Twilight Fans and Haters Need To Stop
In honor of my review of the upcoming "Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn- Part 2", I've decided to do a hub honoring it to some degree. At first, I was thinking about doing some sort of comedy sketch, like I've done in the beginning of my reviews in the past. In the sketch, I was planning to do sort of a "what if" scenario where the original wolfman and Count Dracula actually met both Jacob and Edward, from "Twilight", to see what would happen.
However, I've decided to do a hub that talks to both "Twilight Haters" and "Twilight Fans" directly instead, and why I both agree and disagree with their many assessments. Take in mind, that even though I hated all the films thus far (with the exception of the first movie), I do respect the series quite a great deal. I can't comment on the book series, as I've never read it. However, if I had to say what my position was on "Twilight", then I'd probably fall more along the lines of a "Twilight Indifferent." Meaning, I don't give a rat's a** if someone chooses to love it, or not. Sure, the film series sucks as a whole, but that's only my opinion. Hell, I consider the "Dark Knight" to be the greatest superhero film of all time, yet I've been told by quite a few people that it's arguably one of the worst. Therefore, it's really subjective to dictate what constitutes as a good film to begin with.
Before I start, I just want to apologize to everyone who happens to fall on either side of the spectrum on this, as I have a lot to say to both haters and fans of this series. And what I have to say to you if you do fall on either side, it may not be necessarily be what you want me to say. However, it's still the truth nonetheless.
Message to Twilight Haters
First of all, I want to say that I agree with you sole heartedly that "Twilight" is not only the most over rated movie franchise in recent history, but it's also tragically mediocre at best. I won't comment on the books, but I do feel the movies are lackluster to say the least.
Having said that though, I do have a few things to say to the haters that they're not going to like. Far be it from me to tell anyone what you can or cannot like, but why do you even care? Seriously, who cares if a bunch of fan girls want to read or watch a bunch of sparkling sissy vampires anyway? I honestly don't give a damn, and I have to tell you that I've never been happier.
If you find "Twilight fans" annoying, then just ignore them. They're not paying your bills, so why should you care about what they think?
Another thing that many of you, "Twilight Haters", say is that Stephenie Meyer isn't a talented writer. Fair enough, but I will say this. I don't care what anyone says, but I'm pretty sure that even "Twilight Haters" will agree with me when I say that not everyone is capable of writing a novel. Hell, I know I couldn't do it. Why do I say that? Because my imagination basically sucks, and I wouldn't have the freaking patience to sit down to type up a fictional story entirely out of my own head. And, I'm pretty sure I'm not the only person that's like this, as that would be a statistical anomaly. Because if writing a freaking novel was easy, then EVERYONE could do it. Therefore, Stephenie Meyer does have SOME talent as a writer. After all, not everyone can write a novel that's engaging enough to hook an audience; even if that said audience consists of mostly teenage to preteen girls.
As I said before, I know I couldn't do it, and I'm sure about over half the "Twilight Haters" couldn't either; hence saying that Stephenie Meyer has no talent as a writer is way out of line. Granted, I know it takes more than talent alone to become a successful writer, as a lot of it depends on other factors like connections and whatnot. However, the point is that not everyone can write a novel that's engaging enough for people to read; similar to how not everyone can pick up a damn football, and become the next John Elway. It doesn't work that way.
Plus, all your ranting accomplishes nothing, as all it does it generate more press, and more publicity for the very same franchise you claim to hate. Way to go guys! Way to be counter productive there, by drawing even more attention to the franchise you hate. You guys are aware that by virtually talking crap about it, then it only makes people curious to check out said movies/books/etc, and possibly become fans of it. Whereas if you didn't say a damn thing at all, then these potential new fans never would've heard of "Twilight" theoretically.
