Hawaiian "Local Food" Diet Compared to Traditional Native Hawaii Diet

A classic Hawaiian Plate Lunch with mac salad, rice and meat.
A classic Hawaiian Plate Lunch with mac salad, rice and meat. | Source

Introduction

Hawaiian food is difficult to define. Food that is currently advertised as “Hawaiian food” in the continental United States is different from what Native Hawaiians ate. Ancient Hawaiians had a very healthy diet; it is said to be one of the healthiest in the world. In current Hawaiian culture, however, most people do not limit themselves to what Hawaiians ate; rather, they embellish the traditional Hawaiian diet with foods of other cultures. Because Hawaii is the most ethnically amalgamated state in the nation (Kasindorf 2007:1), the types of food consumed there are a mix of many different cultures of the people who call Hawaii home. In parts of the United States, this cuisine is known as “Hawaiian food” or “Hawaiian barbeque”; in Hawaii, however, residents refer to it as “local food.” This food is generally unhealthy and has caused obesity rates in Hawaii to increase. Through extensive research on Hawaiian culture, food, assimilation and historical events, this paper analyzes both the benefits of Hawaii’s ethnic amalgamation and the unfortunate effects of unhealthy, popular foods in Hawaii.

Ancient Hawaiian lu'au.  (top right) Preparing the imu, or underground oven.
Ancient Hawaiian lu'au. (top right) Preparing the imu, or underground oven. | Source
This visual aid illustrates the differences between the Ancient Hawaiian diet and today's American Diet.
This visual aid illustrates the differences between the Ancient Hawaiian diet and today's American Diet. | Source
Ancient Hawaiian foods.  (bottom right) Pounding the taro to make poi.
Ancient Hawaiian foods. (bottom right) Pounding the taro to make poi. | Source

Native Hawaiian Diet

The Ancient Hawaiian diet is said to be one of the healthiest diets in the world (Ann Cecil 2002:1). Ancient Hawaiian’s main diet consisted of poi (which comes from the taro root), fish, birds, breadfruit, pigs, yams, shellfish, and seaweed. The women were the hunters and gatherers and the men were the cooks. Both tasks required hard, physical labor; their diet satisfied their needs for carbohydrates, starch and protein:

“The ancient Hawaiians were fit. The traditional Hawaiian diet may have been ‘one of the best in the world’. It was a simple, high starch, high fiber, low saturated fat, low sodium and low cholesterol diet. It had 12 percent protein, 18 percent fat and 70 percent carbohydrates. By comparison, the typical American diet today has 15 percent protein, 40 percent fat and 45 percent carbohydrates” (Kanahele 1998).

With the amount of exercise they were getting, Native Hawaiians were healthy and strong. Many Hawaiian legends boast about the strength of the warriors; King Kamehameha I was crowned because he was able to lift a 700 lbs boulder over his head.

Although their main diet was healthy, individuals of a higher status were allowed to eat more fatty foods: “In Hawaii, ‘the feast was co-opted as a virtual prerogative of the ruling class, less an instrument of power than a pervasive, daily reminder of the immense gulf of social distinctions that separated the ali’i [chiefs] from maka’ainana [commoners]’” (Kirch and O’Day 2003:485). Although certain members of the group ate different foods, they continued the tradition of eating together. Hawaiians ate a single, large meal during the day, which was in the early afternoon. (They ate smaller meals at other times, but these were not thought of as a meal because they were rarely shared with company.)

The Ancient Hawaiian’s major meal of the day was a lu’au . A lu’au is a feast and celebration where the food is laid out for everyone to share. The ali’i would get a special meal, which was brought to them by members of a lower social status:

“Due to their socially superior position and ability to control resources, elites had more options for their diet. They were able to select certain foods and demand specific items as tribute without fear of dietary deficiency. Commoners had a more limited consumption of luxury, fatty foods” (Kirch and O’Day 2003:490).

In current, American society, it seems that members of lower classes have limited access to healthy foods; in Ancient Hawaii, the situation was the opposite.

