jump to last post 1-12 of 12 discussions (48 posts)

Rock Music Nearly Died Last Year

  1. BritishRock profile image62
    BritishRockposted 6 years ago

    The year end music charts have been released showing that 2010 was the worst year for rock music since 1960. In the UK only 3 rock songs were amoung the top 100 singles of 2010 the news isnt any better in the US Trains Hey Soul Sister is the only rock song to appear in the US top ten throughout the year.

    In the UK there hasnt been a massive rock breakthrough since the Artic Monkeys in 2006 and there popularity has decreased since then. Rock had 27 amoungst the biggest sellers in 2008 such a huge drop in 2010 with only 3 songs is remarkeble. The music scene is now dominated by Hipe Hop/RnB, Country or Pop. Rock needs new bands to emerge even a new style kids today would rather listen to Rap then Rock 2011 should be a bit better then 2010 with Coldplays fifth studio album but will that be the only rock album to enter the top ten in the US?. Mainstream music has few rock bands most of them from the 90,s who have continued into the 00,s such as Greenday, Foo Fighters, Pearl Jam but the only band there likely to keep charting high is Greenday cause they have purposely gone out of the way to make music relating to today while Pearl Jam refuses to sell out and continues to make whatever they want.

    Liam Gallgher lead singer of Oasis stated in 2005 that he thought most the bands today were too busy truing to be indie shitheads rather then wanting to be the next Elvis or Beatles. I agree with this statement bands need to stop being scared of being called sell outs and just do it or Rock will be forced underground.

    1. Wayne Orvisburg profile image77
      Wayne Orvisburgposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      I'm sure you are unaware if you live in the UK, but Pearl Jam did a Target commercial not too long ago. That's pretty well selling out in my opinion.

      1. BritishRock profile image62
        BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Doing an ad isnt selling out thats ridiculous.

    2. Shinkicker profile image88
      Shinkickerposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      I wouldn't worry about the charts BR. Rock bands are still very popular and pulling in massive crowds at festivals and stadium gigs. Also for the first time ever in the UK we have Rock Radio these past few years, a channel totally dedicated to Heavy Rock and of course Planet Rock is still going.

      Last year I was at Donington and almost 100,000 saw ACDC on one night then Rage Against the Machine on another. In fact more and more Rock Festivals have sprung up over the UK like and High Voltage, Sonisphere.

      So I think the singles charts have become an irrelevance.

      LONG LIVE ROCK n' ROLL!!! :-)

    3. profile image0
      klarawieckposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      The problem with rock is not that there are less bands. The problem is that bands like Coldplay are considered Rock bands!

      1. BritishRock profile image62
        BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        I like Coldplay but there not Rock.

        1. profile image0
          klarawieckposted 6 years ago in reply to this

          My point exactly

  2. profile image0
    ryankettposted 6 years ago

    Nothing wrong with a bit of indie, Liam Gallagher is a tool. I would much prefer bands to try and be innovative, rather than selecting another artist to imitate.

    It sounds like a case of grumpy old man syndrome. What happens when a great band does emerge? He slags them off, he even slagged The Libertines off, he doesn't acknowledge the talent of Pete Doherty. Liam Gallagher has no taste for music.

    And if it weren't for his brother, he wouldn't have made any decent music himself; we all know that Noel (actually a half decent chap) was the talent in that band.

    What's wrong with a bit of indie? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQ-bJj21 … ature=fvst

    And surely Oasis WERE considered Indie?

    1. BritishRock profile image62
      BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      Liam Gallagher is arrogant and a tool but he is still a ROCK GOD. I agree with Liam most of the British bands today are rubbish. Pete Doherty is a tool aswell and more well known for drug use and dating Kate Moss then his music.

      1. profile image0
        ryankettposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Pete Doherty may be a tool, but he does not lack talent. Although plenty of people would point out that he hasn't really done anything to harm anybody, and he should have the liberty and freedom to live his life how he wishes to live it.

        You could also argue that any British person who did not know who Pete Doherty before his relationship with Kate Moss knows absolutely nothing about music.

        The Xfactor crowd and red top reading neanderthals may not have known who Pete Doherty was before the tabloid scrambles, but anybody with half an eye on the music scene between 2001 and 2004 no doubt would have done.

