Film Review - The Quick and the Dead (1995)

Source

INTRODUCTION

'The Quick and the Dead' is a Sam Raimi directed Western made in 1995, long after the supposed golden age of the genre. It is, like so many other Westerns, a straightforward story, but with a novel plotline. The scriptwriter Simon Moore has taken one staple ingredient of the cowboy movies of old - the duel - and made it the centrepiece action for the entire 107 minutes.

'The Quick and the Dead' features a memorable four character cast which includes one long established and respected Hollywood star, one young actress who, though rather notorious at the time, was also a major player in front of and behind the camera lens, and two young actors who would soon emerge as two of the biggest stars in the business.

The four actors are Gene Hackman, Sharon Stone, Russell Crowe and Leonardo di Caprio.

WHAT'S THE STORY?

Redemption is a small Western town under the control of a vicious overlord called Herod. What Herod says, goes. And he has said there is going to be a gunslinging tournament in which 16 of the fastest guns around will shoot it out in properly organised duels for the pleasure and gratification of the people, and for the gratification of Herod himself. For the ultimate winner, there will be a stack of prize money. And for the losers - well, if they are very lucky - they will live.

The 16 fighters are a mixed bunch, but four stand out from the rest. One is a preacher with a bad past, forced into the contest against his will by Herod. He is named Cort. One is a very young gunslinger, appropriately known as The Kid, who seems super fast, and super confident. The third is a woman called Ellen, who seems to be hiding a bitter secret. She has got her own reasons for entering this contest, and it has got nothing to do with money. As the only female, she is known simply as 'Lady'. The fourth of these entrants is Herod himself, who is not only rich and powerful, but also very quick.

That, basically, is almost the whole of the story of this film. All that is left to discover is Ellen's secret. And just who is the fastest gun in Redemption?

MAIN CAST & CHARACTERS

ACTOR 
CHARACTER 
Gene Hackman 
John Herod 
Sharon Stone 
Ellen or 'Lady' 
Russell Crowe 
Cort 
Leonardo di Caprio
'The Kid'
Lance Henriksen
Ace Hanlon
Keith David
Sgt. Clay Cantrell
Pat Hingle
Saloon Proprietor

THE FACTS OF THE FILM

DIRECTOR : Sam Raimi

WRITERS / SCREENPLAY :

  • Simon Moore

YEAR OF RELEASE : 1995

RUNNING TIME : 107 mins

GENRE : Western

GUIDENCE : Brief nudity. Mild violence and gore.

ACADEMY NOMINATIONS : None


DiCaprio, Hackman, Stone and Crowe - the four leads in The Quick and the Dead
DiCaprio, Hackman, Stone and Crowe - the four leads in The Quick and the Dead

BEST CHARACTERS / PERFORMANCES

The characters played by the four leads are Herod (Hackman), Ellen, or 'Lady' (Stone), Cort (Crowe), and The Kid (DiCaprio). All are favourite cliches of the Western genre - respectively they are the ruthless land baron who owns and runs the town, the pretty woman who in this movie also happens to be a crackshot, the quiet confident gunslinger, and the slick young gun - the sharpshooting kid. All are played more than adequately by the actors.

But all the other assorted characters who turn up for this contest to kill or be killed are likewise characters which could be found in any of a hundred movies set in the Wild West. There’s an unpleasantly smooth and arrogant showman called ‘Ace’, there’s a tough Indian warrior with the aura of a man who ’cannot be killed’, there's a brutal escaped convict, and an ultra cool, ex-soldier who calmly puffs on a long pipe. Almost any one of them could play the main lead, or more probably the main villain, in almost any Western ever made.

SPECIAL FEATURE - SHARON STONE

I’d like to draw particular attention to Sharon Stone. I suspect that this actress has never really been taken seriously by many ever since that notorious scene in ‘Basic Instinct’ for which she is best known. The first three films I ever saw Stone act in were the aforementioned ‘Basic instinct’, ‘King Solomon’s Mines’ and this film. In King Solomon’s Mines - a comedy adventure - she plays a ditzy dolly bird dropped like a fish out of water into the African bush. In ‘Basic Instinct’ she plays an ultra-intelligent mind-game playing suspect in a serial killer investigation, and if one looks beyond the gratuitous nudity, she actually gives an utterly convincing performance as a cold and manipulative individual. In ’The Quick and the Dead’, her role is once again entirely different; a serious minded woman hell-bent on revenge against a man who once destroyed her life. Perhaps the level of acting skill required in these films is not great, but all three parts are so very different from each other and she plays each as well as it can be played. In the same year as this Western was made, recognition came with an Oscar nomination and a Golden Globe award for the film 'Casino'. What's more, in this film Stone was a major role player behind the scenes as well as in front of the camera (see trivia), and away from her acting, she is known to be a person of high intellect. Sharon Stone is not some dumb sex Goddess; she is a versatile and clever actress.

