So comparing Star Wars to the original Star Trek is like comparing a model T-Ford to a DB9! Do not fear or worry I have made allowances.
I have decided to judge the series on the whole franchise, so I will take into account Jar Jar Binks annoyingness and the strings on the 1960`s special effects. At the moment with our CGI and other fancy tricks I think its almost refreshing and amusing.
Right then how shall I score this? I think as a percentage of the subtopics and then averaging out the score at the end, this seems fair to me so lets begin!
Battle One- Ships
The big kid in me always dreamed of owning or piloting the X-Wing fighter from Episode IV: New Hope. As a proud Englishman they are like the Spitfires of the future, In my eyes they are still awesome, it is the Rebel Alliance`s ace in the hole and in my opinion I speculate a vastly better fighter than the Empires Tie-Fighter. If I was judging Star Wars on one ship its X-wing 100% but I have to take off marks for the following ships in the Star Wars universe. Millennium Falcon as it would fail any space M.O.T and the Imperial Destroyers could have had a lot more destructive power. Also the Death Star although a lethal moon-sized ship and scary, was let down by silly oversights in its architecture. SCORE 85%
Now Star Trek has a lot more ships within its universe but I struggle to see anything which is similar to the X-Wing. At a push the Borg/Federation fusion of the Delta Flyer from Voyager, but it would not be a fair comparison. Of course the Star Trek universe has the legendary USS Enterprise running through its history, although it has been destroyed more than the Death Star. Still as flagship of the Federation it should be feared and respected. The best ship in the Star Trek universe for me is the USS Defiant, a robust and dangerous ship than in honesty would win a fight against bigger ships in either franchise. The Defiant was destroyed once by Breen weaponry in the DS9 series. It survived assaults by the Borg in First Contact and is maybe the most offensive ship in Starfleet's armoury. The USS Defiant with its durability and the Romulan loaned Cloak may well sway the contest to Star Trek??? SCORE 90%
The best ship?
Would you rather have....See results without voting
Battle Two- Villains
Not that difficult to say who the real villains in the Star Trek universe currently are , there have been so many to choose from, although some villains evolve into friends in later series. I think the Borg are the ultimate Bad guy as they represent losing ones individuality. These cybernetic aliens have become a constant threat to the Federation and they can supply limitless resources against their prey as they seek to assimilate the universe. They look on space as their empire, as they believe all will fall to the hive mind. They have tough heavily shielded and adaptive ships, superior strength by augmentation and have knowledge and technologies that can bring down civilizations. The Borg alone are a frightening opponent and if you add into the mix the Imperial and focused Romulans, The Warriors of the Jem Hadar, The cunning of the Cardassians and the Klingon warriors ethic. It is fair to say that all Star Trek villains offer a challenge. I have omitted including the Q continuum in this section as I believe they are not truly comparable to anything most science fiction shows have. Essentially they are as powerful as gods, having the ability to shape the universe to their ideal instantly. If the Federation every went to war with the Q, the Federation would be wiped from existence and history before you could get a phaser lock.
SCORE 90% ( If we include the Ferengi recalculated score is ....)
The Star Wars villains are harder to pin down, I suppose the Emperor, Darth Vader and other Sith lords, are the main threat. Using the darker side of the force they can reap ruin and destruction across the galaxy. The Emperors use of his lightening and other dark powers is very effective, combine this with his henchmen Darth Vader and his legions of cloned Stormtroopers any opponent would be in trouble. Also let us not forget the Hutt`s and the bounty hunters who are devious, professional and lethal
SCORE 92% ( Removed 3% for the silly droids saying "Roger Roger" in Phantom Menace)
Which is the best adversarySee results without voting
Battle Three- Light Sabers vs Hand Weapons
Okay this might be a bit unfair, every boy born after 1974 must have put on his Christmas wish list to Father Christmas a Light saber! It didn't matter what colour it was back then it really didn't matter. Personally I would go for for a Silver Light saber and if I was greedy I would want two light sabers.
I can remember a news story when Phantom Menace first came out in the UK Cinemas. Two fans made their own Light sabers by lighting petrol in strip lights, really stupid it didn't work out well and they got burnt pretty bad.
The Federation issue Phaser, The Romulan disruptor, The Klingon Ba`leth and any other weapon in the universe are good but not in the same league as a light saber.
Ok just tallied up the scores and Star Trek got an average Of 85% and Star Wars recieved an average of 92%. So in my opinion Star Wars is superior but I love them both as I am at heart a Sci-Fi nerd
Which is Better??See results without voting
Same but different
- Collectables versus Children
The other day i found my vintage x-wing fighter on the bedroom floor with the wing turrets pulled off and the cockpit pulled out. So the curse of my Starwars figures continues, back in the 1980's it was my...
- Vintage Starwars figures Part 1
When looking to purchase a vintage Starwars figure you are best buying from a site such as Ebay or Amazon, these sites offer you protection and lessen the chance of you been scammed by unscrupulous sellers....
- Warriors: Spartan versus Legionnaire
The Deadliest Warrior television programme was an enjoyable and interesting piece of entertainment. I really enjoyed the way the programme was set up and the scientific approach was really well thought out...
More by this Author
The moral code of the Viking warrior, dictated how he behaved on and off the battlefield. A true warrior valued his honour and morals as much as he valued his victory.
Had the combined Greek force not stood at the Hot Gates to draw a line in the sand against the Persian invasion. What would have happened if they did not stand?
The Knight's Templar were the guardians of untold riches gathered from their time protecting the Christian pilgrims. Could their relics have been moved away by the Templar naval fleet at La Rochelle?