Build Muscle by Eating Less Protein?

Eat less protein and you will build more muscle. It is a silly idea, right? After all, common scientific knowledge says that an athlete trying to build muscle needs at least 1.5-2.0 grams of protein per kilogram of bodyweight. So what gives?

First, let's do some math:

According to RD411.com, a healthcare professionals website, for a 180 pound male, which is about 82 kg of body weight, you would need between 123 and 164 grams of protein per day to accomplish your goal.

That's a truckload of eggs, meat, protein shakes or all three. If you are vegetarian/vegan, the eating volume is even greater.

If eating this much protein in one day sounds extreme, there is evidence indicating that such high percentages of protein in the diet are not necessary for building muscle. What type of and how many calories you eat with your protein, and when you eat it, are more important factors.

Too much is a Waste

According to researchers at Montana State University, even for a strength athlete whose protein needs are higher than most, protein synthesis stops completely at a consumption level of 2.4 g/kg of bodyweight. And the excess amino acids made by this process?

They are excreted in the resulting increase in urine production (a process called diuresis,) and can cause dehydration. They can also be converted to fat and stored.

The same research emphasizes that an unbalanced diet with too much of any one energy source can destroy progress. Consuming too many protein calories without enough carbohydrate calories, for example, will cause the body to break down the protein for energy.

The priority is to consume enough calories to meet energy needs, in balanced proportions. So how much does an athlete need to meet energy needs and maintain or build bigger, stronger muscles?

How Much Should I Eat?

In strength athletes (weightlifters, bodybuilders, or anyone who engages in regular resistance training,) protein-hungry muscles force the body to increase the production and breakdown of proteins, so a necessary increase in consumption is greatest in these athletes.

Following RD411's guidelines, these people are at the top of the spectrum and should be eating as much as 1.7 g/kg of bodyweight, or about 140 g of protein.

By the same guide, endurance athletes, such as runners,cyclists, etc.,should be consuming from 1.2-1.4 g/kg of bodyweight. That is, 98-115 grams.

Are you a couch potato? Then relax, your body only needs about 0.4 grams for every pound you own. Of course, if you weigh 250 pounds, that's still 100 grams of protein.

These numbers are from RD411, but the National Strength and Conditioning Association suggests an even lower number; .4 to .8 grams per pound for sedentary to high intensity exercisers, respectively.

The most important factor for increasing muscle size and strength according to the NSCA? Adequate fuel in the form of carbohydrates for enabling muscle stimulation and contractions.

Their formula:

Adequate carbohydrates=maximal fuel for muscle contraction through insulin response=protein synthesis=muscle hypertrophy.

I simplified this, but basically their results say that carbohydrates are broken down for fuel and trigger protein synthesis through the production of insulin. Insulin is hormone with anabolic properties.

A Note on Carbs

Eating carbohydrates with a high glycemic index, or a high insulin index, can disrupt your body's ability to regulate incoming calories. Find a glycemic or insulin index card or pocket book and keep it with you for handy reference.

The higher the GI number, the faster the food breaks down and goes into the bloodstream (think sugar rush.) The slower carbs are generally preferred, as they produce a longer, steadier energy supply. But beware, some proteins and fats have a high insulin index which can cause an exaggerated insulin response as well.

Protein Sources

The latest research is clear: Excess protein consumption does not increase muscle size or strength. The body still needs protein, however, so here is a list of some great sources:

-4 oz. of lean steak, chicken or fish: ~28 g protein.

-1 cup cooked vegetables: 4 g protein.

-1 cup oatmeal: 6 g

-1 egg white: 3.5 g each

-1 cup Greek yogurt: ~23 g (high fat kind)

-1 cup Kefir: 11g

-4 oz. tofu: ~10 g

Of course, beans and lentils are another excellent source, and you probably have many more to add to this list.

When Should I Eat it?

