Reality TV - An Opposing Viewpoint

I submit that Reality TV has hijacked its “15 minutes of fame” and stretched far beyond our actual collective consent for nearly 25 years!

Besides making astornomical profits for media giants and advertising executives what other intrinsic value is there in Reality TV?

Just to be clear this discussion centers on the mostly negative variety of the genre.

Understandably, this kind of programming is strangely compelling and certainly temping to watch.

There is no doubt of the “sizzle” of a house full of strangers now “ roommates” arguing, getting in each other’s face, and even throwing blows!

Somehow this “ unpredictability ” of what’s going to happen next seems to captivate us. We are drawn in by its seductive grip and find ourselves forming a habit that is hard to break. In essense this formula is similar to the phenomenon of when we intently watch the aftermath of a terrible automobile accident except without the general concern we have for those involved.

Next up are our classic baby mama dramas, hate spewing cursing and fighting couples, and grandiose displays of poorly educated rebelling people in our society.

Then we have the competitions where “ aspiring hopefuls ” sing or dance to earn our text message votes. After that we learn to be prosecutor and defender as we tune into the judge shows.

Over the last couple of years we’ve hit all time lows with those self proclaimed super “celebrities” of New Jersey shore and step children of a former Olympic Champion Decathlete who tantilize us by being the next in line " Diva" sisters of fashion and hollywood glitz and glamour!

If that’s not enough rag tag crews scurry behind surprised cheating partners as they attempt to give couples their “moment of resolution” live on the street!

Again from a business standpoint we certainly understand the business model. There is no doubt that these are huge financial winners and even in some cases the participants are able to earn a windfall or even launch a career. In the case of the latter, there is some argument of benefit however our dialogue hinges on the value and return on the system as a whole.

We as consumers are giving the content creators and image marketers an easy road to follow. Because viewers continue to give these types of shows enormous ratings it essentially gives the industry a green light to feed us cheap and dumb downed productions that cater to our most base and primal instincts.

Do we not long for thoughtful and intellectually stimulating programming that challenge us to rise to our greater good?

Its high time Hollywood and other major producers of content for television rediscover the immeasurable value and benefit of positive shows that inspire, educate and challenge our society for the better.

Many may brush this suggestion off as being naïve and without plausible cause. To this I would only answer by saying take a look back in history and observe what television was like 50 years ago.

Certainly it was a more basic presentation and less aesthetically pleasing than today’s standards. However, that observation is secondary to the intent and purpose of its quality and production.

During those days, just like today advertisers and corporations were very much interested in profits. Not only was making money a priority as it is today, they enjoyed record profits for decades yet somehow do so without mass catering to the bases elements of the human experience.

Be assured during those times there were relationship destroyers, gossip propagators, cheaters, hostile neighbors who needed small claims court, shock promoters and everything else in between. The reality of drama and ugly was just as alive then as it is today.

This great platform of influence in our culture should be turned toward solving dramatic problems, inspiring never before seen solutions, reenergizing the spirit of the culture to make a real and positive difference in our lives.

For example why not have a reality show about the greatest teachers and students in our nation and how they are changing the trajectory of value and hope of a better and brighter future for the country.

What about a reality show that champions nurses, medical professionals and patients that are turning the tide toward a more healthy and sustainable population and health care system.

Of course at first these kinds of choices don’t seem to have the “sizzle” of a Jerry Springer show, but that’s because they haven’t been launched and had the change to grow advertising dollars.

A practical solution.

Think of the loud and clear message that would be sent to executives if we stopped watching. Well not completely but some measurable shift from the automatic profits that they’ve now come to rely upon.

This could be for example anywhere from 10, 5, or even just one percent of the national viewing audience going cold turkey! If that’s too wild fetched an idea, maybe half of everyone who watches regular cable programing obstained from a single program each day, each week even just one each month. It would be a start.

Any appreciative drop in ratings would help exploit a crack in the amour of the status quo. A blip on the industry radar would give chance to awesome high quality programming which would be generally set for the pre production white board chopping block.

That’s right, the audacity of an alternative stirred on by the people!

Imagine the deliberate, purposeful decision of choice over the present buffet of churn and burn Reality TV entrée, and not so yummy dessert!

What a magnificent statement and challenging vision that would set forth to the powers that be that there is an entire vast untapped market of opportunity out there to be conquered!

Could such a shift of the national viewing market send a clear message? A message that says we want better and we’re willing to pay you (advertising dollars) for it.

There is evidence to strongly support this case although it is in the minority. There is a growing group of successful networks; brands and programs, which have started leading the way here, just to name a few:

Discovery Channel

History Channel

The Cooking Channel

The Learning Channel

Animal Planet

DIY channel

PBS

National Geographic Channel

Comedy Channel

Arts & Entertainment Channel

C-Span …etc.

These choices entertain us, inform us, inspire us and challenge us to grow our families, communities and our nation in the most positive ways! We need the will and the ratings clout to grow and expand them so that they are the majority rather than the minority.

Let’s have the character, courage and foresight to learn from those who have previously traveled before us

Those like Nobel Price winning playwright, George Bernard Shaw and renowned 20th century Poet and Author Oscar Wilde both agreed on the premise of Wilde’s famous quote which draws us to a conclusion.

