A Review of 5 Ways to Cook a Turkey

The Pros and Cons of 5 Popular Ways to Cook a Turkey

Every holiday brings the same cooking conundrum: shall I stick with the time tested way to roast a turkey, or attempt something new, perhaps better, than the classic preparation? Usually, it is hard to improve upon a classic; I suppose that's how traditions become traditions in the first place, but sometimes it's just fun to try something different.

The following is a brief review of some of the more mainstream ways to cook a turkey.

Do You Prefer a Traditional Turkey?

5 out of 5 stars from 2 ratings of Classic Roasted Turkey

Method #1 Traditional

The traditional way to cook a turkey is to stuff and roast it in a 325 ̊F oven for approximately 20 minutes per pound, or until the breast meat reaches 170° F and the thigh is 180° F. Except for the frequent basting, this method is very straightforward and easy. Also a plus, roasting this way usually results in a visually appealing bird.

However, there are some drawbacks to this method. Often the breast meat dries out before the dark meat is thoroughly cooked. If your turkey is frozen, you have to remember to start thawing days in advance, and cooking time can be extensive.

There are a few simple ways to improve upon the classic. One way is to tent the turkey with foil. This keeps the turkey moist, speeds up cooking time, and eliminates the need for frequent basting. Some folks use a oven bag for the same purpose.

Another great idea is to cook the turkey frozen. This way you never have to handle a raw, dripping bacteria mass, you don't have to remember to thaw, and the white meat does not dry out by the time the dark meat is done. Obviously, this cooking technique takes longer, allow as much as 50% more cooking time. Don't forget to remove the giblet bag from the turkey, and do not stuff a frozen turkey. Stuffing will have to be cooked separately. (Try your crock pot for the stuffing; it comes out perfectly and doesn't take up oven space.)


Drum roll please....

Brine the Bird

Soak the turkey in brine for up to 24 hours.
Soak the turkey in brine for up to 24 hours. | Source

Method #2 Brining

Brining is one sure-fire solution for dry turkey meat. Brining is hardly a new concept but is often forgotten or overlooked because it does require a bit of forethought. Soaking your bird in salt water for up to 24 hours will make it tender and juicy; add some herbs, apple cider, maple syrup, or spices, and your meat will be extra flavorful as well.

Drawbacks to this method include the obvious need to plan ahead, as well as the requirement of a pot large enough to submerge the turkey, and a space in the fridge for both turkey and pot (if you want to brine for more than a few hours.)


Grilling the Turkey

Grilling the Turkey
Grilling the Turkey | Source

Method #3 Grill It

Grilling a turkey is a great way to save space in your oven for all the sides and trimmings. Another bonus: cooking a turkey on the grill cuts down on cleanup. You must use indirect, constant heat, and don't forget a drip pan beneath the turkey. Cook the bird directly on the top rack (lightly coat the rack with nonstick spray,) close the lid and open all vents. Cook for approximately 12 minutes per pound, or until the breast meat reaches 170° F and the dark meat 180° F.

Disadvantages to grilling a turkey include a non-traditional look and flavor to the turkey, and the possibility of weather complications. Also, you obviously need a fairly large grill, the mini-Weber just isn't going to cut it.

My Holiday Party Animals

There is a rumor that turkey can make you sleepy.  I'm sure it has nothing to do with all that eggnog.
There is a rumor that turkey can make you sleepy. I'm sure it has nothing to do with all that eggnog.

Method #4 Make It In Advance

One way of reducing your holiday work load is to roast your turkey a day or two before. Make the gravy and carve the bird. Store the meat (refrigerated) in a large roasting pan covered in the gravy. On the big day, the turkey just requires reheating and the meat is moist and delicious because it is kept in the gravy.

What I don't like about this method is the presentation. Call me nostalgic, but I love the part where the golden-brown turkey is pulled from the oven looking picture perfect and smelling like...well, like the holidays of my memories.

Deep Frying a Turkey

Deep Fried Turkey
Deep Fried Turkey | Source

Method #5 Deep Fry It

This method has become increasingly popular in the recent years due to the claim that the turkey turns out moist and delicious with a crisp skin and superior flavor.

I have never tried this method myself; I cannot imagine heating a huge vat of frying oil outdoors (safety standards require that you keep well away from buildings, people, and anything flammable,) risking burns, spills and grease fires, and trying to get this red-hot grease ball safely out of the pot. I am quite happy with the old fashioned way of doing things, thank you.

If you choose to try this method, please be very careful and take every possible precaution. Just in case it isn't already apparent, I personally do not recommend this method.


At A Glance

METHOD
PROS
CONS
Traditional
Simple preparation, nice presentation
White meat can get dry, time consuming
Brining
Moist, flavorful meat
Must plan ahead
Grilling
Easy, doesn't take oven space
Can look and taste non-traditional
Make ahead
Convenient, moist delicious meat
No beautiful presentation
Deep Frying
Moist meat, crisp skin
Messy and potentially dangerous

More by this Author


Comments 8 comments

chrissieklinger profile image

chrissieklinger 4 years ago from Pennsylvania

I never thought about grilling a turkey and like you I prefer the traditional method and having it look beautiful on the table. Lots of great ideas here though if anyone wants to try something new!


Mrs. Menagerie profile image

Mrs. Menagerie 4 years ago from The Zoo Author

Thanks Chrissie!

I know what you mean, for some reason the visual is just so important to me!


kashmir56 profile image

kashmir56 4 years ago from Massachusetts

Great hub filled with all great way to cook a turkey, well done ! Great photos and video too !


Mrs. Menagerie profile image

Mrs. Menagerie 4 years ago from The Zoo Author

Hey Tom...thanks a million!


chefsref profile image

chefsref 4 years ago from Citra Florida

Hey Mrs

Great Hub. I'll add my 2 cents.

Use an insulated plastic picnic cooler to brine the turkey. Sanitize it by washing it out with a little bleach and add some ice to keep the temp down to safe levels. This way you don't need to find room in the fridge and most of us seem to have a picnic cooler.

Also, before you roast a brined turkey be sure to dry the skin very well, otherwise you'll have soggy skin


Mrs. Menagerie profile image

Mrs. Menagerie 4 years ago from The Zoo Author

Ah ha! Great, great tips Chef! Thank you!


aviannovice profile image

aviannovice 4 years ago from Stillwater, OK

These are all great things to do. I have some southern friends that swear by the deep frying, but I have heard horror stories on burns.


Mrs. Menagerie profile image

Mrs. Menagerie 4 years ago from The Zoo Author

Hi ya Deb,

Sounds yummy but scary...to me anyway.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working