How To Cook Pot Roast In a Cast Iron Dutch Oven: Recipe Ingredients and Directions with Photo Review

How To Make American Pot Roast

American Pot Roast is a favorite recipe all over the United States. It is typically a New England Recipe made on cold days. This is Soul Food!
American Pot Roast is a favorite recipe all over the United States. It is typically a New England Recipe made on cold days. This is Soul Food! | Source

Nutrition Information

Nutrition Facts
Serving size: 6-8 People
Calories 237
Calories from Fat54
% Daily Value *
Fat 6 g9%
Cholesterol 354 mg118%
* The Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet, so your values may change depending on your calorie needs. The values here may not be 100% accurate because the recipes have not been professionally evaluated nor have they been evaluated by the U.S. FDA.

Cook Time

  • Prep time: 45 min
  • Cook time: 3 hours 45 min
  • Ready in: 4 hours 30 min
  • Yields: Serves 6-8 People

How To Make a Beef Pot Roast in a Cast Iron Dutch Oven

You want to make a Pot Roast for that special occasion. Maybe someone asked you to make it for them. Maybe you want to try this traditional American dish. Perhaps your grandmother used to make this dish and you want to learn how she made it. Whatever your reason, this recipe will help you get through the entire process and you will enjoy a delicious comfort meal.

American Pot Roast is a time honored tradition. It is a champion of dishes served in American kitchens for hundreds of years and many more to come. This is the kind of "Sunday Night Dinner" that will create memories for a lifetime. This Pot Roast Recipe is fairly easy and fool-proof. It's healthy and smart. If you have never made Pot Roast you should consider making it today! It is a great slow-cooked meal whether you are sick or if it is cold outside. Or maybe you just want a great home cooked meal!

Beginning with quality fresh ingredients and ending with your family asking for more, this Beef Pot Roast with Vegetables Recipe will warm you up on a cold night. It's fast and delicious and will become a favorite for your family and friends for years to come. This recipe will leave an impression on people.

Pot Roast Recipe Ingredients: What You Will Need to Buy at the Store

These are the Raw Ingredients for the American Pot Roast Recipe. The ingredients were purchased fresh from the local super market.
These are the Raw Ingredients for the American Pot Roast Recipe. The ingredients were purchased fresh from the local super market. | Source

Pot Roast Ingredients

  • 4 lbs. Beef Rump Roast, Use Fresh Meat
  • 6 Cups (about 3 mdeium) Sliced Onion, Cut into 1/4" slices
  • 2 Tbsp. Paprika, *(prefer Hungarian Sweet; any will do)
  • 1/2 tsp. Dried Basil
  • 1/2 tsp. Dried Oregano
  • 1/2 tsp. Dried Thyme
  • 3 Fresh Golic Cloves
  • 1/2 Cup Fresh Water, (Natural Spring Water without Chlorine tastes best)
  • 2 Tbsp. Red Wine Vinegar, *(can substitute with 1/2 Cup Dry Red Wine)
  • 1 Can (14.25 oz) Beef Broth, *(use Low-Sodium brand if desired)
  • 6-10 (1 lb.) Red (Bliss) Potatoes; Many varieties will do, (Will have to cut and shape to fit)
  • 1/2 tsp. Salt
  • 1/4 tsp. Black Pepper
  • 1 lb. Carotts, *(can use Baby Carrots but may take a little longer)
  • Can Cooking Spray, You will need to spray the entire inside of your Cast Iron Dutch Oven for some steps in this recipe.

Recipe Ingredients In Photos!

Click thumbnail to view full-size
Can of Beef Broth (14.25 oz)  Making Beef Pot Roast Stock Is Easy!First you will need an appropriate Cast Iron Dutch Oven that is well-seasoned. Other pans can be used but there is nothing like a Pot Roast cooked in Cast Iron! Ingredients and Spices for making a Pot Roast.1 lb. Baby Carrots. (Can use 6 or so regular carrots, rinsed, peeled and cut into 2 inch pieces.)Dried Thyme SpiceDried Oregano SpiceDried Basil SpicePaprika SpiceRed Wine Vinegar can be used instead of Dry Red Wine when making Pot Roast.4 Lbs. Beef Rum Roast for Pot Roast RecipeMedium OnionsGround Black Pepper SpiceSalt
Can of Beef Broth (14.25 oz)  Making Beef Pot Roast Stock Is Easy!
Can of Beef Broth (14.25 oz) Making Beef Pot Roast Stock Is Easy! | Source
First you will need an appropriate Cast Iron Dutch Oven that is well-seasoned. Other pans can be used but there is nothing like a Pot Roast cooked in Cast Iron!
First you will need an appropriate Cast Iron Dutch Oven that is well-seasoned. Other pans can be used but there is nothing like a Pot Roast cooked in Cast Iron! | Source
Ingredients and Spices for making a Pot Roast.
Ingredients and Spices for making a Pot Roast. | Source
1 lb. Baby Carrots. (Can use 6 or so regular carrots, rinsed, peeled and cut into 2 inch pieces.)
1 lb. Baby Carrots. (Can use 6 or so regular carrots, rinsed, peeled and cut into 2 inch pieces.) | Source
Dried Thyme Spice
Dried Thyme Spice | Source
Dried Oregano Spice
Dried Oregano Spice | Source
Dried Basil Spice
Dried Basil Spice | Source
Paprika Spice
Paprika Spice | Source
Red Wine Vinegar can be used instead of Dry Red Wine when making Pot Roast.
Red Wine Vinegar can be used instead of Dry Red Wine when making Pot Roast. | Source
4 Lbs. Beef Rum Roast for Pot Roast Recipe
4 Lbs. Beef Rum Roast for Pot Roast Recipe | Source
Medium Onions
Medium Onions | Source
Ground Black Pepper Spice
Ground Black Pepper Spice | Source
Salt
Salt | Source

