Can You Solve Larry's Polygon Puzzle?

Racetrack Playa, Death Valley National Park, California
Racetrack Playa, Death Valley National Park, California | Source

Background

When we studied plane geometry in high school, we learned the concept of congruent polygons. Basically, two plywood polygons are congruent if we can put one of them on top of the other one, and if all of the sides are flush with each other. It may be necessary to flip one of the two polygons in order to achieve congruence, even though flipping is not explicitly stated in Euclid's postulates.

We also learned several congruence theorems for triangles. Here are two examples:

Two triangles are congruent if two of the sides--plus the angle between them--of Triangle A match up with the corresponding ones of Triangle B. Ditto for two angles and the included side.

These are known as Side Angle Side and Angle Side Angle, and by the acronym, SAS and ASA, respectively. Other congruence theorems include: SSS (Side Side Side) and AAS (Angle Angle Side).

However larger polygons--quadrilaterals, pentagons, hexagons, heptagons, octagons, nonagons, decagons, etc.--are trickier. And the friendly congruence theorems that work so nicely for triangles do not necessarily apply to more complicated polygons.


In Northern Canada, the natural polygons in the foreground are formed by alternate melting and refreezing of the permafrost.
In Northern Canada, the natural polygons in the foreground are formed by alternate melting and refreezing of the permafrost. | Source
Everyone's least favorite polygon.
Everyone's least favorite polygon.

The puzzle

An N-gon is a polygon with N sides and N angles. Suppose that we have two plywood N-gons. Let's also assume that there's a one-to-one correspondence between the sides of N-gon A and those of N-gon B. However the matching sides of the two n-gons are not necessarily in the same order.

Let's make a similar assumption about the angles of the two N-gons. Let's also assume that N-gons A and B are not triangles. Then it is not necessarily true that N-gons A and B are congruent.

The puzzle: What is the smallest possible value for N, such that N-gons A and B are not necessarily congruent? And yes, flipping is allowed.

In other words, we're looking for two NON-identical N-gons whose sides and angles match up, one for one, but in different orders. Having found one such pair of N-gons, can you find another pair of 'paradoxical' N-gons that have a smaller value of N?


A hint and a few more things

This puzzle illustrates the idea that muddling, which has gotten a bad reputation, is a perfectly valid problem-solving technique.

Having a mathematical background will not be particularly helpful in solving this puzzle. Formulas and equations are not relevant here. The only tools that you need are a pencil, a ruler, a protractor, and lots of paper. Or you can treat it as a 'pillow problem'.

Hint: The two non-identical hexagons in these crude hand drawings have identical sides and angles. However their orders are different. Pentagons, anyone?


About Racetrack Playa

I chose the photo at the top of this hub, because it has lots of small polygons in the foreground. Racetrack Playa is arguably the biggest mystery of Death Valley National Park. We're still not sure about how these large stones move around, leaving tracks in their wake.

Copyright 2011 and 2015 by Larry Fields

How do you think that the 'sailing stones' at Racetrack Playa move around?

See results without voting

More by this Author


Comments 3 comments

Teresa Coppens profile image

Teresa Coppens 4 years ago from Ontario, Canada

I can see Larry how it works in your diagram. At 8 am in the morning and not having had my first cup of coffee, replicating your results on my own would be a stretch. Come to think of it, even with the coffee it would be a stretch. I will pass this on to my husband who has significantly more patience and wisdom in these matters!


Larry Fields profile image

Larry Fields 4 years ago from Northern California Author

Hi Teresa. Thanks for stopping by.


jackclee lm profile image

jackclee lm 16 months ago from Yorktown NY

Larry, the moving rocks mystery was solved.

http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-rocks-...

Interesting puzzle...

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working