AM Hanson profile image 78

Would you rather see a 1-2hr long or 3-4hr long film version of a favorite book?

Would you rather see a shorter movie based on one of your favorite books that left out a lot of the little details (which may include your favorite little side story or chapter) but generally stuck to the main story, or see a longer movie that included EVERYTHING (even those parts which were less interesting or downright boring)?

This question is closed to new answers.

sort by best latest

sangre profile image87

Sp Greaney (sangre) says

4 years ago
Eric Calderwood profile image84

Eric Calderwood says

4 years ago
Georgie Lowery profile image96

Georgianna Lowery (Georgie Lowery) says

4 years ago
duffsmom profile image60

P. Thorpe Christiansen (duffsmom) says

4 years ago
  • AM Hanson profile image

    Adam M. Hanson (AM Hanson) 4 years ago

    a good example of this is the book "Dune." The miniseries are generally seen as being extremely superior to the 1984 film version, which cut out a good third of the book and took a good deal away from the whole "danger of being a hero/leader" message

MarcusJ profile image60

Marcus J. Guidry (MarcusJ) says

4 years ago