Lance Mindheim – Discover His Secret: A Review of “How To Design A Small Switching Layout”

Lance Mindheim can help you finally get a layout with your spouse’s blessing. You talk about taking over the entire basement for your dream layout. Your spouse says no. You beg for a small room on which you can close the door so the layout bothers no one. The answer is still no. You pull out How To Design a

Lance Mindheim Techniques

Why? In his book, the master of custom layout design, Lance Mindheim, advocates a few simple principles so layouts can co-exist peacefully with the rest of the household. The most important of these is using a shelf layout occupying only a corner or two of the room. The shelf width ranges only from 12 to 24 inches, and is mounted close to eye level, allowing room for furniture underneath. Lance Mindheim also suggests decorative framing and lights, making your creation look like a work of art.

Lance Mindheim Sample Railroad

Well, those principles satisfy the ruler of your household, but what about you? Lance Mindheim addresses hobbyist concerns with an HO sample layout that is a 10 x 10-foot L-shape, with an 18-inch width, no grades, and a 24-inch minimum radius. He offers step-by-step procedures, with the first half involving planning. Here, Lance Mindheim discusses strategic concerns that include writing down your interests and time, setting the benchwork footprint, selecting industries and roughing in their locations.

In the second half of his process, Lance Mindheim talks about track planning. He specifies elegant and simple runs, with no return loops. This may disappoint train watchers, but allows more track and scenery in smaller spaces. Add enough turnouts to handle the planned industries, and you get hours of operational interest. Lance Mindheim even leaves room on one end for a six track yard, so those who collect freight cars have a place to display them. An optional one-track staging area can attach to one end of the example, so foreign engines can be brought in and out as needed.

Lance Mindheim's book
Lance Mindheim's book | Source

Lance Mindheim Conclusions

Aside from many full-color diagrams and photos, Lance Mindheim offers numbers for measurements and standards honed from years of experience. For example, he recommends a minimum of 1.25” between a track and the front edge of a layout, with 2.5” to 3” being better. These specific recommendations tell me that Lance Mindheim knows what he’s talking about. (You can check out the Lance Mindheim website for more information about his activities.)

The book is pricey at $21.95 for only 68 pages. And the fonts are large, with lines of text running uncomfortably long across the page. Lance Mindheim was obviously trying to fill up space for this self-published effort. But he could’ve done so with more layouts beyond the main example, and two bonus plans, which oddly enough, have no description or commentary.

Lance Mindheim and his book “How to Design A Small Switching Layout” gets high marks for me because of the useful tips and information found nowhere else.

More by this Author


Comments 2 comments

Danette Watt profile image

Danette Watt 5 years ago from Illinois

I haven't read your other train hubs yet (linked over from your recent forum question) but it sounds like you are quite knowledgeable. My husband still has a Lionel train set that he got when he was a kid in the 1950s. We've had it set up at various times over the years, but mainly when the kids were little. Voted up


alocsin profile image

alocsin 5 years ago from Orange County, CA Author

Thanks Danette. I just like the hobby a lot. You guys can probably set up a permanent Lionel train layout if you wanted, though it does take a lot of space.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working