Cooking the Perfect Thanksgiving Turkey

Rate This Recipe

5 stars from 4 ratings of The Perfect Thanksgiving Turkey
Thanksgiving Turkey 2012
Thanksgiving Turkey 2012

Brining and a Butter Rub

As a kid gravy was very important to me during Thanksgiving and Christmas dinner. Once again mom had produced a dried out turkey full of stuffing. Thankfully the gravy brought life back to the turkey and made it easier to swallow. If you watch a lot of cooking shows like I do you probably already know that it's virtually impossible fill a turkey with stuffing and not dry out the breast. By the time the stuffing reaches the safe cooking temperature of 160 degrees the turkey breast is overcooked. If the turkey is only cooked until the breast is done, then the stuffing is questionable to eat because it isn't hot enough to kill any bacteria from the turkey.

Over the years mom began to branch out and gave me a recipe for brining a turkey. I had never heard of such a thing, but since I love to cook and eat I thought I'd give it a try. In case you too are not familiar with the process, it is essentially soaking the turkey in a highly concentrated salt and/or sugar solution before baking. There are several brine recipes with various herbs and spices added, but really the sugar and salt are the star players.

Brine

Before creating a brine solution thaw the turkey and think about the flavors you want the turkey and gravy to have. Initially I'll saute a sliced onion and half a dozen cloves of garlic. Then I add the dry herbs and spices such as bay leaf, rosemary, peppercorns, and crushed red pepper to wake them up a bit. Some recipes call for apple cider and others chicken stock, I've used both with great success. After sauteing the onion and spices I fill an 8Qt stockpot about half full with my liquid of choice. After I add the liquid I add the fresh herbs: thyme, sage, and celery leaves. Many brine recipes call for slightly more salt than sugar, but my husband and I have decided we like equal amounts of both. I stir everything together and bring it to a boil. Turning down the heat I let it simmer for at least 30 minutes to let the flavors infuse into the brine.

While the brine simmers prep the turkey to soak. Some recommend a cooler or a large plastic tub that will fit in the refrigerator. The first time I brined a turkey I didn't have either and I needed to put the turkey in the solution right away . My resourcefulness kicked in and I used my roasting pan and a trash bag. Just be sure it isn't a scented trash bag. I put the turkey in the bottom of the bag and sat it in the roasting pan.

Now it's time to add the rest of the liquid to the brine solution, to cool it off and dilute it a bit. The liquid has to be cool so that the turkey isn't poached. Thankfully this time of year cold water from the tap is pretty cold but I also use a fair amount of ice (8-12 cups) to help cool down the brine solution. You will see some of the salt/sugar precipitate but don't worry. The ratio of liquid to sugar/salt is critical for the number of hours the turkey is brining. If the solution is too concentrated or the turkey is left to brine too long then it will taste salty. On the flip side if the turkey doesn't brine long enough or if the solution is too diluted then the benefits will be diminished. In my opinion it's still better to brine a little than not at all. It is also better to buy low sodium chicken broth and add salt to the gravy at the very end to make sure it isn't too salty.

I have a scratch piece of paper with a few recipes scribbled down. For a 12lb turkey and 12 hour brine one recipe calls for 8 cups of apple cider, 4 cups of ice, with 2/3 cup of salt, 1/2 cup of sugar, 1/2 cup of brown sugar, and 1/4 cup of maple syrup. Another recipe combines 8 quarts of liquid with 3/4 cup of salt with 1/3 cup of sugar and a brine period of 2-3 days for the same size turkey. So, depending on the length of time available you can adjust the concentration of your brine accordingly. I typically use 8 quarts of liquid and a cup of both salt and sugar. In the refrigerator I'll brine the turkey for 24 hours turning it over after the first 12 hours. I do still use the unscented trash bag sitting in a roasting pan.

After the turkey has brined discard the solution and all of it's contents. Then rinse the turkey and pat it dry with paper towels.

Butter Rub

The brine will give the turkey an excellent flavor and help it retain moisture but in my opinion I think a butter rub takes it to a higher level. Depending on the size of turkey you'll need 1 or 2 sticks of butter softened. To the butter I add thyme, sage, parsley, rosemary, salt, pepper, and garlic and onion powder. Since raw garlic has a tendency to burn and become bitter I opt for the powder. Mix the herbs with the butter and rub the mixture all over the turkey, inside and out. Then, gently slide your hand between the skin and the breast and rub the butter all over the breast. Make sure to leave the skin in tact because it will help keep the breast meat from drying out. If needed, any remaining butter can be used to make stuffing or gravy, but whatever isn't used should be discarded.

Stuff

In place of the traditional stuffing the bird cavity can be filled with onion slices, garlic cloves, apple or orange wedges, sprigs of fresh herbs, celery, or whatever flavor combination you desire. I think it helps keep the cavity moist while providing excellent flavor to the drippings you'll use for gravy.

Turkey Rubbed With Herb Butter and Stuffed With Vegetables and Herbs

Bake

It is recommended to bake a turkey roughly 18 minutes per pound of turkey. Some recipes recommend the first 30-45 minutes upside down at 400 degrees. That helps put a sear on the turkey without drying out the breast. The first turkey I ever made I put in the pan upside down because I didn't know any better. After a "Griswald" moment of trying to carve the bottom of the turkey we realized it needed to be flipped over. It was tremendously juicy. The inverted turkey technique works, but I've always found flipping over the turkey somewhat of a nightmare.

