After Injury Why x-Ray vs. MRI?

Be sure to experience all there is to see in life. Amazing Colors

Spring time blooms are the best.
Spring time blooms are the best. | Source

Why pushing for an MRI "at first" may not work

After one has an injury, soft tissue damage almost always occurs. Regardless of whether a fractured, broken bone or soft tissue damage; services to diagnose the injury is applied to determine a course of treatment. And a concern that should be understood by the patient: When should you have an x-Ray vs. an MRI?

It is most probable you’ll be referred for an x-Ray at first to diagnose the underlying damage of an injury area. Why is this non-intrusive viewing of your inners a gold standard? Because when you injure a joint or muscle area that is swollen, painful and/or discolored, the doctor wants to rule out fractures or other soft tissue anomalies.

If your pain is chronic at the joint, or muscle area and it never goes away surgery may be necessary. Surgery is always the last resort one should seek in order to resolve a soft “partial” tissue tear (muscle, tendon, and ligament). The doctor’s decision making process will follow a medical protocol to determine the extent of the injured area through diagnosis, treatment and follow up.

However, if the pain continues to be unbearable and you now aren’t participating in physical therapy, or have immobilized the area and/or exceeding your pain medication requirements, the next line of medical diagnoses will “now” likely follow.

At this point the primary doctor refers an MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging), or magnetic resonance tomography (MRT) to look at the soft tissue and next refers you to an orthopedic specialist. A point-of-interest many patients are not aware. An x-Ray mostly is interested in seeing the bone. And not all “partial, or worse” soft tissue tears (especially muscle and tendon) can be seen using this technology.

Let me provide a bit of advice for those familiar with MRI technology. Before you advocate for your MRI referral, be sure to try the treatment program your primary care physician prescribes. Why? Because you may have a soft tissue sprain (ligaments that hold bone together that are overstretched or torn) as opposed to a soft tissue strain (A muscle or tendon that become overstretched or torn). Sprain and strains can occur in any joint, or along any segment of bone. The most common soft tissue damage occurs in the back, shoulders, wrist, knee and ankles. You may be the “overstretched soft tissue” patient that can be rehabilitated without the use of costly MRI diagnosis services.

Doctor’s are not encouraged to send you for an MRI immediately after injury. Why? Well cost is a given, but this technology does not serve its full purpose until the swelling has gone down and sessions of physical therapy ensue. But there is a point of time passed… That one should self refer for an MRI through their primary physician, when swelling has gone down, therapy sessions are finished and pain is not alleviated. In other words, if you have not healed make a follow up appointment.

You should expect if you have overstretched soft tissue damage, it can take up to 6-8 weeks to heal correctly. But if you have gone for 3 months on a rehabilitative course and your pain management programming is not improving and if you’ve not had an MRI, suspect you may have a soft tissue partial tear, etc. And a soft tissue partial tear can completely tear. You want to avoid a full tear! Why? The only way to repair this is through surgery. Or you can choose to live through the pain and partial immobilization that will follow.

Don’t make yourself a surgery candidate unnecessarily. If you know you have a pain problem as the result of injury and well after physical therapy, self refer through your doctor for an MRI to look at the painful muscle, or joint area. Chances are the orthopedic specialist will see soft tissue damage that can be treated without surgery before a full tear occurs.

You then have an opportunity to expedite the healing process through the findings with a different approach to treatment. You’ll also, alleviate pain and minimize what might be otherwise a lifelong dependency on drugs and more severe pain. I’ve personally been successful in self referring to receive an MRI after the first 2-4 weeks of injury. As always, good health to you and your families!


More by this Author


Comments 7 comments

Garnetbird 5 years ago

Good, well-written Hub--I had an MRI and it was so distressing they had to give me valium beforehand..it's a very noisy machine. {It bangs)


woodamarc profile image

woodamarc 5 years ago from Portland, Oregon Author

I was in an MRI for 1.5hours. Talk about a very lonely experience. It's good they gave me ear plugs... Your right, very noisy.


Matt Stark profile image

Matt Stark 5 years ago from Albany, CA

Good advice and very true an MRI is not always needed initially. Great suggestion on when one might be indicated. Up, useful, following.


sgbrown profile image

sgbrown 4 years ago from Southern Oklahoma

Excellent information! Everyone should learn the difference in what an X-ray can see and what an MRI can see. Some years ago my mother went through X-rays and a CT scan before I insisted on an MRI. The MRI found a tumor the size of a grapefruit that the other methods would never have found. If the previous treatments are not working...keep looking! Excellent information, voted up and useful! Thank you for sharing this information! :)


woodamarc profile image

woodamarc 4 years ago from Portland, Oregon Author

Thanks for the positive comments. It definitely helps to have knowledge of diagnosis equipment and its applicable use. In your example, found a tumor the size of a grapefruit. The MRI was the best piece of equipment to see it... Amazing.


Johne871 2 years ago

Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thanks Nonetheless I am experiencing issue with ur rss . Dont know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anybody getting similar rss drawback? Anybody who is aware of kindly respond. Thnkx gkefgadddebd


woodamarc profile image

woodamarc 23 months ago from Portland, Oregon Author

Sorry for the long awaited reply. Been out of commission for awhile. Thanks for the kind words on the hub. Did you get the RSS drawback taken care of? Thanks for the kind words. And I'm happy you enjoyed the article. Good health to you and your family!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working