FM Dual Cable Cross vs. TRX Suspension Trainer vs. Resistance Bands
The FM Dual Cable Cross, the TRX Suspension Trainer and a complete resistance bands system are three great fitness products with extreme differences in price. All allow the user to simulate movements in life and sports by allowing the body to move in endless ranges of motion, and each offers a wide range of resistance. So what are the advantages and disadvantages of each?
I’ll start with the FM EXT Dual Cable Cross, a finely tuned machine from FreeMotion. This is their ‘light commercial’ version designed for home use or private personal training studios. Using a pair of sturdy arms attached to a pillar enclosing a cable weight stack, the user can adjust the arms up and down, locking them in place for an exercise. The arms pivot about 180 degrees between them and they have enough range of motion to accommodate any user (cable and arm = 89 inches each) and probably any exercise (you’d have a hard time stumping this machine.)
The cables, which for the sake of clarity each have handles, travel on a fluid enclosed pulley system. Each cable pulls its own weight stack, going up to 210 pounds. For strength training and muscle building, a total of 420 pounds max resistance offers room to grow. Or so you would think. The specifications indicate the effective resistance at 70 pounds per arm.
In either case, the advantage of the Free Motion Dual Cable Cross is not that it replaces the bench press or similar strength exercises, but that it allows the user to move against resistance in so many planes of motion. As a cable machine, the weight stack lets you know exactly how much weight is being used. With the TRX and resistance cables, it is a bit of a guessing game. Sure, resistance bands come color coded according to the maximum poundage they approximate, but it takes a bit of adjusting to get just the right tension with resistance band exercises.
There are some exercises that the FM EXT lends itself well to, possibly better than either the trx or resistance bands. The squat is one of these. With the right bands, it is easy to do squats by stepping on them, but with the FM dual cable cross machine, you can squat a specific weight and not have to worry about the bands rubbing on either side of you.
Another is the woodchopper. This exercise can be done with a resistance band, but unless you have a high attachment point, you may be limited to the low/high version. Resistance bands have a major advantage over the dual cable cross, though. They are portable, and you can buy long bands for powerlifting with tension ratings to 275 pounds. In fact for about $100, you can pack an entire gym with light to heavy resistance in the bottom of a suitcase or duffel bag. The FX EXT? Unless you can find one used, it comes in just under $4,000, and well, you can't take it with you. It is a nice design and will look great in a studio or gym, but as a piece of home gym equipment, are there better values out there?.
For price and versatility, the trx suspension trainer gives the FM EXT serious competition. It has a unique design that, unlike the FM cable cross machine or resistance bands, allows you to move in any plane of motion using only your body weight. Sounds simple right? It is and it isn’t. It is a basic piece of equpment like every other suspension trainer on the market with some notable differences.
First of all they come in yellow and military (desert) beige, colors that are so far unique to TRX. Second, the construction is excellent. The straps feel and look heavy duty (they are rated to over 1000 lbs.) as is the stitching. When you examine the trx for the first time out of the package, it impresses. There is nothing light or half-ass about it. On the other hand it only weighs about two pounds and is even easier to transport than the resistance bands.
While certain exercises can not be done with the trx, such as the low to high woodchopper or a resisted squat, the extended number of exercises you can do with it more than makes up for the few you can’t. For instance, you can’t go heavy on a squat, but you can perfect you’re single leg squat (pistol) and increase leg power and hip drive with Sprinter’s Starts.
You won't be executing military presses either, but you’re shoulders and chest will be challenged by decline push-ups, and the infamous ‘TYW’ exercises. Also, it isn’t exactly a woodchopper, but you can do standing oblique twists or suspended planks with the reach under. One thing the TRX has a clear advantage on is core workouts. Nothing compares with having to stabilize the body in free space and direct its movement at the same time.
With the trx suspension trainer, resistance increases by changing the angle of an exercise-push-ups get harder as the feet go higher, body rows get harder as the body moves towards horizontal and so on. Price-wise, It comes in at the middle of our three products at $200-220. For this price it includes a door anchor and a full instructional workout video.
So which product is the best in class? I’m partial to cheap and portable, and the FM Dual Cable Cross machine seems a bit redundant. Other than looking cool, it is basically an expensive, well-made, gadget. For me, it does not offer enough advantage over resistance bands set-up and anchored to a wall or door, or a light trx which can go anywhere and offer a similar (and perhaps more challenging) workout.
The advantage it does offer is a stable, fixed point and
ample weight to push against, but at those prices you can get a pretty nice set
of dumbbells to do the same thing. Check out the videos for each product and
judge for yourself.Or, Click here to check out the TRX suspension trainers >>>
TRX Reach Under Plank
Continue Reading >>>
- Can you Live Longer through Diet and Exercise?
- Resistance Bands Exercises-Great for Travel or Just Playing Around
Exercises for resistance bands can seem flimsy, especially when compared to a barbell loaded with iron on the back of a well-muscled tree trunk. But if you know what to do with them, you can get a serious...
- TRX Functional Training That Builds Muscle and Increases Performance
Suspension training can be a very effective method of building and strengthening muscles, burning fat, and enhancing sports performance and daily mobility. Although tools like the TRX Pro Trainer can be...
- Kettlebells or TRX-Which is a Better Value for the Money?
The best piece of exercise equipment is the one the owner enjoys the most and therefore will use the most. Of course, individual fitness or athletic goals play an important part in what types of exercises a...
- Traveling Workout and Portable Gym Equipment
Traveling offers an opportunity to experience some of the greatest workouts you will ever have. Whether you're a hardcore gym enthusiast, power lifter, triathlete or somebody who is just trying to stay on...
- Which Resistance Bands Should you Choose?
Not all resistance bands are created equal. In fact, there was a time when resistance bands were not taken seriously, and the idea of wrestling with some rubber bands in place of a "real" workout with the iron...
- Home Gym Workout Routines with No Equipment
An inventive person could go on for days thinking up ways to substitute common household objects for real exercise equipment. Practically speaking, you may never have to spend a dime on a home gym; but, ...
- Buying a TRX fitness system online
The TRX suspension trainer. Born in the u.S. Navy Seals. Gym in a bag, anywhere you go. Suspension training can be defined as the performance of bodyweight bearing exercises while suspended. This may sound...
- MosLadder: More Homemade Clubbells for at Home Workout Routines
- Flex and Flow
More information about resistance bands, dumbbells and more.
More by this Author
Learn all about the full lineup of trx suspension trainers, what's included with the price and the latest additions to the product line.
Plyometric exercise is not just for competitive athletes. Learn what plyometrics are and design a program for your needs. Everyone can benefit from a little jumping around!
Hiking the Grand Canyon with kids. Absolutely! Follow our adventure on The Bright Angel Trail, a great place for first-time canyon hikers.
No comments yet.