Other recipes suggest putting the bird in the oven at 350 and bake until it is finished. Since I don't like flipping the turkey I'll bake it the first 30 minutes at 400 and then turn the oven down to 350. If you're looking for a pretty turkey you might want to cover the wing tips to keep them from burning. As the turkey bakes, baste it periodically (every 20-30 minutes) with the pan drippings for a beautiful brown color. My favorite basting tool is a silicone brush because the bristles don't fall out.

Another great investment is a meat thermometer. Most grocery stores carry them in the baking isle for a few dollars. When measuring the temperature of the turkey insert the thermometer into the thigh away from the bone. At 165F pull the turkey out of the oven and cover it with foil and allow it to rest for 20 minutes before carving. If the turkey is cut immediately all of the juices will run out and the turkey will be dry.

Summary

I know this is a long post so here are the cliff notes:

  • Brine solution: 8 quarts of liquid with 1 cup of salt and 1 cup of sugar. Add seasonings to your liking.
  • Brine the turkey for 1 day turning over after 12 hours.
  • Rub the inside, outside, and between the skin and breast with compound butter seasoned to your liking
  • Bake for 30 minutes at 400 and reduce to 350 until the internal temperature reaches 165 degrees. Don't forget to baste.
  • Cover the turkey with foil for 20 minutes and allow it to rest before carving.

Leave a comment and let me know how your turkey turned out. Enjoy the holiday season!


More by this Author


Comments 15 comments

Bob Ewing profile image

Bob Ewing 5 years ago from New Brunswick

I loved stuffing as a kid, still do but not as much, this was helpful, thanks.


Jennifer Essary profile image

Jennifer Essary 5 years ago from Idaho Author

I'm glad you enjoyed the article. Thank you for leaving a comment.


alissaroberts profile image

alissaroberts 5 years ago from Normandy, TN

This sounds delish! I am going to have to try this one on my 2nd attempt of cooking a turkey! :) Thanks for sharing!


Jennifer Essary profile image

Jennifer Essary 5 years ago from Idaho Author

Thank you Alissa. I look forward to reading about your money saving tips.


cardelean profile image

cardelean 4 years ago from Michigan

Your first couple of paragraphs made me chuckle. My mom isn't a bad cook but was never a great one. Although I don't remember the turkey being dried out, I do remember her stuffing it with stuffing. I had never thought before about the temperature being hot enough to kill the bacteria. Yikes!

Since I have made the turkey, I cook the stuffing separately and stuff the cavity with herbs and lemon slices. I have never brined a turkey before but may try it one year. Thanks for the guide. Congrats on your nomination and welcome to Hubpages.


alissaroberts profile image

alissaroberts 4 years ago from Normandy, TN

Congrats Jennifer on your nomination! Best of luck to you!


Jennifer Essary profile image

Jennifer Essary 4 years ago from Idaho Author

Cardelean, Yes, it is scary to think about the stuffing we ate "cooked" inside the turkey. Maybe that explains why I was sick one holiday. Who knows? I did see a cooking show where they put the stuffing in cheesecloth and then in the turkey. When the turkey was done, they combined the stuffing in the turkey with stuffing in a casserole and then cooked them together. Personally, I like the onions, celery, garlic, and herbs I add to the cavity. I think it gives the gravy a ton of flavor. I've never tried lemons and herbs, but that sounds good too. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and time.


Jennifer Essary profile image

Jennifer Essary 4 years ago from Idaho Author

Alissa, Thank you : ) I had to check my e-mail to find out what you were referring to, LOL. My in-laws have been here this weekend so I haven't logged onto HP for a few days.


Reprieve26 profile image

Reprieve26 4 years ago from Oregon Coast

Thanks for posting this hub. I haven't cooked a turkey in a few years, so I was looking for a refresher course! :)


kikalina profile image

kikalina 4 years ago from Europe

Wish I read this before Christmas ;)


Jennifer Essary profile image

Jennifer Essary 4 years ago from Idaho Author

Kikalina- At the store yesterday I saw the turkeys are now on sale. There's no rule about when you make a turkey. I recently took one to work for a pot-luck.


ML 3 years ago

Do you cover the turkey with the roasting pan lid while baking?


Sunshine625 profile image

Sunshine625 3 years ago from Orlando, FL

Wow I sure learned a few tricks of the trade. First off, I didn't know that stuffing the bird would dry it out THIS might explain why turkeys of the past have been dry BUT I wasn't the chef. We haven't stuffed a bird in a few years. Second, my daughter suggested we flip the bird and she heard it makes the meat juicier. I told her she flipped her lid! The meat might be moister, but I was not going to wrestle with a bird. No way! Also, I never heard of brine, until now. Sounds very interesting. I would of course not use a scented trash bag :) This year we wrapped the turkey in bacon for the first time. Not sure how it's going to work, but it was a plan we all agreed on! Excellent hub Jennifer! Happy Thanksgiving!


Vickiw 3 years ago

Very interesting and comprehensive Hub. I will be sure to make some notes for the Christmas Turkey Roast! I had forgotten about brining, but it does make a big difference.


Vickiw 3 years ago

Very interesting and comprehensive Hub. I will be sure to make some notes for the Christmas Turkey Roast! I had forgotten about brining, but it does make a big difference.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working