The truth about organic food
Organic food has become increasingly popular over the last few decades. Consumers are concerned about the health risks and environmental impacts associated with conventionally grown foods, and have turned to organic food instead. However, are we really aware of what it means to be organic? I will analyse organic food and agriculture (based mainly on the US) to try to get to the bottom of what it all really means.
According to the US Department of Agriculture (USDA), organic crops are produced without "using most conventional pesticides, petroleum-based fertilizers, or sewage-sludge based fertilizers", and also must not use genetic engineering or ionizing radiation. Animals raised organically "must be fed organic feed and given access to the outdoors" and are not given antibiotics or growth hormones. However, it's not enough simply for crops and livestock to simply be raised to these standards, they also have to undergo a certification process in order to be labelled as organic.
Organic certification and labelling standards
If a producer or processing operation wants to go organic, they must be accredited by a USDA-accredited certifying agent (unless they sell less than $5000 a year, in which case they are exempt, but can't use the USDA organic seal). Before a farm can even be accredited, its farmland must have been free from synthetic chemicals for a minimum of 3 years. There are many certifying agents in the US which verify a producer's organic system plan and perform site inspections in order to certify them as organic. They examine all parts of the process, from how the produce is grown and harvested, to its processing, packaging and shipping methods, making sure that it hasn't been contaminated by non-organic produce at any stage. It's a long and expensive process, so smaller organic producers, such as those at your local farmer's market, may not undergo the certification process despite operating to organic standards. Foreign producers may also be certified as USDA organic if a certifying agent accredits them or if the USDA accepts the certifying agents in that country.
Labelling standards (in the US):
- "100% organic" = contains only organic ingredients
- "Organic" = contains at least 95% organic ingredients
- "USDA Organic" = contains 95% or more organic ingredients
- "Made with organic ingredients" = at least 70% organic ingredients
- Processed foods containing less than 70% organic ingredients may not be labelled as organic
Some other hubs on organic food
- Natural Vs Organic Food - What's the Difference?
Diet experts and green living enthusiasts alike toss around terms like natural and organic, but what exactly do they mean?
- Organic Food Online
Organic Food farm locations have been proven to sustain diverse ecosystems to a greater degree, with a broader biodensity of plants, insects and animals...
- Sustainable Agriculture - Best Practices For Sustainable Food Production
We are beginning to look at current food production practices with an eye to how these critical systems function, and more importantly, how we can improve them...
- How Does Organic Food Affect Your Body?
The rising trends in organic foods have recently led to many people asking, just how does organic food affect your body? The truth is that organic food is generally a lot more expensive...
The health benefits of eating organic food is an area of controversy. The USDA “makes no claims that organically produced food is safer or more nutritious than conventionally produced food". A report by the UK Food Standards Agency (FSA), published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition in September 2009, concluded that organic food has no health benefits when compared with food produced through conventional methods. However, this study addressed only the "nutrients and other nutritionally relevant substances" found in the food and not the presence of contaminants, like herbicide, pesticide, and fungicide residues. Other studies have shown that organic food does lead to increased levels of antioxidants and some nutrients, but there isn't yet consensus on this within the scientific community.
Many proponents of conventional agriculture argue that by the time the food reaches your plate, most chemical residues are long gone, and that any remaining residues are not a threat to human health. However, chemical residues in the diet have been shown to cause all kinds of health problems, such as allergies, asthma and some cancers. Organic food has been shown to contain fewer residues than conventionally grown food. Proponents of organic argue that an organic diet reduces the risk of ingesting toxic chemicals; totally avoids genetically modified organisms and dramatically reduces the amount of food additives and colourings.
Finally, we must also consider the health impacts of organic farming on the farmers themselves and those who live in the vicinity. Many studies have shown that exposure to pesticides, even when used correctly, can cause serious health problems. While organic agriculture can still use certain non-organic chemicals in its production, the elimination of most chemicals leads to fewer risks to farm workers and neighbouring residents.
The Dirty Dozen: 12 foods to buy organic
The below foods are the biggest offenders when it comes to residues of pesticides, fertilizers and fungicides, so if you want to go partly organic, it's recommended that you start with these:
- Bell Peppers
- Grapes (Imported)
It's easy to jump to the conclusion that organic agriculture is good for the environment. However, the truth is that the environmental impacts of organic agriculture are extremely complex, which makes it difficult to conclude whether fewer impacts will result from organic in comparison to conventional methods. By making some generalizations and breaking it down to three main categories, we can analyse the pros and cons.
Organic agriculture doesn't use conventional pesticides, petroleum-based fertilizers, or most other chemicals. This means that fewer harmful chemicals will find their way into our groundwater and surface waters. However, one of the cited weaknesses of organic production methods is its reliance on increased tillage (the turning of the soil) for weed control. One consequence of more tillage is more disturbed soil, leading to higher rates of soil erosion. Soil erosion can lead to increased rates of sediment flowing into surface waters, which is detrimental to aquatic life. However, it is important to note that there is also evidence that suggests that some organic farms perform as well or better than conventional farms with less soil disturbance.
Air pollution and climate change:
On modern farms, more tillage can also mean more consumption of diesel and its associated impacts, like contributing to climate change and decreasing local air quality. However, the absence of the application of synthetic chemicals (often through spraying) likely means that local air quality may be improved in comparison to conventional agriculture. The transportation/distribution of agricultural goods in both organic and conventional production also plays a large role in the impact of agriculture on air quality and climate change. With the increasing popularity of organic produce, it is now being shipped much further afield than in the early 1990s.
