jump to last post 1-27 of 27 discussions (40 posts)

Miracle Whip or Mayonaise?

  1. heart4theword profile image64
    heart4thewordposted 6 years ago

    Are you a Miracle Whip Person or are you a Mayonaise Person.  Seems like we all grew up learning to like on or the other?  Maybe you don't like either?  Just was thinking this might be a fun question to ask. 

    Then there is regular Mustard, Brown Mustard or Poupon Mustard?
    Is there any you who have a preference about?  I know this might be a shallow topic, but had to ask?

    1. Cagsil profile image84
      Cagsilposted 6 years ago in reply to this

      Miracle Whip is excellent compared to mayo.

      As for Mustard- Golden's Spicy Mustard will do. smile

      1. B.T. Evilpants profile image60
        B.T. Evilpantsposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Shallow topic? Au Contraire! This is a topic of unfathomable depth, at the bottom of which we may find the holy grail, the meaning of life, perhaps even the true location of Waldo. This subject is near and dear to my heart, and I have contemplated  it much over the years.

        Personally I prefer Miracle Whip for tuna salad and egg salad, but the real deal is awesome for burgers and sandwiches.

      2. Jeff Berndt profile image93
        Jeff Berndtposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        I like them both, but prefer mayonnaise.

        Also, dijon mustard or brown mustard are both preferable to the traditional American chemistry-set-tasting "yellow mustard."

      3. PhoenixV profile image79
        PhoenixVposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        miracle whip I think

      4. Keyttle profile image59
        Keyttleposted 5 years ago in reply to this

        Mayonaise, but not just any, has to be Best Foods Mayonaise.

        Best for potatoe salads, dips and sandwhiches in my opinion smile

    2. Eaglekiwi profile image74
      Eaglekiwiposted 6 years ago

      These are American brands right?
      I like them all smile

    3. Onusonus profile image86
      Onusonusposted 6 years ago

      Miracle whip is an abomination. Mayonaise all the way!

      1. Jerami profile image78
        Jeramiposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Be very careful of which you speak.

           You have trampled upon holy ground.

           Miracle whip is the only true path to a delicious sandwich.

    4. Ohma profile image81
      Ohmaposted 6 years ago

      Mayonnaise absolutely. Hellmans only mind you.

      1. libby101a profile image61
        libby101aposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        I agree 100%! Hellmans is the only way to go! MMMmm yummmy!

    5. Eaglekiwi profile image74
      Eaglekiwiposted 6 years ago

      Hellmans popular in the North
      Duke in the South, (bit too gloopy for me )

    6. girly_girl09 profile image79
      girly_girl09posted 6 years ago

      Ok, it may sound really gross, but Veganaise is AWESOME. No one believes me until I make them a tuna or egg salad with it. You would never know the difference, although I think it tastes even better. Much healthier for you, too!

    7. SandyMcCollum profile image84
      SandyMcCollumposted 6 years ago

      Mayo, definitely!

      When I was a kid we ate Miracle Whip and I didn't hate it then but didn't really like it, either. Ever since I'm on my own I only get mayo for the house and when I taste something someone else made with MW it's so obviously different. Miracle Whip is a dressing to add spices to, mayo is for sandwiches.

    8. heart4theword profile image64
      heart4thewordposted 6 years ago

      Enjoying your feed back:) 

      Have to share with you a small story:  One day I had ordered a sandwich for my husband, and asked the lady to put poupon mustard on his sandwich.  At the time our daughter was small...she tugged on my shirt and said, mom why would dad want poop on his sandwich:) 

      Really never thought about other countries not having access to our brands of Mayonaise or Miracle whip?

    9. KCC Big Country profile image83
      KCC Big Countryposted 6 years ago

      I can't stand Miracle Whip....has to be Kraft Real Mayonnaise.

    10. Rafini profile image81
      Rafiniposted 6 years ago

      Hellman's Real Mayonaise is the only mayonaise I'll eat on a sandwich.  Although, egg salad, tuna salad, and potato salad have to have Miracle Whip. hmm

    11. Canklefish profile image76
      Canklefishposted 6 years ago

      Miracle Whip on some days, Helmann's mayo on others... Simple as that

    12. kids-toy-box profile image56
      kids-toy-boxposted 6 years ago

      I prefer mustard to mayo.

      1. Sab Oh profile image59
        Sab Ohposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        No need to choose one or the other. Put 'em together!

    13. Just_Rodney profile image42
      Just_Rodneyposted 6 years ago

      Fellow victims of Mayo in all forms!

      Having tasted MW Hellemans and C&B both traditional and the light versions.
      I have come to this conclusion and after many many t=years, still prefer making my own.
      My ratings on the types of oil I use I must in all honesty plumb for the Virgin Avocado oil, maybe a bit expensive, hey but when you need Mayo, you need the real thing!!!!!!!!!!

