Eat Tasty, Nutritious Liver: But do take care.

owners and victims of poisonous liver

Click thumbnail to view full-size
Young polar bears credit komar.orgpolar bear liver (maybe) eat at your peril credit studentdoctor.netXavier Mertz.  Meal of polar liver was his last. creditkpunet.orgAlexander Konrad Explorer who wrote about polar bear liver poisoning during polar exploration.
Young polar bears credit komar.org
Young polar bears credit komar.org
polar bear liver (maybe) eat at your peril credit studentdoctor.net
polar bear liver (maybe) eat at your peril credit studentdoctor.net
Xavier Mertz.  Meal of polar liver was his last. creditkpunet.org
Xavier Mertz. Meal of polar liver was his last. creditkpunet.org
Alexander Konrad Explorer who wrote about polar bear liver poisoning during polar exploration.
Alexander Konrad Explorer who wrote about polar bear liver poisoning during polar exploration.

Liver needs treating with caution as a food

After shooting, carving off chunks and eating a Polar Bear for lunch, Gerrit de Veer noticed several of his men were getting very ill and throwing up. He especially noticed that the men who had consumed large amounts of what they said to be delicious liver were the most stricken (one died).

De Veer and his men were part of Dutch explorer, Barentsz' search for the North West Passage; voyages which were to cost many lives before the passage was found.

Leakey's top fossil hunter, Kimeu, fossicking around the Lake Turkana area in Africa, came upon what would be one of the most famous examples of the early man ever found. This was a female, 1.7 million years old, designated as KNM-ER 1808 (the date of the find). Despite the great age, the fossil was of Homo Erectus, our predecessor on the planet. While examining the deceased female, Leakey and his team were puzzled over the deformation of her limbs which were also covered in course growths. She had obviously been crippled by her infirmity for several weeks or even months and would have to have been cared for by other 'Erectus members, which was the first sign we had that these early homids were capable of affection and caring...and this before we think they even had a comprehensive language, much less any inkling of what had killed her.

Russian sailor, Alexander Konrad, on a trip with Valerian Albanov in the Arctic in 1912 wrote about his experiences of becoming very ill from also eating polar bear liver, despite the fact they were warned the local Inuits never consume liver from these bears.

In 1913, Arctic explorers, Doug Mawson and Xavier Mertz, lost supplies and dogs down an ice chasm and having insufficient food to return to base camp, killed and ate several of their sled dogs. Mertz, especially, consumed quite a lot of the dog’s livers. Both men became ill, Mertz had to be carried the last few kilometres, during which time he relapsed into a coma and died. Mawson recovered after a host of dangerous symptoms.

We know today, since the discovery of Vitamin A in the early part of the last century, that the Erectus woman - and the crew members of the de Veer voyage and the Russians - were suffering from Hypervitaminosis A, caused by eating the livers of a carnivore. The Dutch voyagers had prepared and eaten large amounts of Polar Bear liver; the ill-fated Homo Erectus female, possible that of a lion or some smaller predator species in the jungles.

All livers are depositaries of vitamin A, stored as liver retinoids. But many carnivores store far higher concentrations of the prepared A retinoids than do animals on lower protein diets. As few of us come across polar bears, never mind their livers, most people today who get ill from excessive A consumption do it from consuming vitamin A preparations, such as pills, etc., bought from health food stores.

The symptoms of hypervitaminosis A are nausea, head aches, stomach cramps and dizziness. If the excessive consumption has been large, really nasty and life-threatening effects, such as birth defects, osteoporosis, bone growths (like our hominid), hair loss, intracranial hypertension, coma and death can be the result. Today, we can treat this disease, if caught early, by injections of other vitamins and other procedures.

I love liver. But I think we should treat liver for what it is, the highest form of protein nutrition, but also the place where the body stores vitamin A; makes bile and, is itself, prey to a host of diseases, such as liver flukes, in all vertebrates. Many people will not touch liver, nor any organ meats, such as kidneys, hearts, brains and the rest. My opinion, for what it is worth, and after researching for this hub, is eat liver in small quantities after cooking well. Many countries eat liver raw, or partially so. It is also consumed as pate (delicious) and as liver sausage. And, or course, eat no carnivore liver at all; it is never commercially available in the UK, although chicken livers, duck and goose liver are and these fowl may consume a lot of animal protein. (I have no evidence they are harmful, but we need to use our own brains and logic in today’s world to stay harm free!)

There are, indeed, significant benefits from consuming the RIGHT AMOUNT of liver. It is almost solid protein, of course, and also contains Vitamins D,C,B6 and B12, along with thiamine, niacin, folate acid, pantotheric acid, phosphorus and selenium.

But livers can also carry alarming concentrations of dangerous heavy metals, too, such as arsenic, lead, mercury and cadmium. These are found alongside the beneficial “metals,” iron, copper and zinc. For this reason, many doctors and nutritionists advise caution with ANY liver consumption, such as not eating it too often. Some dangerous components - such a lead - stay in the blood and are not removed from the body. We already have far too high levels of lead in our blood and hardly need to increase these.

