Electric Breast Pumps vs. Manual Breast Pumps – Which is Best?

New moms have many choices in types and styles of breast pumps. With so many varieties available today, choosing the right breast pump can be confusing and difficult. The biggest decision in choosing the right breast pump is choosing whether to use a manual breast pump such as an Avent Isis breast pump or an electric one such as an Ameda or Mandela breast pump.

Manual Breast Pumps

If you plan to breastfeed often and use a pump only on occasion, a manual pump may be the best choice. Manual pumps are smaller and lighter than electric breast pumps and so you can easily slip one in your purse or diaper bag to carry with you. The Avent Isis breast pump is a popular manual pump, some of which even offer an electronic memory to pump at the manual pace you set.

Another advantage to manual breast pumps is their affordable cost. They tend to cost less than electric breast pumps, so if you are looking for a breast pump for only occasional use, manual pumps provide the most economical option. If you are unsure how often you will pump, consider getting a manual breast pump first and then investing in an electric one if you find you are pumping often. Finally, manual pumps give mothers control over the suction and speed of the pump, offering more flexibility during the process than an electric pump.

On the down side, manual pumps require arm and hand strength, and if you pump often with a manual pump, you may find yourself growing tired or unable to pump enough milk for a feeding.

Electric Breast Pumps

Electric breast pumps are designed for women who pump often, especially multiple times per day. If you are away from your baby for long stretches of time—at work during the day, for instance—an electric pump will be the best option. Electric breast pumps pump more milk in a shorter amount of time, and when used regularly can also increase the total amount of milk mothers produce. Some electric models also offer a double pumping feature, further reducing the time it takes to pump in a sitting.

The drawbacks to electric pumps is that they are often heavy, noisy, and more costly than manual pumps. However, manufacturers are making them lighter and more affordable as time goes on, so these disadvantages are becoming less prohibitive.

Image Credit: planet_oleary, Flickr

More by this Author


1 comment

Best Breast pump 5 years ago

Do u think this manul breast pump is good, i have double breast pump, can u please wexplain it more with some reviews

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working