How To Make Pot Roast: Step by Step Instructional Photos

Click thumbnail to view full-size
Chopping the onions.Fresh Beef Rump Roast (prior to cooking; raw)Browning the Rump Roast in the Cast Iron Dutch OvenPan-Seared (Browned) Beef Rump Roast on all sides before baking. Pot Roast Recipe Methods. .Saute the Onions for 10 minutes.Crushing Garlic with a Meat Cleaver.Paprika, Basil, Thyme, Oregano and Garlic Spice Mix for Pot Roast Recipe.Adding the Paprika, Basil, Thyme, Oregano and Garlic Spice Mix.Sauteing and stirring the Mixture of Seasonings with the Onions. Adding the Water, Wine and Beef Broth to the Mix.The "Stock" for Pot RoastI cut the Potatoes to spread them out. Less is More!Usually I don't use Baby Carrots because they don't break down as easily as regular carrots. These 1 Lb. bags of Baby Carrots were "Buy One, Get One Free!" I Couldn't pass it up. It worked. And I saved Money!Simmering Pot Roast StockAdding the Potatoes to the Pot Roast Stock.Add the Carrots with the Potatoes and stir lightly.Add the Rump Roast to the Pot Roast StockCover and cook for 2 hours at 300 degrees F. After 2 hours, Flip the Roast and Lightly Stir the mix.
Chopping the onions.
Chopping the onions. | Source
Fresh Beef Rump Roast (prior to cooking; raw)
Fresh Beef Rump Roast (prior to cooking; raw) | Source
Browning the Rump Roast in the Cast Iron Dutch Oven
Browning the Rump Roast in the Cast Iron Dutch Oven | Source
Pan-Seared (Browned) Beef Rump Roast on all sides before baking. Pot Roast Recipe Methods. .
Pan-Seared (Browned) Beef Rump Roast on all sides before baking. Pot Roast Recipe Methods. . | Source
Saute the Onions for 10 minutes.
Saute the Onions for 10 minutes. | Source
Crushing Garlic with a Meat Cleaver.
Crushing Garlic with a Meat Cleaver. | Source
Paprika, Basil, Thyme, Oregano and Garlic Spice Mix for Pot Roast Recipe.
Paprika, Basil, Thyme, Oregano and Garlic Spice Mix for Pot Roast Recipe. | Source
Adding the Paprika, Basil, Thyme, Oregano and Garlic Spice Mix.
Adding the Paprika, Basil, Thyme, Oregano and Garlic Spice Mix. | Source
Sauteing and stirring the Mixture of Seasonings with the Onions.
Sauteing and stirring the Mixture of Seasonings with the Onions. | Source
Adding the Water, Wine and Beef Broth to the Mix.
Adding the Water, Wine and Beef Broth to the Mix. | Source
The "Stock" for Pot Roast
The "Stock" for Pot Roast | Source
I cut the Potatoes to spread them out. Less is More!
I cut the Potatoes to spread them out. Less is More! | Source
Usually I don't use Baby Carrots because they don't break down as easily as regular carrots. These 1 Lb. bags of Baby Carrots were "Buy One, Get One Free!" I Couldn't pass it up. It worked. And I saved Money!
Usually I don't use Baby Carrots because they don't break down as easily as regular carrots. These 1 Lb. bags of Baby Carrots were "Buy One, Get One Free!" I Couldn't pass it up. It worked. And I saved Money! | Source
Simmering Pot Roast Stock
Simmering Pot Roast Stock | Source
Adding the Potatoes to the Pot Roast Stock.
Adding the Potatoes to the Pot Roast Stock. | Source
Add the Carrots with the Potatoes and stir lightly.
Add the Carrots with the Potatoes and stir lightly. | Source
Add the Rump Roast to the Pot Roast Stock
Add the Rump Roast to the Pot Roast Stock | Source
Cover and cook for 2 hours at 300 degrees F. After 2 hours, Flip the Roast and Lightly Stir the mix.
Cover and cook for 2 hours at 300 degrees F. After 2 hours, Flip the Roast and Lightly Stir the mix. | Source

