How To Communicate With Your Child

What's Wrong With Your Question?

I was out in my backyard with my dogs this afternoon when I heard a neighbour yelling at her son, "What the hell is wrong with you?" Triggered some memories, it did. My mother used to ask that question frequently and in a similar tone. I couldn't see the young boy but I could feel him shrinking. When I got asked that question a list of what's wrong with me the length or better of a roll of toilet paper would scroll through my mind's eye.....I'm this, I'm that, I'm the other thing, none of it good. That question would set me to listing ad nauseum, quite literally. I'd struggle to pick an item off the list that seemed to best fit what my mother appeared to be looking for and meekly deliver it hoping against hope to put a quick end to the misery of it. I won't bore you with the details of what generally followed it is not my intention for writing this but I will tell you that once it was all over I used to stomp around the block a few times asking myself, "Why can't she ask me a question I can answer?" I vowed, as I often did when I felt my parental unit had something array with her wiring, that when I had children of my own, I would not ever, ever I tell you, ask them that stupid, dumb, dumb question.

My children are grown now and I never did ask them that question and I'll tell you why. It is a great question to ask if you want to introvert some one and cave them in but if you want information, if you are looking for facts, or heaven forbid, the truth of a situation forget it. It’s right up there with, “Where were you when God was handing out _______? If you really want to get information out of someone, it doesn’t make much sense then to push them in. It makes far more sense to draw them out.

The question combined with the mood level that it is delivered with hardly evokes confidence from the person being asked. They cannot feel confident that their communication will be received,acknowledged or duplicated in any way whatsoever. They cannot feel confident that whatever is “wrong”is going to be landing on an empathetic, understanding or compassion target. Therefore, they cannot answer the question in a confident manner. Not many of us wake up in the morning and think to themselves, “Gee, I’d like to communicate with a hostile person today!” or better still, confide in one.

The other tragedy of a negative question such as "What the hell is wrong with you?" is that once it's hard wired in there, a person starts asking themselves "What the hell is wrong with me?" accompanied by a low and often antagonistic or hostile mood level. If you want to experiment with this, simply ask yourself the question and watch the toilet paper roll turn into a scroll! Your mind begins to lock up just like your computer - too many windows open! Some questions start a negative process and some start a positive one. It is well past time that we started to consciously begin to run positive processes ourselves and each other!

The question I asked my children instead was, “What is happening?” That’s it – simple. The child then gets to tell you exactly what is going on, right here, right now and then you get to clear up whatever it was that was behind the behavior you, as the parental unit, were objecting to. Sometimes there is something bothering the child and at other times it is just a matter of them not understanding of something or of misunderstanding something. The question, “What is happening?” allows the child to look rather than list. It allows you to be an effective parent.

Now I ask you, what the hell is wrong with that? Nothing!

Put Your Listening Ears On

Once you have asked your child an effective question it is imperative that you then listen to the answer. I mean listen, not stand there thinking about what you are going to make for dinner tonight or having to call so and so about the such and such, I mean be there and listen!

When you ask a question you are at cause, and the child is at the effect of the question. When your child responds to the question he is at cause and you are at the effect of his or her communication. Breath out, breath in! If you throw the proverbial ball than be there to catch it when it is thrown back to you. Too often adults will ask a question of a child and then go completely absent, let their mind wander off and not even mentally or emotionally be there to receive the child's response. On the other hand, these very same parents are too often heard to say, "Listen when I'm talking to you!" Children learn by example, they model. Be a communication role model and LISTEN!

Acknowledge!

Once you have asked your child a question and you have received a response then acknowledge that response. "Okay" or "Good" or "Thank You" or "I got that". It lets your child know that his or her communication has been received and understood. When you fail to acknowledge the receipt of your child's communication they will do one of two things, they will withdraw and cease communicating with you or they will over reach and start to over communicate. Neither is an optimum result for either you or your child. Once you have asked a question, received an answer and acknowledged the answer that cycle of communication is complete. If you have further communication to give or another question to ask do so only after you have completed the last cycle before starting the next.

Very often parents will communicated over the top of their child or they will continue to question or talk to their child without ever indicating to the child that they have been heard. The devastating effects of incomplete communication cycles can be seen throughout families and indeed throughout society. People talk over top of each other. People question another and before that person can even respond the party who initiated the conversation has their attention somewhere else entirely. People withdraw from communicating and avoid it or they over compensate and rattle away at hyper speed. The solution is so simple - complete the cycle!

The truth of the situation is that incomplete communication cycles cause breakdowns in relationships while complete communication cycles build and foster relationships. The ability to communicate is a gift, and it is a gift that we all to often abuse, misuse and take for granted. Our bodies,animals, plants, weather, seasons, indeed our entire planet operate in natural cycles, it only stands to reason then that we should avail ourselves of and apply the natural cycle of communication.

