Scrooge: Which Actor Played Him Best?

Who was the best Scrooge on film?

We're still in November, but in a few days, this author will be eagerly dusting off his Christmas DVDs and settling down with a carton of eggnog to enjoy a handful of movie adaptations of A Christmas Carol.

The British character actor Alastair Sim has traditionally claimed the title of best Scrooge, for his sterling performance in the 1951 film. But does he deserve the accolade, or are there other actors who have excelled in the role? The competition is surprisingly fierce.

One of the earliest screen Scrooges was Seymour Hicks, in the 1935 film Scrooge. He played the old skinflint as a truly miserable, unlikeable character, unattractively scruffy and unkempt. Some screen Scrooges have been bumbling in a way that is almost endearing, but Hicks is a genuine wretch, never a loveable rogue. The tone of the film is exceptionally bleak, opening in dreary fashion with the sound of a Christmas carol being badly played through a thick London fog. Hicks, despite being forgotten in the wake of later portrayals of the miser, turned in a performance that rivals Sim and may well be closer in spirit to the dark, menacing Scrooge of Charles Dickens's original novel.

Another overlooked depiction of Ebenezer Scrooge is in the 1977 BBC version. The entire production, despite running just over one hour, is one of the most faithful adaptations of the book to date, capturing exquisitely the haunting, ghost-story elements of the tale. Michael Hordern plays the title role in this version; coincidentally, he was a marvellously memorable Marley's Ghost in the 1951 film.

George C Scott's performance in the 1984 TV movie, directed by Clive Donner, has also received high praise. Here again is a version that reflects much of the bleak, gritty reality of the story's Dickensian origins, and Scott plays Scrooge as a severe taskmaster, yet a man of apparent principle. And of course Dickens's Scrooge was, albeit in a strange way, a man of principle, opposed to the "humbug" of Christmas precisely because he perceived it as a hypocrisy.

Dozens of other actors have taken on the part over the decades, including Patrick Stewart, Albert Finney, Basil Rathbone and Jim Carrey. Hicks, Hordern and Scott give Sim a run for his jealously guarded money, but perhaps there is good reason why Sim remains the silver screen's best-loved Scrooge. No one presented quite such a mirthful and inspiring transformation as Sim. It is hard not to bubble over with gladness along with Sim as he tosses his quill aside and collapses with glee at the end of A Christmas Carol (1951). He gives us the mean-spirited miser, but later provides us with a redeemed Scrooge who warms the heart, brought merrily and unforgettably alive by the spirit of the festive season.

Read the story of Ebenezer Scrooge online.

More by this Author

Comments 13 comments

Manutdmumto4 profile image

Manutdmumto4 6 years ago

Alastair Sim is by far my favourite scrooge, the old ones are usually the best! Well Written Hub, a really enjoyable read. x

TahoeDoc profile image

TahoeDoc 6 years ago from Lake Tahoe, California

Nice work, very enjoyable to read. thanks.

KoffeeKlatch Gals profile image

KoffeeKlatch Gals 6 years ago from Sunny Florida

I agree Alastair Sim is my favorite scrooge. He plays the part to perfection. I enjoyed reading your write-up.

Silver Poet profile image

Silver Poet 6 years ago from the computer of a midwestern American writer

George C. Scott was my favorite Scrooge. I am also a fan of the book. Thanks for the hub!

kev 5 years ago

I enjoyed Sim, Finney and Stewart in the role. But I found George C Scott outstanding.

Rattigan profile image

Rattigan 5 years ago from St Catharines, Ontario Author

George C Scott's performance has grown on me the more I've fallen in love with Dickens's book, I must admit.

John 5 years ago

My favourite is Alastair Sim but i, although disliking Jim Carrey, like his animated version.

I vaguely remember George C Scott's version which i thought was good, but, still, Alastair Sim will always be best Scrooge for me.

phillip 5 years ago

Albert Finney is my fave scrooge.

Shawn 5 years ago

Michael Caine was excellent!

John 5 years ago

not Henry Winkler Heyyyyy

howard 5 years ago

i always thought alistair sim was the best, that is until I saw george c scott who is definitely the greatest ever portrayal

No Name 4 years ago

I say Michael Caine leaves them ALL in the dust.

Donnie 3 years ago

George C Scott is by far the best. His raspy and greedy demeanor is legendary in the role. My second is Seymour Hicks. Although Hicks played the role in 1935, I have it on tape and DVD and have watch it every Christmas Eve for 20 years. Yes I know.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article