        Doherty is the best song writer of his generation, up there with the best of them. A poet, an enigma. It's funny, because he is more loved in France than he is in Britain; there is nobody like him at the forefront of the scene, his is effectively a 21st century Oscar Wilde.

        http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbsR6pRjJHM

        Watch 2:25 onwards, and then tell me that he doesn't have talent. You may also be interested in the second highest rated comment:

        "exactly. i bet plently people have been brainwashed into hypocrisy by the modern media. you cant dislike pete´╗┐ doherty because of his drugs and then put a nirvana cd on."

        1. BritishRock profile image62
          BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

          I pointed out Petes drug problems because hes more famous for that Kurt Cobain is famous for his music. Pete Doherty song writer of his generation hahaha. If u want a artists who truely represents what this generation has been about its Eminem every teenager regardless of style listens to him Goths, Popular Kids all types of teenagers listen to Eminem hes been the voice of generation Y kids have grown up with him.

          He might not be a rock star and u might not like him but its true he was born in genration X and has been the voice of Y.

          1. profile image0
            ryankettposted 6 years ago in reply to this

            Well actually, Kurt Cobain is most famous for shooting himself in the head with a shot gun.

            I was referring to ROCK ARTISTS seeing as your thread title says ROCK ARTISTS, I am going to stop posting on your threads because you clearly have difficulties holding a consistent debate about a single topic.

            What Eminem has to do with rock is beyond me. If you want a debate about hip-hop then start a thread about hip-hop, I'll give you a good debate about that too <link snipped, no self-promoting links>

            1. BritishRock profile image62
              BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

              No u stated that Doherty was the song writer of his generation which is complete BULLSHIT I brought up Eminem because he is the real song writer on his generation he relates to everyone.

              Actually Kurt is famous for Music, Killing Himself and Drugs while Doherty is a nobody UK rockstar who never broke into mainstream and runs around making a fool of himself and tries to act cool and thinks its fun to take drugs and squirt needles at cameras he also seems to be faking most of his actions and just being influenced by past rockstars. Doherty is a joke hes more famous for dating Kate Moss and walking around like a TOOL then he is for music. Hes also a horrible father who takes drugs around his kids and has been in and out of jail countless times.

              1. profile image0
                ryankettposted 6 years ago in reply to this

                I would suggest that you refrain from making libelous comments, most specifically:

                "who takes drugs around his kids". You just never know who is watching, that comment is disgraceful and entirely unfounded. I have an associate who knows Lisa Moorish very well, and at no stage would she ever allow somebody to take drugs in front of her children. You should perhaps note that Doherty does not have "kids", he has one child, who he does not live with. 

                Yet again, you show very little knowledge. Nirvana sold hundreds of thousands of albums prior to Kurt Cobains death, tens of millions after. Nervermind sold 26 million albums after Cobain died in 1994, having sold far less than 1 million before his death. It was released in 1992.

                If you do want to continue to make statements about the welfare of other peoples kids, and subsequently ever get to talk to Lisa Moorish, then why not ask her which of her childrens fathers (Liam Gallagher and Pete Doherty) pay attention.

                1. BritishRock profile image62
                  BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

                  Liam Gallagher made the comments a while back so thats where I got the info from not talking to him personally but look it up. Nevermind went to number 1 in 1992 and knocked off Micheal Jacksons Dangerous album. For an album to do that it would have sold over a million copies easy so dont make up stuff u dont know about.

                  1. BritishRock profile image62
                    BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

                    MAY 31 2005.

                    LIAM GALLAGHER LASHES OUT AT PETE DOHERTY

                    Liam Gallagher has vowd to teach Pete Doherty a lesson in parenting as he feels that the babyshambles frontman is a terrible father.

                    Apparantly Gallagher went to pick up Molly to take her on an outing over the weekend and was pissed to find out Doherty had abandoned his son and was spending the weekend with Kate Moss and her daughter Lily Grace.

                    That was just part of an articile made 5 years ago see thats where I got my information that he was a bad father.

                    And also Nirvanas In Utero album also went to number 1 before Kurts death haha.

                  2. profile image0
                    ryankettposted 6 years ago in reply to this

                    Before Death Sales in the hundreds of thousands.

                    After Death Sales of all Nirvana's albums soared in the immediate aftermath of Cobain's death. Nevermind, recorded in 1991, has gone on to sell some 26 million copies worldwide since his death.

                    Source: The Independent

                    I do have to wonder why you are suddenly quoting American charts, as an individual who set up an account dedicated to British Rock. If you want to keep the conversation British, just like I do, then it should be known that Nevermind peaked at #7 in the UK album charts.

