Old Fasioned Peanut Butter Pie

Have You Ever Heard Of The Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie
Have You Ever Heard Of The Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie | Source
4.6 stars from 5 ratings of Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

How To Make An Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

Most people today make peanut butter pies the fast way with out cooking anything but back in the day peanut butter pies were made much different and they were oh so delicious. If you ever make a peanut butter pie the old fashioned way you'll never go back to making them the modern way. Because the flavor of the old fashioned peanut butter pies were just simply marvelous.

My Grandmother Hattie Propst made these pies over fifty years ago and I remember setting and watching her make them. And then many years later when I became a Chef I started making Peanut Butter Pies the old fashioned way that my Grandmother had made them. And before long I had people all over Miami Florida making them this way. And believe it or not but they really aren't that hard to make the old fashioned way.

I think that Jiff makes the best peanut butter there is and I use it anytime I'm making anything with peanut butter. When I'm baking anything I always buy the best ingredients possible to use in making my recipes. For instance buy real graham crackers and puree them for the two cups of graham cracker crumbs you need. Use a food processor with a metal blade in it to make your graham cracker crumbs.

Ingredients Needed For Your Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

For The Homemade Graham Cracker Pie Shell


1. Two Cups Of Fine Graham Cracker Crumbs.

2. One Fourth Cup Brown Sugar.

3. Six Tablespoons Butter At Room Temperature.

For The Filling

1. Three Egg Yolks.

2. One Half Cup Granulated Sugar.

3. One Fourth Cup Brown Sugar.

4. One Fourth Cup Cornstarch.

5. One Teaspoon Ground Sea Salt.

6. Two And One Half Cups Evaporated Milk.

7. Two Tablespoons Butter At Room Temperature.

8. Two Teaspoons Vanilla Extract.

9. One Half Cup Jiff Peanut Butter.

10. One Fourth Cup Confectioners Sugar.

In a Nine Inch Pie Pan You Will Want To Press Out Your Graham Cracker Pie Shell Made Out Of Crushed Graham Crackers, Brown Sugar, And Butter.
In a Nine Inch Pie Pan You Will Want To Press Out Your Graham Cracker Pie Shell Made Out Of Crushed Graham Crackers, Brown Sugar, And Butter. | Source

How To Make Your Graham Cracker Pie Crust

In a bowl combine the graham cracker crumbs, the brown sugar, and the butter and mix it together very well. Spray a nine inch glass pie pan with vegetable cooking spray and then using your hands press the graham cracker mixture out into the pie pan to make a graham cracker pie crust. You'll want to bake the graham cracker crust for 10 minutes at 350 degrees and then set it out and let it cool. You could make the pie with an already made graham cracker crust but you'll never get the flavor you will with a homemade one.

You'll Be Cooking The Filling For The Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie.
You'll Be Cooking The Filling For The Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie. | Source

How To Make Your Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

Combine your egg yolks, granulated sugar, brown sugar, corn starch and salt in a heavy saucepan.

Slowly whisk in your milk. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until the mixture thickens which will take about 8 - 10 minutes. Reduce the heat and continue to cook for 3 - 4 minutes until the mixture is very thick.

Beat in the butter and stir in the vanilla extract. Remove from the heat and cover with plastic wrap and let cool.

You Make Up The Confectioners Sugar And The Peanut Butter Together With Your Fingers.
You Make Up The Confectioners Sugar And The Peanut Butter Together With Your Fingers. | Source

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie Instructions

In a small bowl you'll want to combine the peanut butter with the confectioners sugar, working with your fingers to blend the ingredients to the consistency of small crumbs.

Your Going To Sprinkle The Peanut Butter Crumbs In The Bottom Of The Pie Shell.
Your Going To Sprinkle The Peanut Butter Crumbs In The Bottom Of The Pie Shell. | Source

How To Make Your Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

Sprinkle all but three tablespoons of the peanut butter crumbs evenly over the bottom of the graham cracker pie crust.

And Now Were Going To Finish Our Pie.
And Now Were Going To Finish Our Pie. | Source

How To Make Your Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie

Pour your filling into the graham cracker pie shell on top of the peanut butter and confectioners sugar crumbs. Sprinkle the top of your filling with the remaining peanut butter confectioners sugar crumbs.

Bake the pie at 350 degrees for 15 minutes and then set it out side the oven and allow it to cool for 30 minutes before you slice the pie and serve it. Serve each slice of the pie with a big spoon of whipped topping.

Once you taste this Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie I think you'll agree that its the best peanut butter pie that you've ever had. Yes it really is that good.

I want to thank you for reading my Hub Page on making an Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie. I hope you get to make one real soon.

If you have any questions feel free to ask. Thanks for reading.