How To Cook a Pot Roast

  1. Make sure that your cast iron dutch oven is 4-6 quarts, clean and seasoned.
  2. Peel and Cut onions so they are about an inch long and a quarter inch wide. Set aside.
  3. If using baby carrots, rinse them. If using regular carrots, rinse and peel 6 and cut into 2 inch pieces. Set aside.
  4. Spray the cast iron dutch oven well with cooking spray and place on the stove top on medium-high heat.
  5. Add the pot roast to the dutch oven and briefly brown all the sides of the cut. This will help seal in the flavor. When the roast is browned on all sides, remove and set aside.
  6. Spray a little more cooking spray to the dutch oven. Add the onions and sauté for 10 minutes. Don't let them stick to the pan or they will burn.
  7. Add the Paprika, Basil, Oregano, Thyme and Garlic and continue to stir and sauté for an additional one minute or so. Make sure the ingredients are blended thoroughly. They will have a reddish-orange appearance.
  8. Add the Water, Wine/Red Wine Vinegar and Beef Broth. Stir and bring to a boil. *(if you choose red wine vinegar over dry red wine you may need to add a little more water)
  9. Once your mixture is boiling, add the Potatoes, Carrots, Salt and Pepper. Stir.
  10. Carefully add the Roast to the mixture and make sure it is mostly submerged in the liquid. *(add water as needed. Do not fill to the top and allow a portion of the meat to be above the liquid line.)
  11. Cover the Cast Iron Dutch Oven and Put in the oven. Bake at 300 F for 2 hours.
  12. After 2 hours, Flip the Roast over and stir lightly the other ingredients. Cook for an addition hour or until tender. Meat should be able to separate with a fork when done.
  13. Either serve from the Dutch oven or remove roast, cut and serve vegetables and broth on the side.

Pot Roast Completed: The Best Part!

Flipping or Turning Over the Pot Roast after 2 hours. Mix the stock lightly.
Flipping or Turning Over the Pot Roast after 2 hours. Mix the stock lightly.
It Is Finished...Your Pot Roast Dinner is Now Complete. Enjoy!
It Is Finished...Your Pot Roast Dinner is Now Complete. Enjoy!
Serve your Pot Roast right from the Cast Iron Dutch Oven or if you prefer, serve on separate dishes.
Serve your Pot Roast right from the Cast Iron Dutch Oven or if you prefer, serve on separate dishes.

Rate This Pot Roast Recipe!

4.6 stars from 5 ratings of Traditional American Pot Roast in Dutch Oven Recipe

More by this Author


What Do You Think About This Recipe? Rate Up Above and Leave Comments Below! 8 comments

rjsadowski profile image

rjsadowski 3 years ago

Nice recipe and the pictures make every step crystal clear. Do you ever cook this outside over an open fire?


pstraubie48 profile image

pstraubie48 3 years ago from sunny Florida

Don't you just love cooking in cast iron? It takes me way back to the kitchen with the wood stove and a big pot of something yummy cooking. We had electric appliances in our kitchen which were used often but my Daddy loved his little wood stove so many yummy things were prepared there.

this looks like something lovely to try.


Eiddwen profile image

Eiddwen 3 years ago from Wales

A definite for me to vote up and share. Sounds and looks delicious.

Eddy.


J.S.Matthew profile image

J.S.Matthew 3 years ago from Massachusetts, USA Author

@rjsadowski: Hello there! Sorry for the delay but my computer has died and I haven't had access lately. To answer your question, no I have never cooked this outside but it can be done. It's a bit tricky because it is hard to maintain an accurate and consistent temperature, especially over an open fire. If you were to try it the best method is to use hot coals. There is a formula to figure this out but I can't remember it. I will have to research that, perhaps for a later Hub! Thanks for asking and I appreciate your comment.

JSMatthew~


J.S.Matthew profile image

J.S.Matthew 3 years ago from Massachusetts, USA Author

@pstraubie48: Hello! I love cooking in cast iron! I have quite a collection (check out my Hub about how to Season Cast Iron-there are photos of my collection!) For me, I go back to being a young Boy Scout and cooking food in the Dutch Ovens and Frying Pans. Food just tastes better in cast iron! I hope that you get to try this recipe out. Let me know what you think if you do. Thank you for your inspirational comment!

JSMatthew~


J.S.Matthew profile image

J.S.Matthew 3 years ago from Massachusetts, USA Author

@Eiddwen: Hi Eddy! I appreciate your votes and share. This is one of my favorite all time recipes and my family loves when I make it! Thank you very much!

JSMatthew~


girishpuri profile image

girishpuri 3 years ago from NCR , INDIA

Nice recipe with perfect pictures and sounds yum...


J.S.Matthew profile image

J.S.Matthew 3 years ago from Massachusetts, USA Author

Thanks girishpuri! This is my favorite dish to make and it gets eaten up pretty quickly! Glad you enjoyed the photos. Thanks for stopping by!

JSMatthew~

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working