Graph displaying the immigration to Hawaii.
Graph displaying the immigration to Hawaii. | Source

Immigration and History

The many immigrants that came to Hawaii brought their tastes for certain foods with them. Japanese and Chinese immigrants traveled to Hawaii and worked on the sugarcane plantations. Laudan (1996) writes: “The Chinese, the first immigrants to work on the plantations, demanded rice instead of poi, the Hawaiian staple. At first, their rice had to be imported, but as the Hawaiian population declined, so did the demand for the taro from which poi was made” (31). Hawaiian staples changed as immigrants traveled to Hawaii. Because foreigners’ tastes had to be adjusted to what was available in Hawaii, food was shared, mixed and imported as Masuoka (1945) explains in his essay.

Masuoka (1945) conducted a study which analyzed the eating habits of 100 Japanese families living in Hawaii in the early 1940’s. In his results, he concludes that the Japanese immigrant in Hawaii tends to eat differently from the tradition Hawaiian and tradition Japanese individuals. He discovered that the families of Japanese immigrants who traveled to Hawaii and worked on sugarcane plantations acquired a taste for sweeter foods. Sweet foods were considered a luxury in Japan—whereas, in Hawaii at this time, sugar was one of their key staples; Hawaiian food is known world-wide for its sweetness.

When immigrants first came to Hawaii, Native elders were not ready to give up or share their culture with the newcomers:

“Native leaders saw their people faced by loss of autonomy and of territory, looked back with poignant memory to the good old days, resented the confidently domineering ways of the newcomers who were thwarting their activities at so many points, could foresee no future other than displacement and destruction of their race” (Keesing 1934:449).

As the youth began to mix with imiigrants from the East, modern Hawaiian culture began to form. Their ability to assimilate came from a collective identity. Hawaiians believe that they are part of the Orient and share a feeling of “the other.” This is because they too were looked down on by Western cultures:

“Being an immigrant, or belonging to an ethnic minority, often means belonging to a category of disadvantage in today’s Western multiethnic societies. This disadvantage is not based upon a particular ethnicity, but could rather be understood in terms of being defined as the Other—something that affects certain ethnicities more than others” (Hallden, Grand and Hellgren 2008:4).

Immigration and Hawaii
Immigration and Hawaii | Source

The assimilation of Eastern cultures immigrating to Hawaii caused the local cuisine to change and mix:

“Today, then, Hawaii’s foods are a mélange, imperfectly adjusted to the soil and climate of the Islands, imperfectly adjusted along themselves. In this lies their interest. For all the nostalgia for foods rooted in one place, for all the loving stories of peasants around the Mediterranean eating the products of the lands they till, the reality is what each one of us eats…is the result of centuries of change” (Laudan 1996:6).

This change is obvious when we look at what is considered Hawaiian cuisine in current society. Many cultures came to assimilate in Hawaii and the culture was effected dramatically.

In order to understand others, residents of Hawaii created their own language: Pigin English (which is commonly referred to as “Broken English”). For example, “‘Manapua’ is the Pidgin word for ‘dim sum.’ It purportedly comes from a contraction of three Hawaiian words: ‘mea,’ which means ‘thing’; ‘ono,’ which means ‘delicious’; and ‘pua’a,’ which means ‘pig.’ So a manapua is a ‘delicious pig thing’” (Scanlan 2009:1). Like our food, our culture is mixed and influenced by immigration. Because Hawaiian was not a written language, it was difficult for foreigners to learn; they shorten sentences and mix them with Hawaiian, Pilipino, Japanese and Portuguese words. This language still exists in Hawaii today and it is what defines our ethnically amalgamated culture:

“Pacific Islanders historically have constructed their ethnic identities rather more complexly than many other peoples. Pacific Islanders have long had a greater consciousness than other American groups of being mixed peoples, of having multiple ethnic identities….They seem more comfortable than other Americans with holding in tension two or more ethnic identities, with being deeply more involved in more than one at the same time” (Spickard and Fong 1995:1368).

Because of the many cultures, which traveled to Hawaii, it became a place of ethnic acceptance, where culture mixed. The local cuisine changed as more immigrants traveled to Hawaii.

