Fighting For The Truth

Gregory Jacobs
Gregory Jacobs

Has your life been touched by organ donation?

  • Yes
  • No
See results without voting

Loss Of A Life Equals Second Chance For Others

Your loved one has just been in a serious accident. They may be hours from dying. They may be brain dead. You haven’t been told yet. All you know is that they are being treated down the hall by doctors who have saved countless lives. Everything is so rushed and jumbled. You can’t think beyond the current second. You are in shock.

A doctor, presumably from the team that’s working on your someone, comes to visit you in the waiting room. From their expression, you know that all is not well. You know that they are seconds away from telling you some of the worst news you will ever hear. In spite of your prayers and your head telling your heart to quiet down, you learn that, as next of kin, you must decide whether or not to put your loved one on life support or to let them go. The doctor also tells you that you could give “the gift of life” to someone who is on a transplant list by allowing your family member to have their organs harvested after death. What do you do?

For Michael Jacobs of Bellevue, Ohio, this unthinkable decision was his to make when his eighteen year old son, Gregory, sustained serious head injuries in a 2007 snowboarding accident. Under the impression that there was no chance for recovery, he allowed his son to become an organ donor. Gregory’s parents are now suing the hospital. They believe that they were given misleading information. After meeting with experts, it has become clear to them that not only could he have recovered, but that the doctors began to harvest his organs twenty-nine minutes before he was officially dead. The hospital, obviously, believes otherwise.

Gregory’s story gives people who are already wary of organ harvesting another reason to remain so. It speaks to the fear in all of us that something bad will happen if we aren’t able to speak for ourselves. It forces us to come to terms with our own mortally and urges us to write down our last wishes. For those of us who have lost someone young, it is a sad reminder that life is precious and that death has no age requirement.

Had Gregory been my son, I don’t know if I would’ve done anything differently from Michael. He loved his son very much. I would imagine he remembered Gregory as a small boy while he waited in the waiting room, making his eventual decision all the harder. He was in shock, not understanding fully what was going on. He listened to everything the doctor said and believed that all hope was lost for his son. Being a father, he didn’t want other fathers to lose their children. He allowed his son’s organs to be harvested so that another’s life could be spared. He made a selfless decision.

As Michael and Teresa are now suing the hospital, it makes many of us scratch our heads. Given the facts, it appears that Gregory’s organs were harvested too soon and that the hospital acted negligently. Still, no amount of money or notoriety will ever bring their son back. His death, by whatever means, has given a new chance to people who didn’t think they’d last beyond the year. Though wronged, can’t they see the good their son has done?

I agree that the doctors must be held accountable for what they’ve done. They have cut a life short by wanting to provide life to others. This man’s death deserves reflection and investigation. Still, I can’t imagine that a man as active as Gregory would’ve been content with the life that was left to him after his recovery. Knowing people who have become severely handicapped after brain injury, his new life would’ve been more than an adjustment. Would he have been able to walk, talk, feed himself, dress himself, and control his body functions? Would be have been under permanent guardianship? Would his life have been one operation after another? While his family and friends believe that their guy was cheated of life, I would argue that Gregory would’ve felt cheated had he lived. They would’ve had their Gregory or at least the shell of him, but Gregory wouldn’t have been Gregory. Gregory’s life, as he knew it, ended the second he lost consciousness.

The opponents of organ donation, I imagine, will use this story to petition for better laws and/or the end of donation. They will say that, with doctors like Gregory’s doctors calling the shots, none of us are safe under the knife. No patient that has survived longer thanks to a new organ will matter. As with many things, the only account that matters is the negative one.

I hope that Gregory’s parents get the justice that they seek, but, more importantly, are able to make peace with their loss. To lose someone is difficult, but to lose someone and have a bubble of suspicion forever surrounding their final moments is enough to break you down. Michael and Teresa need to stay strong in their pursuit of answers. Once given them, they need to accept them and move on. For them to waste their lives fighting a court battle would be an insult to Gregory’s memory.

More by this Author


Comments 5 comments

WannaB Writer profile image

WannaB Writer 7 years ago from Templeton, CA

My son was 14 whe he went with a group from church to water ski. He never came home again. He was allowed to ride a jet ski we did not know he would have access to. He collided with a boat and lived only for about 5 minutes. Had he lived, he would not have had legs, and he was a very active boy -- biking swimming, hiking, skating --you name it. Interestingly enough, on the way to the lake another boy asked him "If you had a bad accident and got hurt really bad, would you rather live or die?" His answer was that he would rather live. He loved life. We really have no way of knowing that Gregory would rather not have lived.


LowellWriter profile image

LowellWriter 7 years ago from Lowell, MA Author

I'm so sorry to hear about your son. You and your family will remain in my thoughts for awhile to come. Thank you for telling me your story.


BISG Writer profile image

BISG Writer 7 years ago from Arkansas

Had Gregory lived, would he have felt cheated? Everyone who suffers a brain injury feels cheated to some extent. I, too, was told that my wife probably would not survive the trauma she'd sustained; the first 24 hours were critical. Then it was the next 48 hours are critical...and so on. Next week is the 19th anniversary of her event, and she is a vibrant brain injury survivor, maintaining a blog to help others living with brain injury. The contributions she made to our book, Brain Injury Survivor's Guide, were simply invaluable. She is still cheated from being what society considers "normal" because of memory and visual deficits yet she is determined to make life better for others.


LowellWriter profile image

LowellWriter 7 years ago from Lowell, MA Author

Thank you for telling me your story. Best wishes to you and your wife. :)


LowellWriter profile image

LowellWriter 7 years ago from Lowell, MA Author

Thank you for telling me your story. Best wishes to you and your wife. :)

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working