Natural resources / wildlife:
Organic agriculture depletes less of our fossil fuel reserves, because even if it uses more diesel fuel for increased tillage, it uses no petroleum-based fertilizers or other petroleum derivatives. However, it's important to point out that many organic crops use more land because they often have lower yields than their conventional equivalent. Impacts on wildlife and ecosystems are difficult to gauge - while they would not be impacted by chemicals, the impact of other biological controls, such as insect predators, used in organic farming are varied. In general, it's thought that organic farming is beneficial for biodiversity compared to conventional farming.
Sediment from soil erosion into surface waters
Chemicals (pesticides, fertilizers) may seep into ground and surface waters
Air pollution and climate change
Emissions from transport of goods and from (possible) increased tillage
Emissions from operating equipment (application of chemicals), airborne chemicals from spraying, emissions from transport of goods
Natural resources and wildlife
Less use of fossil fuels, promotes biodiversity, more use of land
More use of fossil fuel, negative impact of pesticides/herbicides on local food webs, unknown impact from GMOs
There is no clear-cut answer about whether organic agriculture has less of an environmental impact than conventional agriculture because of all the variables involved. Only by looking at each individual product's life cycle can you get an accurate picture of which is the more environmentally sound choice. I believe that consumers should simply try to get as much information about their food as possible and make the judgement that is right for them. For me, that means trying to buy local food as much as possible, buying organic foods from the above "Dirty Dozen" List, and trying to buy more ethical/humane meat products when I can.
At least in the US, organic certification also impacts the treatment of animals. The organic standard requires that they be given organic feed, have access to outdoors and not be given any hormones or antibiotics. However, there is controversy over whether or not this means that the animals are actually treated more humanely.
The Organic Center claims that eating organic foods benefits the humane treatment of animals by:
- Assuring animals access to the outdoors and pasture, and opportunities to carry out normal behaviors.
- Increasing the average cage floor space for hens producing eggs from less than one 8"x11" piece of paper to almost three sheets.
- Reducing by nearly 200,000 the number of dairy cows injected twice each month with a genetically modified hormone used to boost milk production.
However, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) claims that the organic label does not guarantee that animals were treated any better than animals raised in conventional factory farms.
The Certified Humane Raised & Handled program is the only farm animal welfare and food labeling program in the U.S. dedicated to improving the welfare of farm animals in food production and includes all stages of the animal’s life including handling and slaughter. This program is run by Humane Farm Animal Care (HFAC), a non-profit organization whose major principles are that animals are able to engage in natural behaviour, they have sufficient space, shelter, access to fresh water and are raised without antibiotics or hormones (www.certifiedhumane.com). Products labeled as "Certified Humane" have been raised to these standards, but are not necessarily free-range or organic.
Some interesting links
- The FSA paper on the nutritional value of organic food
- Pesticide Residues In Conventional, IPM-Grown And Organic Foods: Insights From Three U.S. Data Sets
- EWG\'s Shopper\'s Guide to Pesticides | Environmental Working Group
EWG's FoodNews offers users a downloadable shopper's guide showing what fruit and vegetables to buy organic.
- The Organic Center
- Home | Certifedhumane.org
Food for thought...
There are many issues related to organic food production and consumption, which makes it difficult for consumers to know what choices to make. I don't want to jump to any conclusions over the benefits and drawbacks of organic food, I simply want to look at the facts and then make the decisions that are right for me. I hope that this has provided you with some food for thought and that you are now a little more informed about some of the issues related to organic food.
Comments 14 comments
Other hubs by Chirls
- The environmental impacts of offshore drilling
If there had been any doubt before, the recent catastrophe on the Deepwater Horizon in the Gulf of Mexico has really driven home the message that drilling for oil is a messy and risky business. Consequently, decisions are now being made that affect t
- How to reduce food waste... and lower your grocery bill, too!
How many times have you gone to get something out of the veggie drawer and found half a celery wilting away at the bottom of it? Or you've gone into the fridge to get some milk, only to find that it's gone bad, and you have to pour it down the sink.
- Is Earth Day still worthwhile?
Earth Day has been in existence for 40 years. There is no question in my mind that the first Earth Day and many Earth Days since then have been extremely important, but is it still relevant today? Or has it...
- A beginner's guide to making sushi
Sushi is becoming more and more popular all around the world. Eating out for sushi can be a great experience, but is often quite expensive. Making your own sushi is really fun and easy to do, and might save...
- Cooking on the BBQ: Meats on sticks
Cooking meat on skewers is a great way to barbecue. Barbecuing is a great way to cook all kinds of foods, but especially meat, poultry and fish. To quote the film There's Something About Mary, "I don't think that they have enough meats on sticks"...
- Three sure-fire BBQ side dishes
Barbecuing is a fun and easy way to cook a casual meal for your friends and family. Anyone can prepare a simple potato salad, cole slaw or macaroni salad, and these are all great side dishes to go with a BBQ...
- How to cook quick and healthy meals in 5 easy steps
In recent years, our relationship with food has changed. These days people are much more likely to eat out or buy ready made meals than to cook from scratch. There is a time and a place for convenience foods...
- Eat less, move more: The big, fat truth about weight loss
Weight loss is really simple when you break it down to the basics. It's all mathematics: you simply have to consume less calories than your body burns. But that doesn't mean it's easy! Read on to find out the truth about weight loss and get some tips
More by this Author
Pulses and grains are a good source of protein, but if you're a meat-eater then you've probably never had to worry about getting enough protein in your diet. On the other hand, most vegetarians have probably had to...
Sushi is becoming more and more popular all around the world. Eating out for sushi can be a great experience, but is often quite expensive. Making your own sushi is really fun and easy to do, and might save you some...
If there had been any doubt before, the recent catastrophe on the Deepwater Horizon in the Gulf of Mexico has really driven home the message that drilling for oil is a messy and risky business. Consequently, decisions...