I also should mention the high purines in liver which can be bad for anyone with elevated uric acid or sufferers from gout and other arthritic illness. Liver should not perhaps be on the menu of these folks.

After a slew of deaths, preparing Puffer fish livers in Japan for consumption had to be made illegal. This has nothing to do with excess vitamin A, but to the virulent tetrodotoxin - a lethal neurotoxin - present all through this fish, but especially in the liver, (Mexicans have used poisonous fish livers for years to poison unwanted cats!).

Well, there it is. Along with the precautions needed comes the sadness as you eat calf or lamb’s liver and think of the poor little baby sheep and cows being slaughtered before they have lived and their organs torn from them. And our domestic animals and fish accumulating debilitating levels of heavy metals in their organs because of man’s irresponsible industries.

Turrible business, life, isn’t it?

More by this Author


Comments 15 comments

Sa`ge profile image

Sa`ge 5 years ago from Barefoot Island

By the gods, this is a great article. I knew there was a reason most people naturally do not like liver. They say, that when something is not good for us, we will tend to not be able to acquire a taste for it. I believe this to be true. thank you for such a wonderful write and with so much great info. I for one will not eat any liver. Am about to dance as I usually do on my way out... :D hugs :D


diogenes 5 years ago

By the sound of your energy level, you don't need any liver! I also forgot to mention in the article the high uric acid level of liver which can be bad for many people. Ever though of entering "Strictly Come Dancing?" Bob


Hello, hello, profile image

Hello, hello, 5 years ago from London, UK

Thank you for your fabulous hub and I also love eating liver but would never eat it raw.


GarnetBird profile image

GarnetBird 5 years ago from Northern California

Good Hub!! I was saved from terrible anemia by eating cooked beef liver/I was so weak and bruised I could barely walk around. I also recall losing hair and my skin turning slightly yellow when eating too much winter squash.


diogenes profile image

diogenes 5 years ago from UK and Mexico Author

Yes, lots of iron. Nothing beats liver for nutrition if eaten with care...Bob


diogenes profile image

diogenes 5 years ago from UK and Mexico Author

No, not raw, HH, but they do in some countries...the ones where many people die of unusual afflictions!! Bob


j.amie profile image

j.amie 5 years ago from PA

Growing up in the south, fried chicken livers were more common than any sort of pate - but I've had my share of both. I never thought of liver in it's true context until I read this, actually. I might have a more difficult time eating it now - but somehow I doubt it! I'll just steer away from the polar bears (liver, teeth, bears in general) and stick to mama's home cookin'. ;)


diogenes 5 years ago

Hi Jamie, I like liver, too, apart from the ongoing guilty feelings about eating any flesh. But I don't est it very often---ideal batchelor food actually, easy to cook and goes with baked beans, fried onions, mashed potatoes, bacon and all health food!

Have a nice Chrissie with mom's turkey...Bob


cathylynn99 profile image

cathylynn99 5 years ago from northeastern US

i eat beef liver as a treat about once per year. one liver advantage (at least in the states) is that it's cheap. it also has a lot of cholesterol. the reason it has so many heavy metals is that it's the body's main filter and detoxifier between the intestinal products of digestion and our blood stream.


diogenes 5 years ago

Hi cathylynn. It used to be cheap here, but no more, about the same as chops. Thanks for comment...Bob


surfgatinho profile image

surfgatinho 5 years ago from Cornwall UK

Was just reading about hypervitaminosis A today and the dangers of eating too much liver. Apparently there are risks attached to too much carrot juice too!


diogenes profile image

diogenes 5 years ago from UK and Mexico Author

Yes, I just heard about that...Bob


stars439 profile image

stars439 4 years ago from Louisiana, The Magnolia and Pelican State.

Very inteesting hub, and educational. Why kill such awesome creatures as Polar bears for food. Why not go fishing for God's sake. Better yet bring along beans, corn , or a storehouse of healthy nutritious wheat items on those old time vessels. I enjoy cow liver with onions yum yum. My doctor said I was anemic as a kid so I had to eat, and liked it.

See you're point. The liver is the storehouse of bad stuff, and kidneys help clean the bodies too. Nothing like a peanut butter, and jelly sandwich. Peanut butter is great. I like crunchy jiff. God Bless You. Great Hub. All your writing is awessome, as the teens would say.


Au fait profile image

Au fait 3 years ago from North Texas

I know Vitamin A can be toxic if too much is taken. I hate liver. I know, you love it. My mother tried to get me to eat it, but it was just so nasty. It tasted awful, and there is nothing like a huge liver fresh from the bull that was slain to get it. It's still warm and the smell is unbelievable -- a benefit of growing up on a farm where we butchered our own beef, pork, and chickens. I'm being facetious as just the memory of that smell still makes me sick.

Still an excellent hub as always. Voting it up and interesting and will share it with my followers! xx


Shyron E Shenko profile image

Shyron E Shenko 3 years ago

diogenes, I like Au fait lived on a farm in a different state, of course. I don't remember as a child eating liver, maybe for me it would have been a good thing. I do like liver now, well done.

This is very interesting, will share, voted up and interesting.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working