Are Pickled Onions Good or Bad for You - Discover the Health Benefits

Pickled Onions - Good or Bad for You
Pickled Onions - Good or Bad for You | Source

Discover why pickled onions are both good and bad for you. Healthy benefits vs. unhealthy ingredients. The nutritional and health benefits of onions make them a staple of a healthy diet. But can the same be said for pickled onions? Drawbacks outweigh benefits.

Pickled onions - healthy, but not your best friend

The question; "Are pickled onions good or bad for you?" has a simple answer - yes.

Yes, they can be a beneficial part of a healthy diet, and yes they can be bad for you because of the salt, vinegar, and preservatives used in the pickling process, (plus the high sugar content of the onions themselves).

The qualifier for both answers is one word - moderation.

An onion's nutritional benefits have long been known, and in many cultures they are a dietary staple eaten daily. But pickled onions are very different, and it is the pickling process that changes the health aspect of an onion from, "eat all you want," to "eat in moderation" - because too much pickled onion can be bad for you.

Then there is the question of different kinds of pickled onions - is one better or worse for you than the other?

Pickled Onions Dietary facts:

  • Typical serving size: approx. 3.5 oz (100 g)
  • Calories.................: approx. 23 calories
  • Type of calories.....: 87.5% carbohydrates, 12.5% protien
  • Nutrition provided..: 7 g of fiber, .8 g of protein, 4.9 g carbohydrates, and .1 g of fat


The Pickled Onion Health and Benefits Short Answers

The short answer for the good vs bad question is that for most normally-healthy people, eating pickled onions - in moderation - is fine. The onions still retain their nutritional values, and the pickling ingredients will not be harmful in typical moderate amounts.

As mentioned, the pickling process does use large amounts of salt and sugar, (plus the onion's own sugar), and these are two dietary intakes that you should always be conscious of. Especially people with health issues like high blood pressure or diabetes.

Also, because of the acidic content of vinegar, people who eat a lot of pickled foods have a higher rate of Gastric (stomach) Cancers.

Typical pickling Ingredients

  • Vinegar: Apple Cider, Malt, Balsamic, White
  • Pickling Sesonings
  • Salt: Table, Kosher, Pickling
  • Sugar
  • Flavor seasonings: Mustard seed, Coriander Seed, All Spice, Garlic, etc.

It is the pickling ingredients that are not your friend

Onions, before pickling, have good nutritional values. They are very low in saturated fat, cholesterol and sodium, and are a good source of dietary fiber, vitamin B6, folate, potassium and manganese, and also vitamin C. Unlikely as it seems, they are also high in sugar content. A medium yellow onion can have as much as 7 grams of sugar content.

But, when pickled...

It is the large amount of vinegar and salt contained in a pickled onion that outweigh the original nutritional benefits of an onion. Either one, in moderate amounts, is not harmful. Salt is a necessary part of any diet, but in small amounts. Vinegar has long been believed to have health benefits also, but the acidity of vinegar is nobody's friend. A pickled onion retains large amounts of both these ingredients, making them fine for as an occasional part of a diet, but not a routine segment. Pickled onions are similar to eggs - good once in a while, but bad as an everyday food.

Does it matter what kind of pickled onion it is?

Another easy answer - yes and no.

The "no" part of that answer addresses the fact that even using different pickling methods and recipes - the basic ingredients are still; salt, sugar, and vinegar, so the same health concerns apply.

The "yes" part of the answer applies to the pickling recipe and the way the onions are served.

Popular types of pickled onions
Popular types of pickled onions | Source

Types of Pickled Onion Recipes

Regarding the recipes; some call for a quick pickling process that imparts the flavor, but doesn't really include the ingredients soaking to the core of the onion, so there will be less of the potentially concerning ingredients ingested.

How to Cook Pickled Onions - American Style

British Pickled Onions

Whereas other recipes, like traditional British pickled onions, call for soaking whole onions in the pickling brine for a day or more - allowing the ingredients to completely permeate to the core of the onion - meaning much more of the salt and vinegar are consumed.

How to Make Pickled Onions - Traditional English Style

Pickled onions as an accompaniment

Pickled onions have a long and multicultural history as a side-dish or accompaniment to other foods. It is not typically a food eaten by itself.

Sliced pickled onions are used as a condiment for a sandwich. Below you can see a video on how to cook pickled onions to be used as a topping for entree'-type foods.

Sliced Pickled Onions

Sliced pickled onions are used as a condiment for a sandwich
Sliced pickled onions are used as a condiment for a sandwich | Source

Small Pickled Onions

Small pickled onions used as an accompaniment to a gorgeous looking Dutch potato salad. Note the small potion size when used this way.

Small pickled onions used as an accompaniment
Small pickled onions used as an accompaniment | Source

Pickled Pearl Onions

Small pickled Pearl onions as a side dish to a Danish sausage recipe.

