Can a Psychiatric Diagnosis Hurt You in a Divorce?

Mental illness plagues about a fourth of our population. Should you bring up mental health issues if you're divorcing?
Mental illness plagues about a fourth of our population. Should you bring up mental health issues if you're divorcing? | Source

Taking Care of Yourself, Your Spouse, and Your Children

In any given year, about one of every four American adults is diagnosed with a mental illness, according to the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH). Not surprisingly, many couples who are considering divorce may have a mental health issue that plays a role in the decision to divorce. A diagnosis can also have a major effect on the divorce itself.

If you are considering divorce or in the process of one, and there is a question about your or your spouse's mental health, it can affect how your divorce proceeds, the way your children relate to both of you, and the kind of settlement that the judge may award. Learn more about what you should know if you're considering raising mental health issues in a divorce case.

What Do YOU Think?

How often do you think mental illness is a factor leading to divorce?

  • In more than half of all divorces.
  • Not more than half, but more than 25% of divorces probably have some mental health issues.
  • Probably less than 25% of them.
  • I have no idea!
See results without voting

How Mental Illness Affects Divorce Proceedings

Mental illness is a tricky factor when it comes to divorce equations. Some people are seriously mentally ill with conditions like borderline personality disorder (BPD) or narcissistic personality disorder (NPD), conditions that very likely contributed to ongoing problems that have led to divorce, but they may never have been diagnosed.

Meanwhile, some people have an illness that is treatable, but aren't diagnosed or they don't comply with their doctors' recommendations. Yet other people have been diagnosed and are compliant with their treatment, but they're not getting the "right" treatment or have received an inaccurate and contestable diagnosis.

And then there's a whole different scenario - people who self-diagnose a partner as having a mental illness when that person is actually emotionally stable. Often, the accusers are undiagnosed narcissists or borderline personalities, but the nature of their illness makes it unlikely they will ever be diagnosed.

Some states offer no-fault divorces, while others require grounds for a divorce - and mental illness is considered to be a valid reason.

In the courtroom, hostile estranged spouses may bandy about accusations of mental instability, especially when children are involved. Judges may order psychiatric evaluations to consider which parent can provide their children the healthiest environment in which to grow. Accusations of mental illness can incur delays, extra expenses, and lingering resentments that may never heal.

Mental Illness and Children in Divorce Proceedings

When mental health plays a role in divorce, it can stigmatize a parent and affect how his or her children perceive their caretaker. Even if a parent has been an adequate and loving parent, the moment they're labelled with even a common diagnosis like depression or anxiety, it begins to affect the children's relationship with their mom or dad.

Suddenly, their parent may become "less" in their eyes. Less capable. Less worthy. Less deserving of love. Children are already under stress because of the divorce proceedings. Introducing mental health issues can aggravate that stress and lead to acting out behaviors, depression, anxiety, and more adjustment problems for children.

If a parent's mental illness affects their ability to provide for their child's basic needs so much that they shouldn't have unsupervised time with your children, it may be necessary to document their condition thoroughly and introduce the evidence in your proceedings. However, if the truth is more akin to the parent simply holding different values that you dislike, consider finding a different way to persuade them if you truly love your children, because your kids still need both of you.

How Your Divorce Settlement Can Be Affected by Mental Illness

Angry partners may pledge that their soon-to-be-ex will pay the price when they get to court because of a mental illness, but they're often wrong.

In fact, the opposite may happen. Courts may require the healthy parent to provide spousal support (what used to be called alimony) or family support - and may not change custody as long as the diagnosis doesn't interfere with the patient's ability to parent.


When Should Mental Health be an Issue in Divorce?

By the time a couple files for divorce, the effects of any mental illness are evident even when there hasn't been an official diagnosis. Bringing it up in the courtroom can cause more problems than necessary, or claims might be ignored altogether.

However, there are times when it's better to raise the issue of mental illness:

  • When there is a high risk of violence toward you or your children.
  • When your children are at a moderate to high risk of neglect or abuse.
  • When you anticipate that your partner will try to get spousal support due to their diagnosis.

In all three of these circumstances, be prepared to defend against an unwanted outcome. Keep journals that report threats and injuries, including the dates, locations, and events that took place. Take photographs of suspicious bruises or injuries. See a doctor to get third party, objective documentation of abuse. Ask the court to issue a temporary restraining order if the risk is immediate. Use e-mail, witness statements, photographs, work histories, and recreation information if it can prove that your spouse's behavior is unstable or that they're healthy enough that you shouldn't need to provide for them financially.

More by this Author


Comments 4 comments

michememe profile image

michememe 4 years ago

Depression, which is a mental illness takes control of many people during a divorce. I have witness this first hand. Also, some take to substance abuse in the for of alcohol or drugs. Good hub.


jellygator profile image

jellygator 4 years ago from USA Author

Yes, those two are probably the most common illnesses that affect people, and they can be especially bad during times of stress. Thanks Michememe.


meloncauli profile image

meloncauli 4 years ago from UK

Interesting hub! I agree to that alcoholism can be prevalent in either or both parents and is cause for concern when raising children. As for mental illness; stigma attached to mental illness in some cases, can interfere with a correct decision.

Thanks for sharing this information for those who need it.


jellygator profile image

jellygator 4 years ago from USA Author

Thank you, Meloncauli!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    Click to Rate This Article
    working