Thomas Byers has been an award winning Chef for over forty years.
Thomas Byers has been an award winning Chef for over forty years. | Source

More by this Author


Please Post Your Comments About Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie And Thanks For Reading. 27 comments

crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 3 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

Thanks everyone for your comments. They are appreciated.


mts1098 profile image

mts1098 3 years ago from InsideTheManCave

First congrats on the hub of the day...second Hattie would be proud to have her recipe carry on...third I will take two mail order :) cheers and great job!


pinto2011 profile image

pinto2011 3 years ago from New Delhi, India

Hi Thomas! You have made my weekend by writing this recipe. I just cannot wait anymore.


whonunuwho profile image

whonunuwho 3 years ago from United States

Next to peanut butter cookies this sounds delicious my friend, I'll give it a try. whonu


Levertis Steele profile image

Levertis Steele 3 years ago from Southern Clime

I have never heard of peanut butter pie, but I will soon discover what one tastes like. Thanks for sharing! I'm voting up, clicking on the good buttons, and sharing.


Peggy W profile image

Peggy W 3 years ago from Houston, Texas

I have never eaten peanut butter pie but I like peanut butter and I agree that Jiff makes the best. With the homemade graham cracker crust...this sounds delicious! Thanks for your instructions and accompanying photos and congrats on getting a Hub of the Day award. Up, useful and interesting votes.


DzyMsLizzy profile image

DzyMsLizzy 3 years ago from Oakley, CA

Congratulations on Hub of the Day!

I have not only never had peanut butter pie; I've never even heard of such a thing. This sounds delicious, and a must-try.

Your instructions were very well put and clear; it sounds pretty easy, even for this non-pie-baker.

Voted up, interesting, useful and starred.


moronkee profile image

moronkee 3 years ago

It looks very good and nutritious.


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 3 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

Thanks everyone for all your great comments. This is a wonderful recipe and easy to make. Peanut Butter Pie is so delicious.


Jacante profile image

Jacante 3 years ago

Sounds amazing. I'm kind of a disaster in the kitchen, but I can't pass up giving this one a try!


sunflowerforests profile image

sunflowerforests 3 years ago from The light in the forest of doubt.

Yum yum yum....gonna have to make this one. Congratulations on your prestigious accomplishment today.


Stephanie Henkel profile image

Stephanie Henkel 3 years ago from USA

I've never tried peanut butter pie, but recently some friends were raving about how good it is. Now I'll have to try your recipe! It looks delicious, and just right for company. Voted up! Congratulations on your hub of the day!


d.william profile image

d.william 3 years ago from Somewhere in the south

What a great recipe. I have never heard of peanut butter pie, but i will surely be trying this one. Thank you so much for sharing this with us.


Victoria Lynn profile image

Victoria Lynn 3 years ago from Arkansas, USA

What a wonderful pie and a wonderful hub. Your photos are great. Well-deserved Hub of the Day. Congratulations!


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 3 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

Thanks everyone for your comments. I really appreciate them and the pie is one of the most delicious that you'll ever taste.


RTalloni profile image

RTalloni 3 years ago from the short journey

Looks wonderful--congrats on your Hub of the Day award!


Marcy Goodfleisch profile image

Marcy Goodfleisch 3 years ago from Planet Earth

Wow! So worthy of the HOTD! I have heard of this pie for years, but never tasted one and did not understand how we can get pie from peanut butter. This looks yummy and decadent! Congrats on your HOTD, and thanks for the recipe! Voted up and up!


symphonyx7 profile image

symphonyx7 3 years ago from Metro Manila, Philippines

Thanks for this. Looks sinful and easy to make. I'll try it out sometime.


HendrikDB profile image

HendrikDB 3 years ago

This one is new to me. I tried buttermilk pie, vanilla pie and pumpkin pie. This one I will try also.


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 4 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

The pie is marvelous. Thanks for the comment..


TamCor profile image

TamCor 4 years ago from Ohio

I'm one of the guilty ones who have only made the refrigerator type peanut butter pies, but mainly because my oldest son just loves them, lol.

I want to try this recipe on him, though. It sounds wonderful, and I'll just bet he--and the rest of us--will really like it!

Thanks for sharing it. :)


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 4 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

I guarantee you its wonderful. I think its the best homemade Peanut Butter Pie there is.


Tonipet profile image

Tonipet 4 years ago from The City of Generals

Let me try this one.. You bet I'll love it down the last bite. I'll be coming back if I have questions :=) Big thanks!


crazyhorsesghost profile image

crazyhorsesghost 4 years ago from East Coast , United States Author

Thanks for your comment. It is a wonderful recipe


kashmir56 profile image

kashmir56 4 years ago from Massachusetts

Another great recipe and sounds so yummy !

Vote up and more !!! SHARING !


Thelma Alberts profile image

Thelma Alberts 4 years ago from Germany

Wow! Must be delicious. Thanks for sharing. I love peanut butter pie;-)


Shesabutterfly profile image

Shesabutterfly 4 years ago from Wisconsin

I have never had peanut butter pie, but I am going to definitely try this one! I love completely from scratch recipes, and this one seems easy enough:)

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working