Watchmen: A Review

20th Century Fox, All Rights Reserved. (Or it might be Warner Bros.)
20th Century Fox, All Rights Reserved. (Or it might be Warner Bros.)

By Wes J. Pimentel

OK, so I saw it. Watchmen is a movie inspired by a comic book. Actually, it started as a series of comic books that later became, and was published as, a single volume.

A lot of people are asking what the big deal is about this movie, or the comic book on which it is based. My wife doesn't get it. She doesn't even get Batman, though, so I wouldn't exactly consider her views about super-hero movies the norm. Many people are asking what makes this movie different from others.

One thing that makes this particular story very unique is the way the writer inserted the presence of super-heroes into our nation's history, starting as far back as the 40's. This element is very original and it brings you right in, as you have a frame of reference for the story right from the beginning.

Upon seeing the previews of the movie, unless you're a die-hard comic book freak, you immediately notice that you don't recognize any of the characters. But, there is something familiar about all of them. The reason for this is that each character is either a composite of various heroes or a hero archetype. Basically, this was written as a commentary on the genre of comic books, rather than a simple story.

The author's aim at the time of its writing was to offer a very intimate and tangible version of the super-hero. Rather than fitting into the expected black and white, good guy/bad guy roles, these characters are painted with a realism that is almost disturbing. It is the humanity of each that gives the overall story its Herculean success as a narrative. I can see why this story has garnered so much praise. These characters are as real as you and I, only... they wear costumes. And fight crime. And have gadgets way cooler than my iPhone.

Now, many people claim that other than Dr. Manhattan (the blue guy), no other character has super-human abilities. Well, if you've seen the movie, you know there are things that these "people" do that defy physics, physiology, and the limitations of the human body.

Speaking of what they do... The fight scenes. Wow. The fight scenes are wonderful. They are fast and clean and really kick-ass (pun, I know). If you liked the action in 300, you will definitely enjoy this. They were directed by the same guy, Zack Snyder, and you can tell. The fight scenes have that signature momentum that made 300 so cool.

The movie is 2 hours and 45 minutes short. At the end of it I felt like I could have stayed and watched at least another hour of it. The story is so complete and rich, it's simply captivating. The actors do a superb job and really sell it.

There are a couple of interesting historical facts about the evolution of this project from comic book idea to movie. First, the idea. The man who wrote the original comic books, Alan Moore, had this idea and approached DC Comics about using one of their already-existing group of super-heroes for the project. They denied his use of those characters because most of them would not be able to be included in future issues, once the events in the story transpired.

Another interesting thing is how long it has taken for the film to come to fruition. The truth is that they have been trying to make this into a movie since 1986. That's 23 years. The voyage the film adaptation of this story has taken is truly amazing, but I won't go into it here. You can read about it here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watchmen. In recent history, 20th Century Fox sat on it for a while, before Warner Bros. took it and ran with it. There was some legal dispute as to who owned the rights to produce it, and Warner Bros. has ended up having to pay Fox a percentage of the take.

The last interesting bit of trivia is the fact that the original writer, Alan Moore, has never wanted to be affiliated with a film version of the story. He has even been reported to have stated that if it ever makes it to film he won't see the movie. He is of the opinion that there are elements to the story that can only be expressed in the comic medium. Too bad, 'cause that movie is hot!

So, that's it. In short, go see it. I've finished up here with a round-up of the main characters and actors.

The Watchmen characters and actors are as follows:

Dr. Manhattan - The blue guy. I think he's made out of radioactive plasma, although research into the actual comic books might offer the exact explanation. An interesting note on this character is that his penis gets more on-screen time than the actor who played Max Headroom. He's played by Billy Crudup. If you don't know who he is, look him up. He's done some work. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001082/

Silk Spectre - The chick. Hot. She has "no super-powers," but she's an incredible fighter and she has a supernaturally appealing physique. She is played by Malin Akerman. Although not a household name as of yet, she has also done some work. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0015196/

Ozymandias (The Smartest Man in the World) - The pretty blonde boy. I guess this guy's abilities lie in his use of his entire brain. This not only gives him unsurpassed intellect, but apparently makes him fast enough to catch a bullet. No super-power? Anyway, the guy's name is Matthew Goode. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0328828/

Rorschach - For those of us with a mental health background, this guy is freakin' awesome! What a cool concept. This is the guy with the ever-changing ink-blot mask. Now, without super-powers, how do you keep the ink-blot on the front of your face changing? My brother proposed that his mask might be made out of that "Hypercolor" stuff, like those t-shirts that highlight your armpit sweat. I guess. But, not really. Anyway, he, like the rest of the heroes, is a ridiculously good fighter, endowed with incredible speed, strength, and agility. He is played, quite well, by Jackie Earl Haley. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0355097/