Seriously, if you can show this much passion hating on something, then why don't you haters direct that same passion towards doing something positive for humanity. You know...instead of getting royally p***ed off about sparkly vampires, then why don't you show that same anger towards something like animal cruelty, or how the government screws up the economy, then I'd understand. Seriously, those are REAL PROBLEMS that we should be passionate about. Yet, you're biggest problem is "Twilight?" A franchise that's not even going to matter a few years from now? I think if that's your biggest problem, then you need a serious reality check. Food for thought.
Message to Twilight Fans
First of all, I just want to say that I think it's great when fans love something so much. Seriously, I always love seeing fans get passionate about what they care about. It's one of the many reasons why I like to debate with comic book fans on youtube; whenever they make a comment about an upcoming comic book film. No, it's not out of any kind of disrespect, but it's more about challenging their ideals, and possibly gain a clearer understanding about why they feel that way towards a particular film. In fact, that's how I found out about the "X-Men: First Class" boycott, as there was a lot of comic book fans that were severely p***ed off about "X-Men 3" and "X-Men Origins: Wolverine", to the point that they adamantly refused to see the movie; unless it was handled exclusively by Marvel Studios.
Sure, I thought these same fans were being over dramatic, and some very hypocritical in their double standard logic. However, I still loved hearing their opinions, to gain a clearer understanding where they were coming from. Unfortunately, this also meant I was forced to give "X-Men: First Class" a three out of four, due to audience perspective; versus my original rating of three and a half out of four, but what can you do? Therefore, I don't mind if little teenage or preteen girls love "Twilight." If all the little girls want to fantasize about Edward Cullen, or Jacob Black, then I'd say more power to them. I honestly don't care. As long as they don't tell me about it, then we're good.
However, I do care whenever "Twilight" fans take their fandom way too far. For starters, there was the infamous Stephen King comment a few years ago. He was asked during an interview about his thoughts on both, J.K. Rowling and Stephenie Meyer, in an issue of USA Weekend. Now before I comment, I'll show you exactly what he said word for word, then we'll get into my arguments from there:
"Both Rowling and Meyer, they’re speaking directly to young people. ... The real difference is that Jo Rowling is a terrific writer and Stephenie Meyer can’t write worth a darn. She’s not very good." Stephen King would go on to say the following:
"Somebody who’s a terrific writer who’s been very, very successful is Jodi Picoult. You’ve got Dean Koontz, who can write like hell. And then sometimes he’s just awful. It varies. James Patterson is a terrible writer but he’s very very successful. People are attracted by the stories, by the pace and in the case of Stephenie Meyer, it’s very clear that she’s writing to a whole generation of girls and opening up kind of a safe joining of love and sex in those books. It’s exciting and it’s thrilling and it's not particularly threatening because they’re not overtly sexual. A lot of the physical side of it is conveyed in things like the vampire will touch her forearm or run a hand over skin, and she just flushes all hot and cold. And for girls, that’s a shorthand for all the feelings that they’re not ready to deal with yet."
Okay, I just posted exactly what Mr. King said about Stephenie Meyer, and the "Twilight" series. If you feel that what he said was in anyway disrespectful, then please enlighten me down in the comment section, as I'd love to hear your rationality. If you ask me, I honestly don't think he said anything that was remotely offensive. Outside of the first line where he says that Stephenie can't write worth a darn, he doesn't say anything that's offensive to her at all. No, he merely offers honest criticism of what he thinks of her work. Nothing more or less. In fact, he never even brought it up during the interview, as the writer for USA Weekend did. Therefore, I fail to see how what he said was insulting. But, I've been wrong before, so I'll digress.
The thing that really bothers me is the reaction of many "Twilight" fans to this comment. Not only have many fans made outrageous comments saying Stephen King is over rated, and how he couldn't allegedly hold a candle to Stephenie Meyer, but some have even gone on record saying that nothing he's ever written will ever be as adored as "Twilight." Ouch...that's harsh. You fans are aware of who Stephen King is...right? I mean the man has been a consistently popular writer for decades, and many of his books have always been well received. As for many "Twilight" fans claiming that many of the adaptations off Stephen King's stories will never be well received, you fans are aware of films like "The Shining", "Pet Cemetery", and "Shawshank Redemption"..right? I mean many of the movies that are based on Steven King novels have won various Academy Awards; whereas "Twilight" has yet to even get a freaking nomination for one.