In the1889 essay, The Decay of Lying - " Life imitates Art far more than Art imitates Life”.

The major message of this literary masterpiece was paraphrased - If you keep making art chaotic and with no intrinsic value, pretty soon that’s what you’ll have in your society.

I submit that the assertions of this discussion are worth giving some very serious consideration.

I hope you do too!

StayPos!

More by this Author

  • The Phenomenon of Starbucks
    13

    $8 Dollar Coffee! Just think about that for a moment. No really, take a moment and get your mind around that fact. I’ll be fully transparent here; I am NOT a legitimate expert on coffee since I drink it rarely....

  • Escape Your Comfort Zone!
    20

    In order to reach new heights in life and career you'll have to risk leaving what your familiar with and Ecape Out of Your Comfort Zone!

  • Interracial Marriages Don't Work
    32

    Richard P. Loving and his wife, Mildred, were convicted under Virginia law that banned mixed marriages. They eventually won a U.S. Supreme Court decision in June 1967 that overturned laws prohibiting interracial unions....


Comments 11 comments

BobbiRant profile image

BobbiRant 5 years ago from New York

Yes, but reality TV is so dirt cheap (the name of the game in our modern era) to create that every producer has jumped on the band wagon and they make big monies with little effort. Funny, most of us will not sit through an entire commercial, yet we watch 'Apprentice' people making commercials through an Entire show. Rather funny. Besides, watching those other shows, people may accidentally learn something. They may not be up for that. :0) Good hub.


StayPos profile image

StayPos 5 years ago from Florida, USA Author

BobbiRant,

Glad you enjoyed :-) It is interesting how commercial pitches are disguised inside full length episodes of some " reality " shows. Very astute point.

Also, the inexpensive nature of cheap sets, " acting " talent, script writing, etc., does in fact make it that much harder for quality and substance to compete!

Let's stay tuned.


RealHousewife profile image

RealHousewife 5 years ago from St. Louis, MO

Excellent hub! Of course - I am a REAL housewife and I protest the bravo series real housewives - it is so UNREAL! Haha!

I love all the channels in the latter of your hub - Discovery, History - all that!

Up and awesome SP:)


StayPos profile image

StayPos 5 years ago from Florida, USA Author

RealHouswife,

Thanks for your comments and the vote up :-)

Yes, you're so right in many cases " Reality " TV has highjacked the true mean of REAL and is promoting the furthest thing from it!


ladyt11 5 years ago

very good hub and I completely agree with you!


visionandfocus profile image

visionandfocus 5 years ago from North York, Canada

You're absolutely right--there is no intrinsic value to reality shows. To get network ratings, they court controversy, pandering to the lowest common denominator. I shudder to think what impressionable young people learn from watching them. Instead of learning that we should accept each other's differences and work together (a life skill in the real world), they learn to judge, to hate and to ostracize one another. Mean people (or, in some cases,idiotic celebs) are glorified. And we wonder why there's an epidemic of bullying in schools.


StayPos profile image

StayPos 5 years ago from Florida, USA Author

visionandfocus,

Glad you enjoyed the hub and thanks for your compliment :-)

Indeed, it's very tragic that network ratings and profits control the substance and quality of what is shown on television!

You make an excellent point regarding how “ lowest common denominator ” programming basically promote bullying amongst our young people in schools.

Hopefully, the tide will turn in the future and we can pull the plug on this kind of Reality TV and get back to delivering solid content that supports more positive outcomes!

Thanks for the contribution :-)


.josh. profile image

.josh. 5 years ago

Another great hub, StayPos. Well done.

I'm with you entirely, though I have to admit I quite enjoy some of the reality cooking shows, particularly Australia's MasterChef - it plays far too often for me to watch every episode, but I like what I've seen :) Definitely some fluff, but it's predominantly positive - and certainly not in the same realm of 'Jersey Shore,' 'The Real Housewives,' or any of that nonsense - so I allow myself the guilty pleasure.


StayPos profile image

StayPos 5 years ago from Florida, USA Author

.josh.

Thanks for the positive compliments :-) I too appreciate the Food Network which comes on here in the states.

It’s great picking up new skills in the kitchen and experiencing the expertise and creativity of chefs around the world.

Thanks for sharing!

Cheers!


b2b-sales-europe profile image

b2b-sales-europe 5 years ago from Berlin, Germany

StayPos,

let's pull the plug on most TV program that is simply steeling our lifetime!

We don't watch TV for years now. We still get our news and information, but we don't need someone to entertain us.

Also, there are lots of people sitting alone at home in loneliness, TV is not the answer.

The best answer is always: socialize! Know your spouses, buddies, colleagues and neighbors and spend time with them. That makes living worthwile and even neighborhoods more secure. Our neighbors are watching our home, while we are on holiday, we need no guards!

I give TV credit for bringing valuable information (history, science, languages) as a transmitter to lots of people, as you mentioned.


StayPos profile image

StayPos 5 years ago from Florida, USA Author

b2b-sales-europe,

Thanks for your comments!

No matter where we are in the world, one thing is the same… we all have a 24 hour day.

Sharing too much of that day with time draining and low value Reality TV (or similar) is not the best use of it.

I share your positive perspective that connecting and creating mutually beneficial relationships with others is far greater.

Cheers and welcome to Hubpages!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working