FAVOURITE QUOTES

Perhaps the line which encompasses best what this film is all about, and how this dueling contest can take place in this town, is delivered by John Herod, who authorizes it and dicatates what exactly will happen. He has just learned that one of the 16 was hired by the townsfolk specifically to kill him:

'All I hear from you, you spineless cowards, is how poor you are; how you can't afford my taxes. Yet somehow, you managed to find the money to hire a gunfighter to kill me. If you've got so much money, I'm just gonna have to take some more, because clearly some of you haven't got the message. This is my town! I run everything! If you live to see the dawn, it's because I allow it. I decide who lives and who dies!'

TRIVIA

Sharon Stone's acting abilities are discussed above. In this film, she also has significant other responsibilities. Stone was signed on as co-producer of The Quick and the Dead, and as such she wielded very considerable influence. First, she insisted on Sam Raimi as director. Second, she insisted on casting of two relatively unknown actors - Russell Crowe and Leonardo di Caprio - in major roles. In the case of Di Caprio, she even voluntered to personally pay his salary.

All the 'gunfighters' received tuition in the skill of quick draw. The actor who practised most and proved in reality to be the fastest gun in the movie was ......... Gene Hackman.

Another Western - also called 'The Quick and the Dead' - was released as a TV movie in 1987 starring Sam Elliott. The story is unrelated.

FAVOURITE SCENES

All the gunfights are worth watching. The outcomes for the most part are fairly predictable, although it gets a little harder to foresee what will happen when the final four line up against each other. The rules of the gunfight contest decree that only one should be left standing at the end, but it is difficult to figure out how that can be, especially when Cort has to fight Ellen - who both seem like good guys - to the death!

NEGATIVES ?

The biggest negative is perhaps a point already made - this film stands or falls on the suspense to be had from watching a duel between two ace gunfighters; that suspense is severely diluted when it's pretty obvious which one is going to win, and in most of these contests, it is pretty obvious.

The other negative I think is the silliness of some of the gunfights. One character shot with a single bullet ends up with a neat round bullet-sized hole through the chest which allows daylight to shine through. Nothing like that could happen in real life. Another goes one better - he ends up with a hole in the head the size of a baseball, which would allow a veritable sunbeam to shine through!

Of course the whole concept of a town holding an insane do or die contest like this seems pretty far fetched even by bloody Wild West standards.

My advice is; accept the silliness and enjoy the action, or don't watch!

WHAT'S SO GOOD ABOUT IT?

I don’t think we should make more of this film than meets the eye. There’s no deep underlying morality, nothing special about the screenplay or acting. It’s just a nice simple story of 15 men and one woman shooting each other one by one until one is left. The duel in the street is one of the mainstays of the Western movie genre affording as it does the basic pleasure of seeing two people slugging it out as equals. But usually it’s a one-off battle, the climax and highlight of the movie. In this film there’s about a dozen featured duels, so the whole film is filled with highlights. Perhaps not really the most edifying of themes; for all that watching ‘The Quick and the Dead’ is an enjoyable way of passing the time with four of Hollywood’s biggest stars.


CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

‘The Quick and the Dead’ is the sort of film I like. It’s a well made film with decent performances by all involved both in front of the camera and behind. It’s not going to require some hard work to understand the plot - the plot is as simple as it gets. If you can get past thinking about the banal storyline and just enjoy the action for what it is, then you’ll enjoy this movie.

PLEASE PROVIDE YOUR ASSESSMENT OF THIS FILM

4 out of 5 stars from 2 ratings of this film

More by this Author

  • Film Review - Shenandoah (1965)
    15

    'Shenandoah' is one of the great Westerns - a powerful and evocative drama about one man's attempts to keep his family together in the midst of the escalating conflict of the American Civil War This.is a movie which has...

  • Film Review - The Big Country (1958)
    22

    The Big Country is a savage indictment of the cliched Wild West philosophy of men who believe it is right to live by the gun and settle disputes in a terminal way. Everyone's opinion is personal, but my opinion is that...