Look, I can understand why fans would be upset over a silly criticism, but it's only his freaking opinion, so why do you even care? Hell, Stephen King once said that he thought the "Beattles" were over rated too, but I don't see any "Beattles" fans out there wanting to lynch him for his comments. Therefore, please don't take what Stephen King said personally, as he has a right to his own opinion, and I'm glad that he was honest about it too. Seriously, I'd rather he told the truth about how he felt rather than giving us a PR bull s*** answer we all wanted to hear.
This brings me to my next point about how fans sometimes tend be hypocritical in their nonsensical arguments. Fans will often claim that they hate it when haters talk trash about the very thing they love, yet many of these same fans are openly allowed to condemn things they don't like. I'm sorry, but isn't that hypocritical? Are you honestly saying that it's okay to criticize something as long as it's something YOU hate too? What if the thing you're hating on happens to be something I love? Am I supposed to be okay with it, while paying nothing but respect towards something you love? And, god forbid I should ever say one...ONE...little criticism about something YOU like...right? You see how hypocritical that is?
Look, I know you might find haters offensive, but who freaking cares? There's always been haters. The "Beattles" are considered to be one of the greatest musical groups of all time according to most music experts, yet you still have people like King and others that claim they're over rated. I love the "Dark Knight", but you still have people that say that movie is pure garbage. "Avatar" is the highest grossing film of all time, yet there are still people that go out of their way to say it's one of the worst films of all time. In the end, people are going to believe what they want about something anyway; with logic or reason be damned.
Therefore, the important thing to remember here is that YOU like what you like, as that's all that really matters. I could see if you fans got upset if the haters didn't allow you to like what you like, but if all they're doing is talking, then let them freaking talk. As I said earlier to them, all their ranting accomplishes is gain more attention to a franchise they hate; hence it's counter productive.
Plus, why do you have to take a franchise so freaking personally that any type of criticism to said franchise affects you? If you stop to think about it, they're not insulting you at all. No, they're merely criticizing the franchise that has nothing to do with you; other than you liking it.
Heck, do you think Stephenie Meyer really cares about "Twilight" haters? Hell no. She's rich because of that franchise, so she doesn't care. And if she doesn't care, then why should you? Food for thought.
Closing Arguments to Both Parties
Whether you're a fan or hater of this franchise, it doesn't matter. The point is that it's nothing more than a damn franchise that has nothing to do with both parties, and it only has about as much affect on you as you allow it to. As I stated earlier to fans, I love it when fans show passion towards something they care about, but it should never come at telling others that they don't have the right to their own opinions. And, it doesn't give fans the right to condemn a great writer's work just because he was giving a direct answer to a question.
As for the haters, "Twilight" is a fad series that's destined to die out in a few years, so please stop. Nothing you say or do will change how immensely popular the franchise is right now, so it's pointless to bash the hell out of it for kicks. Seriously, if you can show this much passion towards hating something, then why don't you direct that same passion towards something beneficial to humanity?
Look, I apologize to everyone if I said anything that was truly offensive, as that was never my intent. No my intention was to merely share my thoughts on the whole situation, and hopefully make both parties realize how truly silly it is to worry about what other people think. In the end, it's just a fictional story anyway, so it doesn't matter.
More by this Author
A twelve year old boy is struggling with the concept of possibly losing his mom, due to an incurable illness. However, he soon finds comfort from a monster, whom helps him confront his deepest fear.
When a girl realizes that she's labeled as the "Duff" by her classmates to her more popular friends, she takes it upon herself to examine the social hierarchy of high school.
- 0Critic's Corner: My current thoughts on arguably the world's most controversial adult film star, Mia Khalifa
In this month's topic, we will be discussing arguably the world's most controversial adult film star, Mia Khalifa.