Star Trek 11 2009

Star Trek Review - Is Star Trek 11 Any Good

Look up front - I've been a life long trekkie this will not be an un-biased review - you have been warned!

I know the JJ Abrams isn't a trekkie - and in a lot of ways that's good- he has a tricky balancing act which is to persuade new viewer into the new Star Trek series - oh yes there will be a sequel no surprise there! But at the same time there is probably more "back story" to Star Trek than any other series anywhere in the universe - get that wrong and he will need protection orders out! He cannot afford to fail on that one!

Is Star Trek 11 Any Good?

Well luckily I am not a movie critic so I don't have to cover ever aspect - instead I am going to go straight to the heart of it - is Star Trek 11 a believable prequel to the original Star Trek which ran on US TV from 1966-1968?

Lets face it there are some issues - the original is 43 years old! Some of the technology has been and gone - my cellphone is a great deal smaller than Kirk's communicator and communicators didn't even text. My laptop has more computing power than the entire on-board computer of the original Enterprise! So to be true to the technology you'd have the 21st century characters using 1960's technology - amusing but hardly likely!

So they can do what they like with the technology, the Enterprise can be better, and the special effects. But there are several things they can't mess with: Kirk, Spock and McCoy are the three main ones.

Star Trek 2009

Chris Pine as James T. Kirk.

Kirk, James T., is an interesting mixture. In the original Shatner hammed him up- particularly in the bad third series. But at his best moments Shatner's Kirk was real because he was a mixture. He was a strong leader -the youngest Capitan of a Starship at 30 he must be bright and charismatic leader of men. He's the only cadet to have passed the Kobiyashi Maru test, he changed the rules because he doesn't like losing.

He could border on arrogant though from time-to-time. And he's a womanizer - big time- its a rare episode when Kirk doesn't get the girl! He's got a great sense of humour too - when he lets himself go he is quite the comic - but we don't see often in Shatner's Kirk - probably because he doesn't think it becomes his leadership role.

From the original series we want to know how Kirk made it Captain the fleet's flagship at only 30. We know his father died serving - does that have something to do with it? Why does he treat women so badly- did a girl break his heart?

Over the years of the movies we have seen Shatner's Kirk get older and heavier so young Kirk has to be a skinny hyper-active kid and Chris Pine is certainly that. The face isn't quite right but and he doesn't seem to use some of the classic Shatner facial expressions of the 1/2 smile and squint.

But he's believable as a raw, unformed Kirk - though it seems that this new Kirk won't be doing quite as well with the ladies as in the glorious star dates of the 1960's. You have to feel for an actor taking on the Kirk legacy but I think Pine has managed to blend Shatner and himself reasonably well - though its not as "pure" as some old treikkies would ilke I think this character will grow with the new actor. But he's not doing too well on the girl front - this is big new development for the character !

Spock and Kirk as their alter-egos in Mirror,Mirror
Spock and Kirk as their alter-egos in Mirror,Mirror
Kirk and Spock with the Younger Generation
Kirk and Spock with the Younger Generation

Zachary Quinto as Spock

Leonard Nimoy as Spock is a legend really. The first time that an alien was included as part of a TV series this "half breed" Spock's mixed Human Vulcan heritage intrigued many fans from the original series -myself included. He's the son of a Vulcan diplomat Sarek and earth women Amanda Grayson - who presumably met on earth, and where was Spock brought up Earth or Vulcan? There is only one time that Spock ever shows emotion (Amok Time) - was he always like that. We know Vulcans can have really violent emotions but choose to supress them - why did Spock choose to go the Vulcan way and the not the human? Has he ever regretted it? We know that Nimoy's Spock loves his mother but was at the start of the original Star Trek had been estranged from his father for many years {Journey to Babel) because of his decision to join Star Trek - the first Vulcan to do so.

Then there is Spock's relationship with Kirk - obviously Spock could command - but doesn't and chooses to plays second to Kirk's Captain - why is that? From the start they are a close team - obviously have been together for a long time - but we know that Spock is a lot older than Kirk - Vulcans age slower than humans. They show signs of more than a professional respect too - Spock is emotional when he find's KIrk alive after thining he had killed "my captain, and my friend" - why is that - they are lilk chalk and cheese why do they trust each other so completely?

Quinto's Spock gets to meet Nimoy's Spock and of all the new crew he has the closest physical match. The mannerisms come as the movie progresses and by the end we can see the future for this Spock.

But there are twists and turns in the plot which i can't mention here without giving the game away - suffice to say there is room for a an interesting development or two in the next movie....

Karl Urban as Dr McCoy

Initially seeing Urban as McCoy I couldn't see the likeness - but when he talks its like DeForest Kelly still has the part - the guy has the southern drawl down to perfection - which is fascinating because he is actually a New Zealander - as I am and I it sounded just like Kelly talking to me. Urban has Kelly's timing and of course some of the classic one liners - its going to be interesting to see he further develop the role.