Because the body needs adequate carbohydrates and protein to fuel workouts, eat a very small meal or snack an hour before you start exercising. MayoClinic recommends consumption of 45-65 percent carbs, and 10-35 percent protein. The rest is reserved for good fats.

Remember to refuel the body with a balanced meal after the workout as well. This speeds recovery and provides much needed nutrition to exhausted muscles. Follow the same guidelines above, but feel free to eat a larger meal.

For the remainder of your protein needs,try to eat up to four additional snacks/meals throughout the day, for a total of six feeding times. An example would be:

-early am breakfast or snack

-mid am snack

-light lunch

-early afternoon snack

-dinner

-pre-bedtime snack

The timing and amount of consumption is a highly individualized process,so do some experimenting to find out what works best. Keep a detailed journal of what, how much and at what time the food was eaten. Indicate whether there was a workout that day and other activities that took place if necessary.

The right balance of calories in the diet can mean drastic changes in athletic performance and everyday life.

Quality protein counts
Quality protein counts | Source
Fiber Menace: The Truth About the Leading Role of Fiber in Diet Failure, Constipation, Hemorrhoids, Irritable Bowel Syndrome, Ulcerative Colitis, Crohn's Disease, and Colon Cancer
Fiber Menace: The Truth About the Leading Role of Fiber in Diet Failure, Constipation, Hemorrhoids, Irritable Bowel Syndrome, Ulcerative Colitis, Crohn's Disease, and Colon Cancer

Fiber Menace is for people who believe fiber prevents cancers, reduces the risk of heart disease, regulates blood sugar, wards off diabetes, lowers appetite, induces weight loss, cleanses the colon, and eliminates constipation.

Tragically, none of it is true, and Fiber Menace explains why it’s the complete opposite.

 
The Paleo Diet: Lose Weight and Get Healthy by Eating the Foods You Were Designed to Eat
The Paleo Diet: Lose Weight and Get Healthy by Eating the Foods You Were Designed to Eat

According to author Loren Cordain, modern health and diet problems didn't start with the advent of packaged snack food, but much earlier--back at the dawn of the agricultural age many thousands of years ago. As humans became less nomadic and more dependent on high-carbohydrate diets, we left behind the diet we had evolved with, which is based on low-fat proteins and plenty of fruits and vegetables.

 
The Paleo Diet Cookbook: More Than 150 Recipes for Paleo Breakfasts, Lunches, Dinners, Snacks, and Beverages
The Paleo Diet Cookbook: More Than 150 Recipes for Paleo Breakfasts, Lunches, Dinners, Snacks, and Beverages

Dr. Loren Cordain's The Paleo Diet has helped thousands of people lose weight, keep it off, and learn how to eat for good health by following the diet of our Paleolithic ancestors and eating the foods we were genetically designed to eat.

 

More by this Author


Comments 6 comments

H.Kephart profile image

H.Kephart 5 years ago from United States

Good article! The guys I used to work out with would heavily disagree, but then again they all would drink a ton of protein shakes a day. Such a waste, and it can't be healthy. Voted up and useful.


MosLadder profile image

MosLadder 5 years ago from Irvine, CA Author

Thanks! I know what you mean, i have guilty of that myself, especially when I was in my teens/twenties. Glad I know better now!


Melovy profile image

Melovy 4 years ago from UK

This is very useful information. My kids are vegetarian and keen swimmers, so I’ve often felt unsure if they are getting enough protein. My mind is at rest now after reading this. Thanks.


MosLadder profile image

MosLadder 4 years ago from Irvine, CA Author

Thanks for commenting Melovy. Good for them for being so healthy! (and you :-) )


Angelme566 profile image

Angelme566 4 years ago

This is so informative especially to me for i am a Protein eater..thanks !


MosLadder profile image

MosLadder 4 years ago from Irvine, CA Author

Hi Angelme566! Thanks for your comment. I can relate, this research made me realize I could ease up on the constant protein intake. Cheers!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working