Pros and Cons of Cluster Grouping Gifted Children
What Is Cluster Grouping?
Cluster grouping is when gifted and talented and/or high-achieving students are identified as being within the top five percent and placed in a standard, mixed-ability (heterogeneous) classroom within their grade. Groupings of three to six or five to eight are typical cluster groups. If there are more than eight to ten students meeting the necessary criteria, another cluster group is typically formed and placed in a different class. Cluster groups are instructed by a teacher who has ideally undergone specialized training in differentiated learning, gifted instruction, or both. Cluster grouping is typically used in upper elementary grades but has been successfully used from kindergarten to high school. Instructional options typically including but are not limited to: curricular enrichment, extensions, higher-order thinking skills, differentiation, compacting, accelerating, and adding more complexity.
Cluster Grouping Model
The Pros of Cluster Grouping Gifted Children
- Gifted students often feel more comfortable among students with similar ability. Cluster groupings help facilitate this comfort level by increasing the number of high achieving students within one class.
- Teachers tend to teach to the center of ability. Cluster groups tend to raise the level of instruction. Cluster groupings typically result in more challenging tasks that result in increased academics.
- Grouping gifted students together often helps teachers challenge those students more easily.
- Once a student is identified as gifted, special instruction is often legally required. Cluster groupings can fulfill this mandated instruction in a cost-effective, full-time program where students benefit each day.
- Any attempt at improving instruction for gifted children is often an improvement over the norm.
- Cluster groupings provide all-day instructional opportunities that are unavailable to gifted students who merely attend out-of-class enrichment opportunities.
- Cluster groupings do not siphon all of the high-achieving students into one class. Gifted-qualified students and some of the high-achieving students are often placed in the cluster group. The remainder of the high-achieving students are placed into the other classes. These high-achieving students benefit in this model too, as they have new opportunities to become academic leaders.
Links to Gifted and Talented Child Resources
- Gifted and Talented Characteristics in Children
Gifted checklists will not help you identify gifted children. This site details the proper way to identify gifted children and why gifted education is so important.
- Links to Gifted and Talented Child Resources
This is a comprehensive list of resources for gifted and talented children and their parents. Please feel free to add more in the comments and I'll incorporate them into the list. Associations National...
- OLSAT test secrets for gifted and talented kids
Most schools have some type of gifted and talented program for the top level academic students in their grade level. A lot of schools use the Olsat test to qualify kids for these gifted and talented programs. If you value your kids future and want...
- How Do You Know If your Child is Gifted or Talented?
All children are unique and develop mentally, socially and creatively at varying levels. Some children have strengths and talents that are much more developed than their peers in one or more areas....
The Cons of Cluster Grouping Gifted Children
- Cluster grouping in itself is not effective without worthwhile instruction. Merely placing all of the highest achieving students in one classroom will neither form a cluster group nor automatically result in improved academics. Districts may form cluster groups that are not truly beneficial because of the tendency to skim the “cream” off the top of all classes in order to form one large clustering of gifted or high-achieving students.
- In order for cluster groups to be successful, teachers should ideally receive specialized training. Unfortunately, this isn’t always possible or even likely to occur.
- Teaching a cluster group requires dedication and motivation. Not all teachers have this passion. Finding teachers who truly believe in the model or even gifted education can be a problem.
- Cluster groupings are typically only beneficial when the remainder of the class does not contain difficult or highly demanding students. This doesn’t always occur, and when it does, it often causes resentment from other teachers.
- Placing the right students within a cluster group is always a primary concern. Parental pressure, new students, borderline students, twice-exceptional students, and highly talented yet unmotivated students all pose a challenge to the cluster model.
- In a true cluster model, teachers are often rotated every two or three years. Staff training or the lack of training is a primary concern when this occurs.
- Districts may fail to provide out-of-class enrichment opportunities for gifted students who have been placed within cluster groupings. Cluster groupings seldom provide a truly gifted education program and do not take the place of gifted instruction.
- On paper, cluster grouping gifted students seems to make sense, but little evidence is available to attest to its effectiveness.
The Needs of Gifted and Talented Students
Conclusion: Cluster Grouping of Gifted Students
Cluster grouping gifted students tends to be the second most effective method of instruction for gifted students. On paper, cluster grouping gifted students allows them to receive gifted instruction throughout the day, but in reality, this differentiated instruction may or may not occur in a heterogeneous group. Simply lumping students together doesn’t necessarily result in gifted instruction that is beneficial, and it may result in instruction within areas in which students have not qualified as gifted.
More by this Author
A complete list of Newbery Award winners by grade level from 1922 to the present.
Emotionally disturbed gifted children are often denied adequate services. This site details why twice exceptional gifted children are not identified. It also details best-practice instruction for students who have...
A list of Newbery Award winners, Caldecott Medal Winners, and the best books by grade level.
What do you think about cluster grouping gifted children?
No comments yet.