    14. Carrie.M profile image62
      Carrie.Mposted 6 years ago

      To be honest I prefer the taste of Miracle Whip over Mayo but will always choose Mayo for health reasons. Have you checked the ingredients list of Miracle Whip compared to real Mayo? If I can't pronounce it, I don't eat it.

    15. brianzen profile image61
      brianzenposted 6 years ago

      Mayo, and especially with dill relish.

      1. Jeff Berndt profile image93
        Jeff Berndtposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        YES! Dill relish is vastly tastier than sweet relish. I had no idea that dill relish even existed when I was a kid. I didn't even bother looking for it when I first started doing my own grocery shopping. Imagine my joy when I first encountered it at a barbecue while I was at university.

        1. mom101 profile image61
          mom101posted 6 years ago in reply to this

          Mayo. Of course.

    16. Lisa HW profile image83
      Lisa HWposted 6 years ago

      Mayo if any of that kind of thing.

      I had a friend (HAD a friend lol ) who would invite me to lunch at her house.  Lunch was a store-brand tuna sandwich with Miracle Whip on store-brand bread.  If she made a cheese sandwich it was Velveeta slices with Miracle Whip on store bread!  mad  THEN - she asked if I wanted to coffee and put the remains of the pot of her morning coffee out of the refrigerator to re-heat!  Whatever she served she'd explain, "It's just as good."   mad  I learned that when I visited her I should eat lunch first and accept only tea at her "den of hospitality".  lol  lol

      1. heart4theword profile image64
        heart4thewordposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Velveeta, now that is another subject of discussion.  Haven't heard anyone talk about that one for a long time:)  I remember my mom using it to make macaroni and cheese, and grilled chese at times.  When I was a kid, didn't know of any other options!  You just ate what was given to you:)

    17. 0
      china manposted 6 years ago

      choose your fat poison - both will get you in the end, the rear end mostly big_smile

      1. Lisa HW profile image83
        Lisa HWposted 6 years ago in reply to this

        lol   The funny thing is this is how she ate all the time, and she was as slender as anyone could be.   (Of course, I have no clue if she's had had a heart attack and dropped dead by now.  lol  )

    18. Sab Oh profile image59
      Sab Ohposted 6 years ago

      For true mayo joy, try Kewpie!

    19. evvy_09 profile image87
      evvy_09posted 6 years ago

      Miracle whip!  Though ranch dressing is better. NOT buttermilk ranch but Hidden valley original. smile As for mustard I love honey mustard but yellow is good on scrambled eggs.


      P.S. I just love being able to put pictures in with my posts.

      1. mom101 profile image61
        mom101posted 6 years ago in reply to this

        Ooops. Just saw the mustard part.
        When dad and I would get a corn dog, i would smother mine in mustard. ........

        When I was 14 or so, a family member was expecting her first baby...I helped give her a baby shower, One of the games was the dirty diaper game. I made the diapers (napkins folded and pinned as would a diaper be). The dirty diaper was you got it...It had a squirt of mustard in it and the person lucky enough to get the dirty diaper won the prize.......I had eaten so much cake, drank way too much punch, nuts, chips, tuna salad and was feeling a little "puky".  But we were playing the game, and guess who got the dirty diaper. Oh yeah.

        I have not liked mustart since.

    20. FloBe profile image82
      FloBeposted 6 years ago

      Definitely Miracle Whip--nothing better than a toasted tomato sandwich with Miracle Whip on it!

    21. Aficionada profile image94
      Aficionadaposted 6 years ago

      Miracle Whip?  Never ever.  Never, never.  Never ever ever never.

      Mayonnaise absolutely. Hellman's if possible.  But we have also amazingly found some generic (store) brands that are almost as good, at least for tuna or chicken or ham salad.

      Mustard?  preferably not Ballpark (yellow) mustard, but it's okay on a rare occasion.  Unfortunately I've had to give up mustard, but almost any other kind (Poupon, German, others...) is good for those who can eat it.

      Relish fanciers - try piccalilli.  Mine's homemade from green tomatoes.  Mmmm!

    22. sabrinaaq profile image48
      sabrinaaqposted 5 years ago


    23. kerryg profile image86
      kerrygposted 5 years ago

      Real mayonnaise for me!

      Miracle Whip is not quite as awful as Cool Whip, but it's bad enough. tongue

    24. sim0n30 profile image59
      sim0n30posted 5 years ago

      Always mayo!

    25. heart4theword profile image64
      heart4thewordposted 5 years ago

      For those who use Miracle Whip, did you convert to "Miracle Whip Lite?"  and now there is a "Mayo Lite" for the mayo people...any of you convert?  Just curious:)

    26. restoremyheart profile image61
      restoremyheartposted 5 years ago

      I like cream cheese on my sandwiches!

    27. writinginalaska profile image83
      writinginalaskaposted 5 years ago

      can't stand MW,  that stuff is disgusting.  Mayo for me please and spicy brown mustard too.