4 easy steps to great pot roast every time!

Fork tender pot roast


How to make great pot roast

Nothing beats the homey mouthwatering aromas of a pot roast percolating in the oven on a crisp day…permeating the house with the promise of a great, succulent and fall apart tender meal to come! Unfortunately, too many pot roasts end up disappointing with a watery sauce, dry overcooked meat, and a flavor that doesn't live up to the promise of that aroma.

Here are four secrets to great pot roast every time, regardless of the recipe you're using.

4 Secrets to great pot roast

1 choose the right cut of meat

For a pot roast--a truly great pot roast--you need to skip right over those expensive, lean and tender offerings at the butcher counter and head straight to the cheapest, gnarliest and scariest looking hunk of meat that you can find (which is great, as these cuts generally retail for next to nothing, and these are the cuts that really shine in a long slow pot roast braise)!

Firstly, these very well worked muscles tend to have the best meaty flavor, and secondly, because they are so full of collagen (the stuff that makes it very chewy if cooked quickly) they will make a rich and thickened sauce with no need for additional thickeners like flour or cornstarch.

Over long slow cooking collagen dissolves into gelatin, which is a natural thickener, and also very rich tasting. Lean meats without collagen tend to become very dry in a long braise, and also do little to thicken the sauce.

Try cuts from the upper shoulder (chuck) the brisket, the skirt area or the bottom round. If in doubt, look for lots of scary looking connective tissue, and look for the cheapest stuff on offer!

2 Brown it well

There is an enzymatic reaction called the maillard reaction that occurs when meat is cooked over a high temperature. You need to really pre fry that meat well to get a rich and deep brown all over before adding liquid, as once you add liquid the temperatures can never get high enough to brown the meat.

Take your time, and in your heaviest Dutch oven or cast iron, slowly sear that meat all over until browned in every corner and crevice. Making a pot roast is truly effortless hands-free cooking, and it really pays to spend 20 minutes or so taking your time with this step.

4 Don't add too much liquid

Whether using water, stock, beer or wine, this is not a stew it's a braise, and you don’t want to dilute the taste of the rich gravy with too much liquid. Start with about 1 cup or so, and you can always add more if needed later.

4 Cook it slow and cook it covered!

Nothing will dry out a pot roast faster than a heavy boil or a steady stream of steam escaping from the pot. You want to use a very heavy cooking pot, a Dutch oven or heavy ceramic works great for slow pulsing radiant heat and you should never have your oven set higher than 350, and lower than this is even better if you’re not in a rush!

The heavenly rich taste of a great pot roast occurs as a result of gentle steam rising to the lid, condensing and drip/basting back over the meat. You need to have a very tight fitting lid to get this effect, and if you have steam escaping, the flavor will disappoint, and you'll also dry out the meat (no basting!)

If you're lid isn't tight enough, use foil to crimp a good seal on before closing the lid.

Great pot roast every time!

Follow these four easy steps, and you will have a heavenly pot roast awaiting you every time!

making pot roast

More by this Author

Comments 20 comments

Marye Audet profile image

Marye Audet 9 years ago from Lancaster, Texas

YAY! I just got a 20 lb hunk of pot roast on sale for 1.49 a lb and planned on cutting it today..so I will be sure to leave some nice size roasts and check this out..Thanks!

John D Lee profile image

John D Lee 9 years ago Author

Cutting your own meat...I like it!!!

raymondphilippe profile image

raymondphilippe 9 years ago from The Netherlands

Wow. That looks tasty!

John D Lee profile image

John D Lee 9 years ago Author

Yeah, when it tastes as good as it smells you've really got something amazing!

Marye Audet profile image

Marye Audet 9 years ago from Lancaster, Texas

by the way..I did this last week and, altho I usually do make a great potroast, this one was superb. thanks!

Blogger Mom profile image

Blogger Mom 8 years ago from Northeast, US

Sounds great, can't wait to try it!

Joan 7 years ago

I am gonna try this today. I will let you know how it turns out. Wish me luck!

Joan 7 years ago

I am gonna try this today. I will let you know how it turns out. Wish me luck!

John D Lee profile image

John D Lee 7 years ago Author

Good Luck!

Let us know how it went

WriteAngled profile image

WriteAngled 7 years ago from Treorci, Cymru

I've always selected the leanest joints going, so that's one reason my pot roasts have been a disaster. What about using a stock pot, which is what I did? Is that a no no too?

John D Lee profile image

John D Lee 7 years ago Author

Hi WriteAngled,

Firstly, I love your pen-name, very witty!

The most important thing is a tight fitting lid, and so provided you have a good cover, a stick pot should work fine. That being said, a heavier pot, like a cast iron, gives you a nice radiant heat as well...


Bottom line - you're fine with the stock pot - but next time you see a good heavy enamel or cast iron lidded casserole dish on sale - think about picking one up!

WriteAngled profile image

WriteAngled 7 years ago from Treorci, Cymru

Thanks, JDL, I'll keep an eye open for one.

jlc 6 years ago

What about using un-polished stoneware?

joaniemb profile image

joaniemb 6 years ago from New York

When I was young my Mom cooked a pot roast just like this and it sure was delicious, the aroma in the house made your mouth water. Today I resort to a crock pot but no more after reading this thanks for sharing. Off to buy a dutch oven thanks again.

Mama__B 6 years ago

I still use the crockpot. But I do brown the meat first and deglaze the pan beforehand. Going to do that this weekend, as a matter of fact.

John D Lee profile image

John D Lee 6 years ago Author

Hi Mama-B,

yes, you brown the meat real well before hand, deglaze the pan and scrape up all the tasty bits that have stuck to the pan and then transfer the whole lot to your crockpot for slow cooking.

saif113sb profile image

saif113sb 5 years ago

Great information. useful hub. Thanks

YourSmartKitchen profile image

YourSmartKitchen 5 years ago from Reno, NV

Truly nothing beats a pot roast cooked in a cast iron! It's one of my grandmother's secret tools to her fabulously delicious beef pot roast, too. A very useful hub.Voted up.

Ornursemarcy 4 years ago

Finally! Now I know what I have been doing wrong. Many thanks for these tips!

votemom@gmail.com 4 years ago

how long do you need to cook it??

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article