The Adventures of Tintin, and Hugo. Two Reviews

Two new films that are safe family viewing


The Adventures of Tintin: (3.5 Stars out of 5)


Take a beloved 80 year old comic series and combine it with a roster of genuine creative talents, add some state-of-the-art motion-capture effects and how can you miss? Directed by Steven Spielberg, produced by Peter Jackson (Lord of the Rings), written by Steven Moffat (Head writer of Dr. Who), with music by legendary composer John Williams, and with the voice talents of Daniel Craig, Andy Serkis, Simon Pegg and Toby Jones, the Adventures of Tintin has an impressive pedigree. Fortunately, it lives up to its resume.

Tintin began as a Belgium comic strip, created by Herge (AKA Georges Remi) in 1929. Twenty three Tintin stories were completed by Herge and the character has become a beloved icon all over Europe, although the character has never made the leap across the pond, Tintin is barely known in America.

Tintin is a young reporter (possibly a teenager but his age is never made clear) who works as a freelance investigator, using his knack for stumbling upon big stories to get the scoop before other, more experienced reporters. He always runs into danger but he gets through it by outwitting his enemies through resourcefulness, courage, cunning and virtue. Tintin is always assisted by his fox terrier Snowy, a dog so remarkably intelligent he’d make Lassie envious.

The comic strip is brought to life using 3-D motion-capture effects. While the 3-D really isn’t necessary, it works in this case, being less grainy than many other 3-d films. The motion-capture FX are top-notch and Tintin’s face is amazingly realistic and expressive.

The story begins when Tintin (voice of Jamie Bell) lucks into another big story after he buys a model of a boat called the Unicorn and finds out that several other people want it badly, and some of them do not play nice about procuring it. The boat turns out to be the key to a sunken treasure and Tintin races evil villain Sakharine (Voice of Daniel Craig) to the goods.

Along the way, Tintin joins forces with inebriate sailor Captain Haddock. Haddock is voiced by Andy Serkis, who retains his title as the Lawrence Olivier of Motion-Capture, after having done Gollum in The Lord of the Rings, the eponymous gorilla in King Kong and Caser in Rise of the Planet of the Apes. He’s the screen’s foremost specialist in Motion-Capture acting. His Captain Haddock is rarely sober and often more of a hindrance than a help.

The chase takes Tintin, Captain Haddock and Snowy around the world, from France to Morocco, using boats, planes, cars and motor cycles; and Spielberg seems to be channeling memories of Raiders of the Lost Ark, as the globe-trotting heroes escape from one peril after another. The final segment of the film is filled with enough kinetic action that younger fans will be entertained and older fans will recall the vintage years of Spielberg.

Simon Peg and his frequent comic collaborator Nick Frost play a pair of well-intentioned but utterly clueless detectives named Thompson and Thompson. Toby Jones voices one of Sakharin’'s henchmen Silk.

The Adventures of Tintin is a lot of fun, safe for kids but an enjoyable day at the movies for adults. You don’t need to be familiar with the long history of the Tintin comic books to appreciate this film. This is old-school Spielberg and it’s his best work in years.


Recommended.


HUGO (3.5 stars out of five.)


The cleverest aspect of the film Hugo is the way it pays homage to a pioneering filmmaker of the silent movie era while incorporating the tribute into the story seamlessly. If you know about the life and work of French silent film director/writer/actor George Melies than there’s an extra level of enjoyment here for you, but even if you’ve never heard of Melies, it won’t ruin your enjoyment of the film.

Martin Scorsese seems like an odd choice of director for this type of film until you realize that this movie is only a drama about an orphan on the surface. Beneath that, this film is a homage to the birth of the film industry and one of its original superstar directors. This is perfect fodder for a film preservationist like Scorsese.

George Melies was the inventor of movie special effects, a ground breaker in the genre of science fiction and the first director to ever open his own independent movie studio. His early films like A Trip to the Moon may seem ridiculously crude today but in the beginning of the silent era, they were considered remarkable.