Source

"Local" Food

After centuries of immigration, many Hawaiian residents label themselves as multiethnic or multiraical. In a 2005 census survey, 21% of Hawaii’s population listed themselves as belonging to more than one race. In Hawaii, there is a name for multiracial people: Hapa . (This term literally means “mixed.”) The current governor of Hawaii, Linda Lingle, says Hawaii is “a model for the world” (Kasindorf 2007:1)—where culture is celebrated and mixed; Hawaii is America’s true melting pot. Lingle also notes that every one in two marriages crosses racial lines; this is more than any other place in the United States (Sullivan 2005:1). Hawaiian culture has blended with others and so has our food.

A popular restaurant chain, L&L, advertises itself as “Hawaiian BBQ” in the continental United States. Their menu consists of mainly plate lunches, which include rice, macaroni salad and an entrée (including fish, chicken, beef, pork or spam) in a Styrofoam box. In Hawaii, L&L advertises that they serve “Korean BBQ.” Although the menus are identical, the food is tied to a different culture. Hawaiian food is now known as a combination of many Oriental dishes.

Residents of Hawaii call this type of cuisine “local food.” Popular local foods include musubi (spam wrapped in rice and seaweed), macaroni salad, kim chee, long rice, and saimien (Japaneese noodle soup). Fast food restaurants such as McDonalds and Burger King began to incorporate popular local food into their menus. McDonalds has breakfast menus, which offer Portuguese sausage and spam. At McDonalds in China, they are currently testing and marketing their “Hawaiian Burger.” This item is a hamburger patty with teriyaki sauce, lettuce, tomato, and a slice of pineapple on a sesame seed bun. What defines this burger as “Hawaiian” is not only the pineapple slice (which was eaten by Natives), but also the teriyaki flavor, which is from Japanese cuisine.

McDonalds also makes special advertisements for Hawaiian consumers. They often have an Asian male rapping about fast food. These commercials suggest that they are attempting to appeal to the large, Asian community in Hawaii. McDonalds’ newest additions to the menu are pineapple pie and the sweet taro pie. These items are popular in Hawaii, because they appeal to the types of foods Hawaiians are used to eating. Although these foods are delicious, they affect the health and well-being of Hawaiian residents immensely. It seems that the fatty and luxurious foods which were reserved for the higher class in Ancient Hawaiian society are now available to the public, causing an obesity epidemic.

Fast food in Hawaii is made to match local foods.
Fast food in Hawaii is made to match local foods. | Source

Obesity in Hawaii

Because of the availability of fatty foods, an obesity epidemic has erupted in Hawaii. 17.6 % of those living in Hawaii are obese. This number is substantial; decades before, Hawaii’s obesity rates were low compared to the rest of the nation. Unfortunately, obesity rates of certain races in Hawaii are higher than others. 39% of Native Hawaiians are currently obese (Evans 2004:1): “In Hawaii, data clearly substantiate that Native Hawaiian and other Pacific Islander populations are more at risk for overweight and obesity and obesity-attributable health complications than other ethnic groups” (25). Native Hawaiians may be more obese than other races in the same area due to class/economic status, hereditary factors and lifestyle choices. Because of the poor public transportation on islands other than Oahu, many people don’t have the opportunities to travel to a store for groceries. When the local restaurants only sell fatty foods, companies try to protect Hawaii from obesity.

Child obesity has become a major issue within our nation; First Lady Michelle Obama is currently attempting to lower the rising rates of child obesity. 20% of children in Hawaii are obese (Evans 2004:16). Native Hawaiian children have an obesity rate that doubles the national children’s obesity rating. This high rating could be a result of Hawaii’s inconsistent educational system.

Since the beginning of the 2009-2010 school year, Hawaiian public schools are closed on Fridays. The government calls them “Furlough Fridays;” because of the lack of funding for Hawaiian education, all students and teachers get to enjoy three-day weekends all school year long. Students have less routine in their daily lives, which heightens the risk of using drugs and alcohol and also gaining weight. They could make poor diet choices if they are home alone (while parents are at work) during Furlough Fridays. Because unhealthy food is cheaper, available and appealing to children, unsupervised children could gain weight without nutritional education. If so, they can become socially detached from society due to social stigmas (Julier 2007: 487).