Small pickled Pearl onions and Danish Sausage
Small pickled Pearl onions and Danish Sausage | Source

Was this information helpful?

See results without voting
GA Anderson aka the Curmudgeon
GA Anderson aka the Curmudgeon | Source

About the Author


*Composite image component source citations: Creative Commons images from:commons.wikimedia.org, flickr.com/creativecommons, search.creativecommons.org, http://googlesystem.blogspot.com/2009/06/find-creative-commons-images-in-google.html, and personal art and graphic programs: GreenStreet Clipart, Print Shop, Art Explosion Pro Silver Edition Publishing program - *photo and image source credits: divider and separation images - http://gaanderson.hubpages.com

More by this Author


Discover the Paradox of Pickled Onions Comments 10 comments

Rain Defence profile image

Rain Defence 4 years ago from UK

Well I have always known that pickled onions are bad for you, but they're delicious with cheese, pickle and a pork & chicken pie. Have you ever tried the king of pickled items, pickled eggs? They're the best!


GA Anderson profile image

GA Anderson 4 years ago from USA Author

@Rain Defence - thanks for reading and commenting on "Discover the Paradox of Pickled Onions."

I love onions - yet have never tried a pickled one (I don't like pickles), but a pickled egg sounds err... interesting. That I may try

Thanks again for the comment

GA


Tultul Ganguly 4 years ago

With full of my respect I want to ask you a question? If YOU think we people are immortal.Today or tomorrow we have to die, How can I will die I don't know, not even you may

know how can you die? I may die in a road accident or you

may die in an earthquake? If WE don't even know how can we

die, then to me what is the use of always be scared about our health? Yes of course we have to follow some health routine for our basic protection,try to not to be ill for a long period, causing problem of others. It's

fine,but to me I got a very precious life, to me I want to enjoy the every moment of it,without tension,without headache, but in real life it seems to be impossible. So if I or any one will try the test of pickled onion and enjoying it, though it may cause any illness, after knowing this, If we want to get rid of some problems for a hours by testing the tests of pickled onion,then what will be a big problem?

MY ENGLISH IS VERY POOR,FORGIVE ME FOR THAT,


GA Anderson profile image

GA Anderson 4 years ago from USA Author

@tultul - uumm... thanks for reading "Discover the Paradox of Pickled Onions," and the comment... I think.

GA


Wesley Meacham profile image

Wesley Meacham 4 years ago from Wuhan, China

An interesting read. I've lived in Louisiana for the vast majority of my life and though I may well at some point have seen a pickled onion, I'm drawing a blank. I don't think that I have seen this popular side dish of the deep south. However... Vidallia is a small town in which the main crop is onions and Vidallia onions are (pickled or not) are fairly well known.

None of that really detracts any from the hub. I could easily just have missed them. I have to agree with you that moderation is a key. Though I understand tutul's comment (surprising I know) I don't agree with him. I've found that there are many things I enjoy that moderation actually enhances. Some things simply taste better if you endulge once or twice a month rather than every day. At the same time there are a myriad other things we might be missing out on if all we endulge in is pickled onions.

Well written hub and informative. Voting up and sharing.


peachpurple profile image

peachpurple 3 years ago from Home Sweet Home

i didn't know pickled onions have disadvantages. Salt and vinegar are indeed bad for health but if we do not consume often, I think it wouldn't hurt much. Thanks for sharing this hub.


GA Anderson profile image

GA Anderson 3 years ago from USA Author

@peachpurple - Thanks for taking the time to comment - and you are right, as with all things, moderation is the key.

GA


Donnie1000 3 years ago

Hmm, not sure what you mean by moderation as obviously everyone has different tastes. But an entire 440g jar of the pickled onions I eat drained (235g of onions) has the following:

Sugar - 8.5g

Salt - 0.25g

Considering the daily recommendation for sugar is 90g and salt 6g those are extremely low, and that's for an entire large jar.

As it happens I would always eat these in moderation because of the vinegar being quite acidic and simply because I can't imagine eating an entire jar (I love them but even half a jar is too much of a good thing to me).

Still I don't get the sugar/salt warning, unless there are some massively different pickling processes out their, because 8.5g of sugar and 0.25g of salt for 235g of food is really extremely low.


janshares profile image

janshares 24 months ago from Washington, DC

Very informative, GA Anderson. I just had a burger at a restaurant last weekend with pickled onions. It was a tasty change from fresh cut onions. I had know idea until I came across this hub of the amount a sugar already in onions. My favorite are Vidalias which is a sweet onion. I don't eat pickled onions often but now I know to eat them in moderation, as a garnish and not as a side vegetable. I do watch my salt intake. Voted up, useful, and interesting.


Mark 11 months ago

"Pickled onions are similar to eggs - good once in a while, but bad as an everyday food". Surely no real nutritionist thinks that way about eggs now? Eggs are a superb everyday food.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working