Star Trek 2009 Trailer

So Is Star Trek 11 Any Good ?

Yes it is - in this trekkie's opinion - yes it has the expected fight scenes, the explosions the grand space opera - which you'd expect. But it has avoided the self-indulgent navel-gazing of too many earlier Star Trek films.

This Star Trek has the humour, the charactes and the potential to Live Long and Prosper and boldly go where no one has gone before for quite a while I think. See it!

Is Star Trek 11 A Good Star Trek Movie?

  • Yes
  • No
See results without voting

More by this Author

  • Ballroom Dance Music - Modern Ballroom Songs
    14

    Ballroom Dance's music used to be strictly boring. Many people probably still expect to hear gorgeous dancers to be accommpanied by the ever-green light orchestra which somehow manages to make everything from a waltz...

  • How to do basic waltz steps. (Men's and Women's parts)
    36

    The waltz is the first dance most people think the might learn when they decide to learn to dance. Whether they want to dance for their wedding or just for a social event the waltz tends to the dance they start with. ...

  • Australia the Movie
    41

    Australia, the movie, is setting the movie world alight. Nicole Kidman is a sexy beautiful actress and the shots of her getting hot and sweaty in remote Australia, are hot, hot, hot...


Comments 16 comments

lafenty profile image

lafenty 7 years ago from California

From one trekie to another, thanks for the hub. I can't wait to see it.


John Z profile image

John Z 7 years ago from Midwest

Thank you for the review. I can't wait to see it either!


Lupo profile image

Lupo 7 years ago from Boston Area

I do not go to the movies much and really do not pay all that much attention to what is coming out. Hence I am surprised by this new Star Trek and that it is a prequel to the TV series. Very interesting and thanks for letting me know all about this Lissie!


janetra profile image

janetra 7 years ago from Antigua, West Indies

As another life long trekkie thanks for the review! I hate to admit it (as it gives my age away) but I've been watching Star Trek since the very first series.


thelesleyshow profile image

thelesleyshow 7 years ago from US

I didn't like it. But I love this hub and I love you for being a Trekki! So I gave you a thumbs up because you always have good content.


Lissie profile image

Lissie 7 years ago from New Zealand Author

Thanks for all the comments guys the movie really had be totally glued tothe screen the whole way thru - and I may even go and see it again - something I very rarely do! You didn't like it TLS, i think you're in the minority for that one but thanks for commenting anyways - yeah trekkies rule!


earnestshub profile image

earnestshub 7 years ago from Melbourne Australia

I will go and see this one!


Dolores Monet profile image

Dolores Monet 7 years ago from East Coast, United States

My youngest son just saw it last night and really enjoyed it. He said they used all the famous Star Trek quips in just the right places. Boy would I love to see a Star Trek return to TV. I loved Next Generation and Voyager like mad!


waynet profile image

waynet 7 years ago from Hull City United Kingdom

I'm looking forward to this film as I've seen the trailer.


Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS 7 years ago from North America

Thank you , Lissie! I won't see it until day after tomorrow...


Cynthia 7 years ago

I went to see this, one old trekkie blowing off work to see it the 2nd day in theaters, and I abolutely LOVED it! It is one of the best prequels ever. I have to admit that I need to go and see it again as I spent a lot of time reconsiling <sp?> the events with what I remember from the series. It hands down blew my mind for effects, the story was wonderful and I loved knowing the "begining" for the major characters. I ROCKED!!!! Star Trek Forever!

Live long and prosper...


Lissie profile image

Lissie 7 years ago from New Zealand Author

Oh that is so cool - "blowing off work to see it" Cynthia - its way cool isn't it! I have to go again after the weekend I think! Thanks for commenting


kerryg profile image

kerryg 7 years ago from USA

I haven't seen very much of the original series except for the movies (IV is my favorite, but II and VI were good too), but I very much enjoyed the "reboot" and am planning to go back and watch TOS now just to have more basis for comparison. I agree that all three of the male leads did very good jobs with their roles, and loved what they did with Uhura and the other supporting crew members as well.


wmd profile image

wmd 7 years ago from South Jersey

Star Trek (2009) was a good movie... and this is coming from a Star Wars fan.

However, it is not Star Trek 11. Sure, it may be the eleventh movie, but it falls into it's own continuity and therefore starts a new "series".


resspenser profile image

resspenser 6 years ago from South Carolina

Loved this hub and I think you got it just right.

Check out my Wrath of Kahn hub when you get a minute.

Thanks.


enjoy life profile image

enjoy life 6 years ago from Europe

I think it is great to see them reviving the original Star Trek. That is obviously where the series originally became famous, and with new technology, it gives them a chance to redo this great series with new filming techniques! This new film is an outstanding Star Trek movie - I think it's the best so far. Also, the Star trek franchise is about due something new again!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working