Are 'turntablists' (DJs who 'scratch', etc.) legitimate musicians? I believe they are. Anyone who has seen DJ Jazzy Jeff (DJ for 'Fresh Prince' Will Smith) in action might just be convinced of this if you are skeptical. And he's not the only one, not by a long shot...just check out some turntablists--especially turntable battles--on YTube.
Well, that's my obviously biased 5 cents. But this aynt 'bout me...
What's YOUR take? Is a DJ who manipulates records/CDs well a true musician? Why or why not?
Well I do particularly like turntable musician,mainly because it's mostly tied to RAP,Which I think is a ruination of the music industry. As far as turntable being a musician,why not,I've seen people playing the spoons and consider them musicians,it all boils down to rhythm and timing and not everyone has that gift.
Considering that saws, hammers, garbage cans and lids and everything else including the kitchen sink has been used as an instrument, many having been recorded and purchased by the public, I would agree they are musicians.
I suppose a distinguishing feature might be in how good any of these items can be made to sound and the reactions they produce in people.
Perhaps then, the thing to do is agree on what constitutes a "legitimate musician"
DJ's are rhythmics (my own new term) but they are not musicians. They only have grasp of the rhythm, but don't understand the full concept of music, such as melody, harmony, etc. Unless they have learned to play an instrument, they are not musicians.
...i haven't read all the posts....i use a turntable but not to 'scratch' anything......just for me....listening to analog and some new digital......... i luv my turntable.... ....am i a musician?...no!...i just like music and have my favourites....
This is an interesting question. I wouldn't class a 'turntablist' in the same bracket as say a drummer or pianist, however they can be incredibly talented with a great understanding of music.
A definition of a musician I found is:
a person who makes music, especially a performer of music.
Using that definition, I'm not sure whether DJ's make music or not. They don't (in most cases) make the records they play, but they do create the sound output (i.e. the mix) which is often unique and could be classed as music.