The original has a greater re-watchability, in my opinion. Depp, a great actor in many kinds of roles, nevertheless seemed to be playing the character ironically, instead of authentically. Or maybe I felt he was mocking the character instead of truly inhabiting it. Wilder, also a great actor, brought his own famous warmth to Wonka. Depp and Burton, predictably, went for an edgy, creepy feel. The original seems more kid-friendly without being patronizing.