The Hawaii board of education continues to struggle to get adequate funding. For the school year of 2010-2011, teachers are being asked to work three school days without pay. Teachers are threatening to strike; if they follow-through, it would create more instability in the children’s lives, causing them to possibly gain weight. President Obama is working to rid the 256 public schools of Furlough Fridays through a bill that would increase the budget.

In a place that is known for its warm weather and beautiful landscapes, Hawaiian obesity shouldn’t be an issue. There are many ways to get exercise that people in other parts of the world cannot do. Fortunately, there are programs in place to help Hawaiian residents lose weight and make healthier choices. Kaiser Permanente shares pamphlets of information with their patients, which instructs them to make healthier food choices. They suggest that instead of the classic plate lunch, the typical Hawaiian should choose to get vegetables instead of rice, skinless chicken instead of chicken katsu, etc. Kaiser also sponsors the Aloha Run, which gets many people to come out with their families and get some exercise.

Source

Conclusion

Through thorough research, it can be concluded that Hawaiian food culture evolved because of immigration and assimilation. The food that locals eat now is very different from that of the Natives (a healthy, rich diet). In current Hawaiian society, there is an obesity epidemic. Without education, Hawaii will continue to gain weight by eating unhealthy foods (like a plate lunch). Children that are attending public school should be able to attend on Fridays; if not, the obesity rates will continue to rise and children will have less daily routine.

Although the amalgamation of Hawaii is positive—“a model for the world”—the types of food that Hawaiians consume on a daily basis is not good for their health. In order to fix the problems with unhealthy eating in Hawaii there must be more access to public transportation and less fast food restaurants in low-income areas. The availability of unhealthy and cheap food makes it difficult for Hawaiians to make healthier choices. Through education and the promotion of exercise, Hawaii can rid itself of the obesity epidemic its currently facing.

References

Boero, Natalie. “All the News that’s Fat to Print: The American ‘Obesity Epidemic’ in the Media.” Quantative Sociology. 30:41-60.

Byles, Julie. 2009. “Obesity: The New Global Threat to Healthy Aging and Longevity.” Health Sociology Review. 18:412-422.

Corum, Ann Kondo. 1983. Ethnic Foods of Hawai’i. Honolulu, HI: Bess Press.

Evans, Brooke. 2004. “Obesity in Hawaii: Health Policy Options.” University of Hawaii at Manoa.

Hallden, Karin. Elias le Grand. Zenis Hellgren. 2008. “Ethnicity and Social Divisions: Contemporary Research in Sociology.” Newcastle, UK: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

Julier, Alice. 2007. “The Political Economy of Obesity: The Fat Pay All.” Food and Culture: A Reader. New York: Routledge. 482-499.

Kanahele, George, PHD. 1998. Pookela Hawaiian Culture Course. Kā'anapali Beach Hotel.

Kasindorf, Martin. 2007. “Racial Tensions are Simmering in Hawaii’s Melting Pot.” USA Today.

Keesing, Felix M. 1934. “The Changing Life of Native Peoples in the Pacific Area: A Sketch in Cultural Dynamics.” The American Journal of Sociology. 39:443-458.

Kirch, Patrick. Sharyn O’Day. 2003. “New Archaeological Insights into Food and Status: A Case Study from Pre-Contact Hawaii.” World Archaeology. 34: 484-497.

Laudan, Rachel. 1996. The Food of Paradise: Exploring Hawaii's Culinary Heritage. Honolulu, HI: University of Hawaii Press.

Law, Sylvia. 2000. “Health Care in Hawai'i: An Agenda for Research and Reform.” American Journal of Law and Medicine.

Linnekin, Jocelyn. Lin Poyer. 1991. “Cultural Identity and Ethnicity in the Pacific.” Journal of Sociology. 27:112-113.

Masuoka, Jitsuichi. 1945. “Changing Food Habits of the Japanese in Hawaii.” American Sociological Review. 10:759-765.

Nestle, Marion. 2003. “The Ironic Politics of Obesity.” Science Magazine. 229: 781.

Reinecke, John. 1938 “‘Pidgin English’ in Hawaii: A Local Study in the Sociology of Language.” American Journal of Sociology.

Scanlan, Laura. 2009. “The Voice of Hawaii.” Humanities. 30:1-3.

