Homemade Oxtail and Oyster Pie Recipe

Braised oxtail and fresh oysters form the filling for this puff pastry pie which is served with chive buttered new potatoes and garden peas
Braised oxtail and fresh oysters form the filling for this puff pastry pie which is served with chive buttered new potatoes and garden peas

Oxtail and Oysters

Oxtail and oysters is by no means such an unlikely combination as you may at first think. It also has a certain ring to it. Oxtail is perhaps most commonly associated with oxtail soup but it should be remembered that it is essentially just a cheaper cut of beef. Oysters for their part are in modern times viewed as a food for the upper classes, or at least someone with a little extra cash in their pocket. This was by no means always the case with oysters, however, and the time was that they were so plentiful and so cheap that they were very much a poor man's food. It was for this reason that oysters were often incorporated in steak and kidney puddings in Victorian times along with the cheapest cuts of beef.

Oysters for me are best eaten straight from the sea, simply shucked and still alive. I don't think my opinion will ever change in that respect but if I do have to eat oysters cooked, this is unquestionably one of my favourite recipe ideas.

Oxtail and Oyster Pie Ingredients

Piece of oxtail and fresh oysters represent pie filling
Piece of oxtail and fresh oysters represent pie filling

Cook Time

  • Prep time: 3 hours
  • Cook time: 2 hours 30 min
  • Ready in: 5 hours 30 min
  • Yields: One satisfying portion

Ingredients

  • ¾ lb piece of oxtail
  • ½ small onion, peeled and sliced
  • 1oz butter, plus extra for potatoes
  • 2 pints fresh beef stock
  • 4 fresh oysters, shucked
  • 4oz puff pastry
  • Beaten egg, for glazing pastry
  • Small new potatoes, quantity as desired
  • 2 tbsp frozen garden peas
  • 1 tsp freshly chopped chives
  • Salt and black pepper

How to Make Oxtail and Oyster Pie

Click thumbnail to view full-size
Browning the oxtail in butter and oilBrowned oxtailCooked and cooled oxtailOxtail meat is separated from bone and gristleOxtail is laid in base of mini 5" by 4" pie dishShucking oystersOysters and juices are added to oxtailStock is added to almost cover meat and oystersPastry is rolled and cut to sizePie is glazed and ready for the oven
Browning the oxtail in butter and oil
Browning the oxtail in butter and oil
Browned oxtail
Browned oxtail
Cooked and cooled oxtail
Cooked and cooled oxtail
Oxtail meat is separated from bone and gristle
Oxtail meat is separated from bone and gristle
Oxtail is laid in base of mini 5" by 4" pie dish
Oxtail is laid in base of mini 5" by 4" pie dish
Shucking oysters
Shucking oysters
Oysters and juices are added to oxtail
Oysters and juices are added to oxtail
Stock is added to almost cover meat and oysters
Stock is added to almost cover meat and oysters
Pastry is rolled and cut to size
Pastry is rolled and cut to size
Pie is glazed and ready for the oven
Pie is glazed and ready for the oven
Victorinox Oyster Knife 2-3/4-Inch Hooked Tip New Haven Style Blade, Red SuperGrip Handle
Victorinox Oyster Knife 2-3/4-Inch Hooked Tip New Haven Style Blade, Red SuperGrip Handle

A knife designed for doing the job properly is a good idea when shucking oysters for several reasons. It makes the job easier, it prevents unnecessary damage to the oyster and it makes the process safer. If you shuck oysters regularly or intend doing so in future, this small investment will pay for itself many times over.