The Comedian - This is the guy smoking a cigar in every preview. He is the coolest, assholiest super-hero ever. He is very similar to the Punisher. If I were a super-hero I would be a lot like this guy, except for one really major difference, which I will not spoil. He is a veteran and a die-hard patriot, who is disillusioned with the state of our country. He is played expertly by Jeffrey Dean Morgan. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0604747/

Nite Owl - This is the guy with the most super-heroest costume. He's the one who looks a lot like Batman. And his namesake is a nocturnal bird of prey. And he fights with a bunch of gadgets based on that animal. And... I think you get the point. He is the sort of straight-man of the bunch. I would guess that his political views are very conservative. He is played by Patrick Wilson. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0933940/

More by this Author

  • My Dad's a Homo
    68

    This is a picture of my father, Robert, holding my daughter, Fauna. By Wes J. Pimentel My father is gay. This is the story of how I found out and the emotions I felt at the time and have felt since. I will then share...


Comments 13 comments

Cris A profile image

Cris A 7 years ago from Manila, Philippines

I haven't seen the movie so I'd skip reading this hub! Unless there are no spoilers! Are there?


Schwag profile image

Schwag 7 years ago from Clarksville, TN Author

NO SPOILERS!! Well, tiny hinting ones, but I HATE when people tell me about a movie, so I respect that. I promise you won't be mad if you read it.


Cris A profile image

Cris A 7 years ago from Manila, Philippines

Now I'm definitely going to see it! It's nice to know that film adapations from comic books have been improving of late (Dark Knigh, Ironman etc.). They're given more soul, more relevance, more currency. I mean, who wants a happy Batman? Hopefully the days of eye candy superheroes are over. Thanks for this review Wes! Great job! :D


Paul Profitt profile image

Paul Profitt 7 years ago from England

I like the look of this film as I use to be a huge comic book fan, especially marvel comics. I have been wondering if the name of this movie Watchmen has any connection to a famous Marvel comic character called the Watcher.


Tom Cornett profile image

Tom Cornett 7 years ago from Ohio

Thanks Schwag, cool hub, now I gotta see the movie. :)


Abhishek87 profile image

Abhishek87 7 years ago from India

Read the hub, watched the trailer : I am definitely going for it... 

Thanks :)


Schwag profile image

Schwag 7 years ago from Clarksville, TN Author

Cris A - I hear you on the super-hero movies. I'm a kid at heart and I have always liked to see familiar characters on the big screen. I almost climaxed when I heard about the first Transformers movie. I'm glad my review helped to encourage you to see this.

Paul Profitt - Watchmen and The Watcher are totally unrelated. Thanks for the comment.

Tom - Thanks for the comment and the compliment. I hope you enjoy the show.

Abhishek87 - My pleasure. I hope you like it.


imadork profile image

imadork 7 years ago from St. Peters, MO

I'm looking forward to seeing this movie. Thanks for the review.


Schwag profile image

Schwag 7 years ago from Clarksville, TN Author

Dork - No probblem. I've been getting annoyed by other people's reviews of this movie. Instead of reviewing the movie, everyone seems to be reviewing the disparity between the comic books and the movie. Friggin' comic snobs.


jonaitis profile image

jonaitis 7 years ago from San Francisco

Nice review. Rorshach's mask is explained in the comic book as constructed of special fabric of heat sensitive liquid suspended in latex made by Dr. Manhattan for Kitty Genovese (who was raped and murdered in New York while her neighbors watched in the 1960s--a famous case); after her murder, Rorshach dons the mask made from this material in disgust with the crime, further cementing the theme of super heroes in our historical past. Pretty cool stuff.


Schwag profile image

Schwag 7 years ago from Clarksville, TN Author

jonaitis - Thanks for the comment, compliment, and the tip. I just looked up the girl's name. So, in the comic book is Kitty Genovese a hero also? I wonder why she would need such a garment and why the doctor would provide it to her.


jonaitis profile image

jonaitis 7 years ago from San Francisco

She wasn't a hero--I'm not sure of her need for the dress, maybe it was just another example of Alan Moore grounding the comic in historical fact. It was such an abominable crime and the resultant donning of the mask certainly fits with Rorshach's character.


Schwag profile image

Schwag 7 years ago from Clarksville, TN Author

jonaitis - Yeah, I see how relevant it is for Rorshach's character, I just don't see why this regular civilian would need a dress made of such stuff or why Dr. Manhattan, the guy working on saving the world, would spare a moment for some light tailoring.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working