Sullivan, Paul. 2005. “Killing Aloha: The Akaka Bill is Wrong for the State of Hawaii and Wrong for the United States.” Honolulu, HI.

Spickard, Paul R. Rowena Fong. 1995. “Pacific Islander Americans and Multiethnicity: A Vision of America's Future?” Social Forces. 73: 1365-1383.

Schmitt, Robert C. 1981. “Early Hawaiian Statistics.” The American Statistician. 35:1-3.

More by this Author


Comments 12 comments

PiaC profile image

PiaC 5 years ago from Oakland, CA

This is an excellent Hub. I love all the depth of information! I had no idea that the public schools in Hawaii are closed on Fridays! Do they have longer days on the other days of the week to make up for the lost time?


brittanytodd profile image

brittanytodd 5 years ago from Kailua-Kona, Hawaii Author

Thank you! Actually, they shorten the summer months in oder to make up for lost time, but not by much. I think that the students suffer from having longer weekends.


Cortezmeow profile image

Cortezmeow 5 years ago

Good hub. This article caught my I because I lived in Hawaii about three years ago and my children went to school there. My husband and I ran the Aloha run. It was awesome. I think the lunches that were served at school didn't help the obese problem in Hawaii either. School lunches consisted of rice, katsu chicken, and mac salad. I also noticed there weren't a lot of activities for kids to do to keep them out of trouble and healthy. I loved the food in Hawaii and miss the malasdas, a Portuguese type of bread served on the islands. The sushi their was the best, because it was so fresh. Another problem that the locals face,when choosing to eat right, is the cost of food. Because most of the food, on the islands has to be shipped, it cost more. A gallon of milk cost eight dollars in Hawaii. How can a family eat healthy, if food cost so much?


brittanytodd profile image

brittanytodd 5 years ago from Kailua-Kona, Hawaii Author

Which island did you live on? I grew up on the Big Island. The best malasadas are definitely at Tex Drive In. I think the beach keeps kids active, but the diet and school lunch program definitely have an impact on the children's weight. I agree that a lot of the food we eat in Hawaii is shipped over and more expensive, but the local ranches on the Big Island help by selling to the grocery stores there. Thanks for reading; I'm glad you liked the article.


Cortezmeow profile image

Cortezmeow 5 years ago

I lived on Oahu. The beaches do keep the kids active, but it doesn't always keep them out of trouble. I think they should have more structured activities they teach nutrition as well as exercise. I miss Hawaii!


Noble One profile image

Noble One 5 years ago from Milpitas, CA

I've never been to Hawaii, but aside from the beautiful beaches and the hang loose culture often depicted, there's something about those islands that's inviting. Perhaps it's the "amalgamation." I learned a new word today. Thanks again, Brittany!


brittanytodd profile image

brittanytodd 5 years ago from Kailua-Kona, Hawaii Author

I agree, Cortezmeow. And thank you, Noble One! I think Hawaii is very unique because of amalgamation.


Derdriu 5 years ago

BrittanyTodd: Thank you for the colorful and factual analysis of a people through the impact of change and migration on the ever vulnerable culture of islands. It is great that you not only pinpoint causes but also problem-solve.

Voted up, and across all categories too,

Derdriu


Natashalh profile image

Natashalh 4 years ago from Hawaii

What an in-depth look at Hawaiian food culture. I was wondering about this, actually, after some friends talked me into going to a 'traditional' Hawaiian breakfast place that served Spam omlettes. At the time, I was thinking there was no way Spam was in the true traditional Hawaiian diet.


Ann 4 years ago

Amazingly inaccurate information about traditional Hawaiian meals.


Kealakai 3 years ago

Mahalo for such a great overview on the Hawaiian diet, historically and today, and the challenges we face concerning obesity and overweight. I'm doing a presentation on this very topic and your article is one of the best sources I've found. Thank you for sharing.


brittanytodd profile image

brittanytodd 3 years ago from Kailua-Kona, Hawaii Author

Mahalo! I originally researched this topic as a presentation for a sociology of food course. (A lot of the images were slides from my presentation.) Best of luck to you on yours! Aloha.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working