 
  1. Add the butter to a fairly large pot. You may also wish to add a little olive oil to help prevent it burning. Gently melt.
  2. Wash and dry the oxtail. Add it to the pot, season and quickly brown and seal it all over in the butter. Do not forget the ends.
  3. Remove the oxtail from the pot and add the onion to brown in the same way.
  4. Re-add the oxtail to the pot and pour in the beef stock. If the stock does not completely cover the oxtail, simply add a little boiling water.
  5. Bring the stock to the gentlest possible simmer, cover and leave to cook for two and a half hours, checking occasionally to see whether the liquid requires a slight top up with more boiling water.
  6. After the two and a half hours, turn off the heat and leave the oxtail to cool - in the liquid - for two further hours.
  7. The oxtail should now be comfortably cool enough to remove the meat by hand. There is no better way of doing this if you want to glean as much of the meat as possible from the bone.
  8. Peel off the excess fat and gristle and work your way around the circumference of the oxtail, picking off the meat as you go. Discard the cleaned bone and pieces of fat and gristle.
  9. Note that all of the above procedures could very effectively be conducted the night before you intend making this pie for dinner. Simply refrigerate the meat overnight in a plastic container then proceed from this point onwards the next night to cook and assemble the remainder of the meal.
  10. Put your oven on to preheat to 425F/210C.
  11. Lay the oxtail meat in the bottom of a 5" by 4" individual pie dish.
  12. Shuck (open) the oysters - see instructional video below this section - and pour the meat and juices on top of the oxtail.
  13. Spoon in enough of the stock in which the oxtail cooked to almost but not quite cover the beef and oysters.
  14. Roll out the puff pastry large enough that you can cut a 5" by 4" rectangle from it. Lay the pastry on top of the pie and tuck in around the edges.
  15. Glaze the pastry with beaten egg and make a steam vent in the centre. Put the dish on a baking tray and in to the oven for about thirty minutes, or until the pastry is beautifully risen and golden.

Video Guide to Shucking Oysters

Preparing the Potatoes and Peas and Plating Up

Click thumbnail to view full-size
Oxtail and oyster pie must be rested when it comes out of the ovenButter and chives are added to potatoesOxtail and oyster pie is plated
Oxtail and oyster pie must be rested when it comes out of the oven
Oxtail and oyster pie must be rested when it comes out of the oven
Butter and chives are added to potatoes
Butter and chives are added to potatoes
Oxtail and oyster pie is plated
Oxtail and oyster pie is plated

How to Cook the Potatoes and Peas

  1. When the pie is in the oven, add the potatoes (unpeeled) to a pot of cold, salted water and bring it to a boil. Simmer for around twenty-five minutes to half an hour, until the potatoes are soft.
  2. Remove the pie from the oven and set aside to rest on a heatproof surface.
  3. Put the peas in to a pot of boiling water for three minutes.
  4. Drain the potatoes and return them to the pot.
  5. Add the butter and chives and gently swirl the pot to coat them all evenly.
  6. Drain the peas.
  7. Plate the pie with the potatoes and peas alongside and serve.

Oxtail and oyster puff pastry pie with chive buttered potatoes and peas is ready to serve
Oxtail and oyster puff pastry pie with chive buttered potatoes and peas is ready to serve

Thank You for Visiting - Hopefully You Enjoyed this Idea

5 stars from 1 rating of this oxtail and oyster pie

More by this Author

  • EDITOR'S CHOICE
    How to Cook a Beef or Ox Tongue
    4

    Step by step guide in text and pictures to cooking a whole beef or ox tongue. Includes a variety of different recipes and serving suggestions to enjoy fresh beef tongue or leftovers.

  • EDITOR'S CHOICE
    Steak, Beetroot and Stilton Pie Recipe
    22

    Steak pie is a classic Scottish dish. This recipe is a twist on the original, incorporating sweet beetroot and delicious Stilton cheese to pack the pie with a fabulous array of additional flavours.

  • EDITOR'S CHOICE
    How to Cook Duck Eggs 10 Different Ways
    27

    Duck eggs make a wonderfully tasty and refreshing change from chicken eggs and can largely be cooked almost exactly the same way. This page features ten different ways in which you can cook duck eggs (or chicken eggs)...


2 comments

Gordon Hamilton profile image

Gordon Hamilton 4 years ago from Wishaw, Lanarkshire, United Kingdom Author

Thanks, Kelley, for visit, comment and vote.


kelleyward 4 years ago

Yum! This looks interesting. I like how you shared the detailed pictures! Voted up! Kelley

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working