Parents are often heard to complain that their children talk non stop. They do so only because they are at the effect of too many incomplete communication cycles. Control is the ability to start - change - stop. It's physics, once a thing is set in motion it stays in motion until acted upon. An acknowledgment is the correct action to take to end a communication cycle! Put you and your child in control of your communication.

More by this Author


Comments 11 comments

Winsome profile image

Winsome 6 years ago from Southern California by way of Texas

Great topic. Another one I hate to hear is "Have you always been this stupid?" You can just hear the little thoughts going: "When did I start being stupid?---Wait, am I stupid?--How can I answer that?" I like questions like: "How did a kid like you get so smart? (or sweet etc.) That lets them go inward with happy thoughts. =:)


raisingme profile image

raisingme 6 years ago from Fraser Valley, British Columbia Author

That made me laugh "Have you always been this stupid?" Always is a long, long time and the likelihood of a child answering "Not until March 5, 2005", is not going to happen!

The purpose of asking a question is to get an answer. The "how did 'a kid like you' get so smart?" kind of feels like the person who asked the question is asking a question within a question - "a kid like you". Too often adults ask a question of a child and do not stay present with them and receive or acknowledge the answer. Unless one really wanted to know the mechanics of the child's "smart" or "sweet" and is willing to let the child express to them how they came to be thus and so, it would be much better to acknowledge the child with a comment. "It was very smart of you to think of doing it ____ that way" or "That was very sweet of you to do..." That way the child is acknowledged and feels appreciated. That is what the adult is wanting to accomplish anyway in asking that question. It's easier and better to just cut to the chase.

It is important to ask effective and appropriate questions. I was in the emergency at the hospital years ago in the throws of a miscarriage - the specialist walked into the room and asked me, "What are you up to?" I answered, "5'4"?" Let's give each other a break and start asking some intelligent questions - who knows, we might even start getting some intelligent answers!


Winsome profile image

Winsome 6 years ago from Southern California by way of Texas

You are right of course. I try too hard sometimes to "kid" with the children when what they really need is a patient, well-thought out mature response or question. That was very smart of you to think of answering my comment in that way.

Have you always been this smart? =:)


raisingme profile image

raisingme 6 years ago from Fraser Valley, British Columbia Author

Nope, I had to travel up the ladder from dog dead stupidity to get the idea of knowing about something to know about something to applying it - and practice, practice, practice - I am still practicing communication. But I figure that is okay because lawyers practice law and doctors practice medicine - I haven't seen a sign in either office that says license to master law or master medicine - so I figure I can practice away to my heart's content...the journey started in childhood when I ask myself the question in regards to my mother, "Why doesn't she ask me a question I can answer?" Your comment has given me an idea for another Hub so THANK YOU!


Lamme profile image

Lamme 6 years ago

Excellent advice every parent should heed. I can't imagine asking one of my kids "what the hell is the matter with you?" I can see how that would devastate them and cause them to have little self-esteem. Our job as parents is to try and lift our children up, find out what the problem is and deal with it. A question like this said in anger and is a put down, not a request for information.


Property-Invest profile image

Property-Invest 6 years ago from London

Great hub, it's so important to teach children not to get a negative mindset.


raisingme profile image

raisingme 6 years ago from Fraser Valley, British Columbia Author

I agree it is VERY IMPORTANT - get the idea of the kind of future that we could individually and collectively create if we began, in earnest, to run positive processes on ourselves and each other rather than negative ones - wherein we enable rather than disable!


2uesday profile image

2uesday 6 years ago from - on the web, I am 2uesday.

It is an interesting subject - that effect of what is said to us in childhood can become embeded into part of who we become. I believe that is true. I find your style of writing is interesting and enjoyable to read.


raisingme profile image

raisingme 6 years ago from Fraser Valley, British Columbia Author

Embedded indeed! Implanted through a forceful and painful process of having the ideas of another enforced upon you destroying your ability to perceive and intend with any degree of accuracy. It is used to control, not to guide or teach or assist the child to learn. The wielder of those swords er words does not even stop to exam the effects or the consequences of their utterances some of which last a lifetime and more as they get past on from generation to generation. As Socrates is quoted as saying, "An unexamined life is not worth living." Gives a whole new meaning to the phrase "Watch your mouth"!


sofs profile image

sofs 6 years ago

A great way to speak about flawed or dysfunctional communication. I like your easy and simple way of handling the subject. Good hub!!


raisingme profile image

raisingme 6 years ago from Fraser Valley, British Columbia Author

Thank you, that means a lot coming from what I have read of your writing!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working