  • 100 Funny and Witty Quotations about Politics
    26

    Some of the words of politicians are among the most erudite of all sayings. But some others are banal nonsense. This is my selection of the most memorable of all political quotes, jokes and analyses


PLEASE ADD COMMENTS IF YOU WILL. THANKS, ALUN 12 comments

Greensleeves Hubs profile image

Greensleeves Hubs 3 years ago from Essex, UK Author

Thanks gnordt. Much appreciated. 'Once Upon a Time in the West' certainly is a film much acclaimed by critics, and I believe a cleverly made film. You make a fine case for its merits, though I must admit the appeal has - so far - been lost on me. I have always felt the film too high on style and too low on story telling (all those scenes where people stare at each other for aeons of time without speaking) and overlong. I know I am in the minority so following your comments, I think I will have to watch it again in the near future and try to get to grips with it. Maybe the quality of 'Once Upon a Time in the West' will finally dawn on me! Alun.


gnordt 3 years ago

A similar but much better movie is Once Upon a Time in the West, portions of which seem obviously borrowed for the plot in this movie. Henry Fonda's understated portrayal of a ruthless, steely blue eyed killer is outstanding. The famous opening scene wherein 3 killers are waiting for a train to arrive so they can try to kill the person getting off (Charles Bronson) slowly, agonizingly builds tension before a climatic eruption similar to the types of scenes created by Hitchcock and Tarantino. Once Upon a Time in the West offers a more complex plot, and is less predictable than The Quick and the Dead. Both movies, however, are fun to watch again and again.


Greensleeves Hubs profile image

Greensleeves Hubs 5 years ago from Essex, UK Author

Thanks for commenting Derdriu. It's a great film just to sit back, relax and enjoy, without having to think too much! I haven't seen '3:10 to Yuma' yet, but I think I probably should.

Thanks Derdriu for your continuing support of my pages. Soon I will have to publish some more, because you've read almost all of them now! Thanks so much.


Derdriu 5 years ago

Alun: What a concise, logical, persuasive review of a fun Western movie! Everything about the film works: costuming, dialogue, music, personalities, plot, scenery. Gene Hackman is one of my favorite actors. It fits that he was the "A" student in the quick draw training. One of the many reasons for watching the film also is the witness to the future, well-deserved successes of Leonardo Di Caprio and Russell Crowe. Have you seen the "3:10 to Yuma" remake with Christian Bale and Russell Crowe?

Thank you for sharing, voted up, etc.,

Derdriu


Greensleeves Hubs profile image

Greensleeves Hubs 5 years ago from Essex, UK Author

Thank you very much Eiddwen for your nice comment. Hope you manage to catch the film sometime and like it! Cheers. Alun

P.S (note the nice Welsh spelling of my name! - my father is from Neath)


Eiddwen profile image

Eiddwen 5 years ago from Wales

A great review and I will keep an eye out for this one now.

I now look forward to reading many more of your hubs.

Take care

Eiddwen.

.


Greensleeves Hubs profile image

Greensleeves Hubs 5 years ago from Essex, UK Author

Thank you Carl for your very generous comments about the review. Glad you liked it. Thanks.


CarltheCritic1291 profile image

CarltheCritic1291 5 years ago

This is a great movie, not one of my favorites but it's great. I love the way your review is written, how it's all organized, and you seem to give a lot of great, useful, and interesting information about the film. Thanks for sharing Voted Up, Useful, Awesome, and Interesting.


Greensleeves Hubs profile image

Greensleeves Hubs 5 years ago from Essex, UK Author

If you do watch it, I hope you like it Simone


Simone Smith profile image

Simone Smith 5 years ago from San Francisco

Huh! I had never heard of this film before! Guess I'll have to check it out!


Greensleeves Hubs profile image

Greensleeves Hubs 5 years ago from Essex, UK Author

Thanks northweststarr. Glad you like the film and the review. It's certainly one of my favourite westerns of recent years with some really classic Wild West characters


northweststarr profile image

northweststarr 5 years ago from Washington State

One of my fav. westerns. Excellent review! Voted up!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Greensleeves Hubs profile image

    Greensleeves Hubs732 Followers
    154 Articles

    In a series of illustrated articles, the author gives personal easy-to-read reviews of some of the most watchable films in Hollywood history



    Click to Rate This Article
    working