PSYCH-Robo-Nurse

WHY "BEHAVIORAL TELEHEALTH" IS AWFUL FOR PSYCH PATIENTS

THE HUMAN TOUCH...ESSENTIAL FOR REAL MENTAL HEALTH CARE

by Dr. Helen Borel

On June 5, 2008, I responded to a cadre of psychologists lauding the "value" of non-hands-on "treatment" of psychiatric patients for monetary reasons and so-called healthcare efficiency. "Dispatch patients rapidly with little feeling or humanity" seemed a concept that enthralled the participants (at a convention on this weird topic, no less). Feverishly praising the technology that now allows home-bound mentally compromised, emotionally ill, frail elderly and assorted emotionally needy others to be reached by phone, computer, and probably even by UFO, I was so distressed by this notion that I sent the greedy "practitioners" the following notice:

Sorry guys! I’m of the old-school. The one with the compassion and understanding that recognizes that patients require HANDS-ON healthcare…ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO MENTAL HEALTH. Patients need to see your face, to hear the words and see them coming from your lips.

I can’t believe the play I wrote in the 1970s called "Switchboard," about the practice of medicine by telephone alone, is coming true. Mine was a futuristic satire. But you guys think this is something good. This is tragic.

How in the world did we become such a mechanical, hands-off society that "distant yearning" is all that patients are entitled to? Since when does a phone call…or a television monitor…or an out-of-state ICU doc substitute for quality patient care? These practices are so out of left field, it boggles my mind.

"BEHAVIORAL TELEHEALTH"? That’s the unhealthiest unhealthcare of all. I don’t care about studies and bottom-line-oriented studies. I care about patients. They are paramount. Why don’t the "researchers" ask patients whether they’d rather have a human being visit them than a machine that logs into their life…or a disembodied phone call?

I have a suggestion: Why don’t people who seem interested in avoiding direct patient contact choose some other field of study and lifetime career…instead of healthcare and psychiatric care that requires THE HUMAN TOUCH?

Or else, why don’t we outsource our patients to an island of sick people where we don’t have to see them, hear them or touch them gently at all? What next, Robo-Nurse?

Helen Borel,R.N.,Ph.D.

3 comments

DiamondRN profile image

DiamondRN 6 years ago from Charlotte, NC USA

I too have deep feelings about this proposed practice and its practitioners. It sounds Orwellian.


Creativita/Helen 6 years ago

Thank you for your support of these ideas. It's nice not to be alone in my wish to protect patients. Best regards, Creativita/Helen B.


Sheila Wilson profile image

Sheila Wilson 6 years ago from Pennsylvania

This is a very interesting topic. I have agoraphobic tendencies with my PTSD, which has led me to empathize with home-bound psych consumers. In those few cases, I can see a value in this type of care. It unnerves me that people would think this is a benefit in this case or in others. If anything, its a sad hinderance to wellness.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


    More by this Author

    • Are There Advantages to Madness?  Part One: Psychosis
      6

      Schizophrenia,hallucinations,delusions,dementia,Alzheimer's,psychiatric hospital,antipsychotic drugs,brain tumors,traumatic brain injury,alcohol-withdrawal, infections all can evidence psychotic symptoms.

    • PREVENTING DEATH FROM ANAPHYLAXIS
      18

      by Helen Borel, RN,PhD Recently, a young man asked about his possible allergy to yeast or barley because of a severe reaction he experienced while drinking beer. First, I advised him to stay away from beer altogether...

    • SPINAL CRIPPLING DUE TO SHINGLES
      24

      A POX ON HERPES ZOSTER by Helen Borel,RN,PhD I'm reaching out for any medical, neurologic or other interested individuals to provide me with information I cannot seem to locate on the internet...not even at any...


    No comments yet.

      Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

      0 of 8192 characters used
      Post Comment

      No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.


      Click to Rate This Article
      working