  3. Mikeydoes profile image79
    Mikeydoesposted 6 years ago

    Parabelle and 10 years are my favorites.

    I have never heard anything like Parabelle before.

    I think the problem is the radio plays crap... I can't even listen to my Chicago radio stations. I actually finally heard a 10 years song on the radio, but Parabelle(who I like better) hasn't had any play that I am aware of.

    1. mrpopo profile image88
      mrpopoposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      Both great bands. If you like Parabelle I think you'll like Evans Blue, it's the same singer (before he left the band).

      1. Mikeydoes profile image79
        Mikeydoesposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Yeah, it surely would have been a great treat if I didn't know those songs yet! Kevin Matisyn is my favorite.

        I was extremely upset when he left Evans Blue. I am glad the break up happened. Evans Blue has a new singer, not quite like Kevin Matisyn, but I really like it. But Parabelle's new CD really is incredible.

        Listening to Evans Blue and now Parabelle I can really see why he left. Evans Blue is all about good hard rock, but it seems Kevin wanted to dabble around, and my God do I love that he did that.

        Not to mention I gave the new singer of Evans Blue a try, and I really liked it as well. It doesn't compare to Parabelle in my books, but still another good band that I will surely continue to listen to.

  4. DaveL profile image82
    DaveLposted 6 years ago

    Blame it on the slew of crappy TV shows here in the UK where talentless muppets via for 15 minute karaoke careers after shovelling burgers all their lives. Unfortunately the British public as a whole laps this rubbish up.

    Then again, on the other hand, a lot of the rock that has been in the charts the last 20 years (since Nirvana and Grunge finally made and impact) has been pretty insipid and unimaginative, and maybe that's why it's fallen out of favour so quickly too.

    I don't think that's a bad thing. The world doesn't need another Crapplay, Shite Patrol or their ilk stinking up the airwaves. It just makes your average pop music loving person think themselves alternative and rock when they're not, really.

  5. profile image0
    china manposted 6 years ago

    There is no rock music because the fire has gone out.  Protesting against war is now unamerican and the UK are too shamefaced about our support for the Bush Cheney money making attack on Iraq to speak out.  Everyone is pretending that racism has gone away, raunchy is labelled sexist, and the creationists are busy stamping out the fires of freedom and hope and self expression.  Schools are sucking the life out of the young people retarding their creative expression while not teaching them very much.

    Here in China they love KTV (kariaoke) and so most pop music is made so that anyone can sing it, creating a similar situation to the dumbing down of music by the tv talent shows.  There is a growing Chinese rock music segment but it is going in directions that rock and roll might not recognise, except when it strays across into heavy metal.

    Maybe 2012 will be the end of the rock world.

    1. SomewayOuttaHere profile image59
      SomewayOuttaHereposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      lol 'end of the rock world'?...... i don't think so....neva eva!

      1. profile image0
        china manposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        So you are listening to new rock music every day ???  or are you listening to Elton, Stones, and all those strange American rockers who never really got away from the kiddie music of country and Western ? big_smile big_smile

        1. SomewayOuttaHere profile image59
          SomewayOuttaHereposted 6 years ago in reply to this

          .. lol  ....kiddie music?  lol.....not sure what is considered new on 'regular' radio..they usually play anything good over and over and ruin it for me......i listen to satellite etc and catch some great music old and newer....Slash was havin' a great time in 2010 recording music with a variety of artists (Astbury and Lemmie)....could be a slump...i recall in part of the 80's there was a slump and i turned to R&B and reggae for awhile because some of the music coming out sucked including what some of my favs were producing at the time....but it's neva eva goin' away....there's too many who love R&R....and many R&R artists who love what they do.....

          ...BP mentioned 'sniff' music below ..... i agree whole heartedly....can't stand the whining of some it.....there's no meaning, no depth...just whining....

          hey CM!....good to run into you!

          1. profile image0
            china manposted 6 years ago in reply to this

            Good to bump against you too SO - time difference is a bummer for chatting - I normally open up just after everyone has gone to bed and quit just as your afternoon is getting thin big_smile

            1. SomewayOuttaHere profile image59
              SomewayOuttaHereposted 6 years ago in reply to this

              lol....i see yor messin' around this a.m. (my time)....

              ....from yur peace luvin' R&R luvin' canadian nutter.....