The focus of the film is not on Melies, though, but rather on a child named Hugo Cabret (Asa Butterfield). Hugo is the orphaned son of a watchmaker (Jude Law) who is temporarily taken in by his uncaring, drunken uncle Claude (Ray Winstone) who works in the massive Paris train station, tending to the oversized gears and springs of the station’s many clocks. When Uncle Claude deserts him, young Hugo is afraid that he’ll be sent to an orphanage so he prefers to be self-sufficient and live in the station, tending to the clocks. Hugo lurks unseen in the catwalks, air-vents, basement, rafters and other hidden regions of the huge station, like a pre-teen Phantom of the Opera. He covertly observes the lives of the people who pass through the station, steals food from station eateries and keeps the clocks running.

Hugo has to constantly avoid the unnamed, inept station security inspector (Played with an annoying Inspector Clouseau-style accent by Sacha Baron Cohen, who is achingly unfunny here) and his energetic Doberman. The dog is smarter than the Inspector.

Hugo has another obsession; a mechanical clockwork man who his father once found and failed to repair. Hugo steals parts and tools from the station toyshop, hoping to fix it, until he is caught by the toyshop’s owner who is at first furious until he learns about the mechanical man and then he makes Hugo work off his debt in the shop. Hugo later learns that this bitter, old down-and-out toymaker is George Melies; (Played with sad authority by Ben Kingsley) who was once the biggest thing in the French film industry before a post-World War One slump caused him to declare bankruptcy and lose his studio. Melies found himself forgotten, forced to open a toy shop to sustain himself. Melies seems to know something about the mechanical man that Hugo is so consumed with but he won’t talk about it. Hugo investigates Melies’ past, with the help of Melies’ young goddaughter Isabelle (Chloe Grace Moretz) who takes a liking to Hugo. Together they unravel a mystery that connects Hugo with Melies.

Hugo is two films in one. On one hand, it’s a homage to Melies and his pioneering work, and on the other hand, it’s the story of an orphan trying to survive and find a purpose in the world. The mechanical devices that fill the movie are used as a metaphor. Hugo compares the world to one, huge machine. As Hugo tells us, “Machines have no spare parts. Every part has a purpose, just like every person has a purpose in the world. You just have to figure out what it is.” Hugo and Melies feel like spare parts and need to find a purpose in a world that has forgotten them.

The bizarre, giant gears and wheels of the station’s clocks are done with CGI effects. The 3-D is meant to highlight the size of the huge pieces of machinery which dwarf Hugo but it isn’t really necessary, except in a few scenes, like when Scorsese does a recreation of the early short film The Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat.

The biggest weakness of the film is young Butterfield as Hugo, because he is not very expressive and lacks any real on-screen star energy. Also Sasha Baron Cohen gives an out-of-place cartoonish performance in an otherwise mature and serious film. However, Ben Kingsley makes up for their short comings with a graceful performance as a cinema legend brought low, and trapped by his inability to move on from the past.

Scorsese does a nice job honoring the early days of cinema using modern 3-D technology, and by mixing a very young star with an established show business legend like Kingsley. Visually it’s brilliant and even though some of the performances are weak; the message that everyone is a useful part in the machine of humankind is a wise and timely message.


Recommended.

More by this Author


Comments 18 comments

Cogerson profile image

Cogerson 4 years ago from Virginia

Thanks for the two reviews....so far Hugo has the best reviews of the year so far it least. Glad to see both movies rate high on the Robwrite chart as I want to see both movies. At first I had no interest in seeing The Adventures of Tintin...but the last previews actually look interesting. I will be sure to link this hub to my Top Films of 2011 hub when I update tomorrow....now I am off to research The Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat which I must admit I have no idea what movie you are referencing.....voted up and useful....thanks for two reviews on one hub.


Jools99 profile image

Jools99 4 years ago from North-East UK

Rob, good reviews. Of the two movies, I'm more likely to see Tin Tin because I watched the animation as a child. Hugo, I will see on DVD sometime. Melies sounds like an interesting man, I had never heard of him.


Steve Lensman profile image

Steve Lensman 4 years ago from London, England

A homage to Melies eh and about time too! ;) I want to see them both but I'll probably wait and get them on disc. Mission Impossible 4 is the only film I can drag the missus too this winter. Thanks for the reviews Rob.


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Bruce; I'm not surprised "Hugo" is getting such good reviews because its a very good film, despite a few weak performances. Both films are fun.

"The arrival of a train at La Ciotat" was a very short piece of footage which was one of the very first moving images ever shown to the public. It was basically a train coming toward the camera but it panicked the people in the theater because no one had ever seen anything like it before and they scrambled to get out of the way when the image of the train came toward them, thinking they were in danger of being hit by a train.

Always good to hear from you, Bruce,

Rob


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Jools; I think you'll enjoy "Tintin" because its good, harmless fun. Spielberg does a nice job with it.

I ,like most Americans, am not too familiar with Tintin. I've occasionally herd references to it but I didn't know much about it until this film was released so I researched it.

Melies is a fascinating figure in film history. A stage magician turned filmmaker who slipped into obscurity but was rediscovered late in life by a new generation. he was an innovator in the industry.

Thanks for readings,

Rob


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Steve; Its nice to see some of the film pioneers aren't forgotten. Scorcese is a film preservationist so he's big on preserving the history of cinema.

While I'm not a fan of Tom Cruise or of the "Mission Impossible" series myself, some people are saying the new one is pretty good. I hope you and your wife enjoy it.

Rob


Amazontickets profile image

Amazontickets 4 years ago from Florida

Tintin looks interesting. The animation style alone makes it worth a look, I think.


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Yes, the motion capture visuals are amazing. The movie looks great.

Rob


Jade Evans profile image

Jade Evans 4 years ago from Sydney, Australia

Great reviews, glad to hear that The Adventures of Tintin is worth seeing. I've been excited about this one as I was a big fan of Tintin growing up and still treasure all the books :)


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Jade; Tintin is definitely worth seeing. If you're familiar with Tintin than you'll probably get an extra level of enjoyment that I didn't get since I'm not familiar with the strip.

thanks for reading and commenting,

Rob


FloraBreenRobison profile image

FloraBreenRobison 4 years ago

I am interested in The Adventures of Tintin


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Flora; It's a good film. I know you don't go to the theater much to see new films but when it comes on DVD or cable you should enjoy it,

Rob


Stevennix2001 profile image

Stevennix2001 4 years ago

very good reviews of both films, as it sounds like we had similar opinions of it. i too seen both films, but i haven't gotten around to writing a review on hugo yet. anyway, keep up the good work as always.


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Thanks, Steve; I look forward to reading your review of "Hugo".

Thanks for stopping by,

Rob


teaches12345 profile image

teaches12345 4 years ago

Appreciate your reviews. I did want to see Hugo, and may yet; however, after reading I prefer Tintin. I always enjoy a good Spielburg movie. He knows how to do it well. Thanks.


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi; This is vintage Speilberg, doing what he does best. He's having a good year with "Tin tin" and "War horse".

Thanks for reading,

Rob


gg.zaino profile image

gg.zaino 4 years ago from L'America

Hey Rob, feels like being back home. always a pleasure to read your reviews- i feel as though there is a mindfulness behind your critique-

unlike typical movie reviews i search for in the local papers here in the Keys. You enjoy film- subject matter you write about is thought out- always a safe bet!

"Tintin" and "Hugo" both have a special appeal.

animation these days gets a little spooky for me. a good example of that eeriness felt was, "Beowulf"-

when characters are so human and are capable of the impossible- are their human counterparts in jeopardy of losing appeal for a new generation?

will the new genre someday replace its predecessor as silent film was to fall away to the talkies? good actors require fat paychecks- animated characters require a voice and technology that does nothing but improve. Spielberg is a great example of riding the wave..

after reading you reviews- i have decided to go with Hugo at onset because you paint a fascinating picture of a fine metaphoric atmosphere, that i personally use often and see its potential for diversion.

might not be here at the moment- i have to find it first Rob- i'd have to believe Ben K is a fine touch.

Tin tin is one that i believe to have seen advertised hereabouts- whichever comes first-

can always wait for Hulu or Netflix to offer them up- but i want to go to the theater if i can...

wow- lotta writin' here pard!

thanx for solid advice- see ya round Rob!

good 2 b back :)peace my friend, and thanx for your fine comment on my new material.

greg


Robwrite profile image

Robwrite 4 years ago from Bay Ridge Brooklyn NY Author

Hi Greg; Good to hear from you. I also wonder if the future of film will be done in CGI instead of live actors. So far they still need voice performers but who knows what the futire will bring. Maybe they will find a way to replace voices, too. Motion-Capture is an interesting development because it combines CGI FX with real acting. A nice compromise.

"Hugo" is the better of the two films on an artistic level and it deserves its many nominations.

Great to hear from you again. Enjoy that warm weather in the keys.

Rob

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working