              1. profile image0
                china manposted 6 years ago in reply to this

                just off to bed in a minute - and we are just off to Beihai on the coast tomorrow where it will hopefully be a little warmer!

                keep on rockin' - g'night !

                1. SomewayOuttaHere profile image59
                  SomewayOuttaHereposted 6 years ago in reply to this

                  .......have a great time...i'll have to google Beihai to see what it looks like...

                  ...later  big_smile   ....off to work...

  6. tony0724 profile image61
    tony0724posted 6 years ago

    I think rock is pretty much dead. There are a couple of artist who have put out some good songs. But they used to put out good albums. No Beatles or Led Zeppelins in the past 20 years or so.

    1. BritishRock profile image62
      BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      There cant be any new Beatles or Zepplin nobody can copy there styles but the 90,s were full of great bands so last 10 years has been empty but the 90,s did have Radiohead, Oasis, Blur, Pearl Jam, Alice In Chains list goes on.

      1. profile image0
        china manposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Oasis and Blur big_smile  we are talking rock and roll - not wock and woll big_smile

  7. Broken Poet profile image60
    Broken Poetposted 6 years ago

    rock music is dying out and is to be replaced by a new breed called R&B
    Do i like it? No
    Should it be happening? No
    Can i stop it? No

    the sad truth is rock music, and alternative rock music is a dying breed and soon there will be nothing on the radios but... 'sniff' songs with no depth and a lite and or techno beat..... 'sniff'

    1. BritishRock profile image62
      BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      I like what u said I feel the same way.

  8. I am DB Cooper profile image68
    I am DB Cooperposted 6 years ago

    I've been waiting a long time for a band to come along and break through the fog of mediocrity in the music scene right now. It seems like every new artist is manufactured, either by American Idol or Disney pumping out the next big teenybopper.

    Even in the 90's, bands that managed to break through were self-destructive and didn't last long. Nirvana made hair bands irrelevant overnight, but we all know how that ended. Then Oasis was being compared to The Beatles, but they got caught up in the fame and squabbled amongst themselves instead of working on making good music.

    I still think rock music has some life left in it, it's just that the quality at the present time isn't there. Eventually the Nickelbacks and Coldplays will fade away and hopefully some good bands will take their place.

  9. BritishRock profile image62
    BritishRockposted 6 years ago

    Id rather you leave cause most of the stuff that comes out of your motuh is utter rubbish to even know who Kurt is u have to know his music first then learn about the suicide while Doeherty has his ugly face all over controversial moments for stupid acts as he tries to make his band more popular and he should focus on his music more instead of being a wannabe rocker who took things a little too far.

  10. profile image0
    ryankettposted 6 years ago

    You have to say that Oasis are influential too, their influence has already been seen in the Artic Monkeys and Kasabian, amongst others. They sold over 20 million copies of Whats the story morning glory.

    1. BritishRock profile image62
      BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      Coldplay have also claimed to been influenced by Oasis aswell.

      1. profile image0
        ryankettposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Coldplay are influenced by anybody that they believe they can plagiarise, I can identify at least four or five guitar riffs on each of their albums. They are frauds.

  11. Mighty Mom profile image90
    Mighty Momposted 6 years ago

    I HATE Coldplay! Bleh!!! Simply don't know what all the fuss is about!

    This band has been around since the early 1990s but survive and thrive and one of their songs has been used as intro to Boardwalk Empire (HBO I think) and the movie Inception.
    I think their name is a hoot.
    I like their jingle jangle guitars and tambourine.
    Singing... not so much. He tries to sound British and he's from SF.
    But the guitars, chord changes, etc. are delightful psychedelic "revivalist" rock a la all the greats of the '60s.
    This particular song reminds me of "Lightning Crashes" by Live.

    Anyway, my two cents.



    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rFoop72c … re=related

    1. BritishRock profile image62
      BritishRockposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      Coldplay made there first album in 1999 in the early 90,s they were still in school haha. Lightning Crashes by Live is a fantastic song.

  12. Mighty Mom profile image90
    Mighty Momposted 6 years ago

    Coldplay is very polarizing for some reason. People either love them or hate them. Nobody is lukewarm about them.

    Live's "Throwing Copper" holds many great memories for me.
    The '90s had some really, really great music.
    I must be getting old as I don't like very much of today's homogenized bubblegum synth pop crap.

 
working