Recalling Half a Billion Eggs is Silly
Do You Think Regulation will Stop Disease? Watch this video for the Harsh Reality of Corporate Farms
More Regulation will Not stop Disease Outbreaks
Hey I’m the first to fully understand the ramifications of Food Poisoning… because I’ve had it. For 10 days it was pure hell throwing up in one end and well you know very disgusting out the other. I actually went and purchased a padded toilet seat after spending so many hours on the thing. It’s horrible, hideous, agonizing and disgusting. Somewhere halfway into the process I was pretty ready to not care if I just keeled over and died. But… that doesn’t mean additional regulations or inspections would have made any difference. Because the Doctor never figured out what exactly was the cause – source of my food poisoning.
I wanted to preface my coming remarks with the preceding paragraph so that people will fully understand that my criticisms are not out of empathy for those stricken ill.
Chickens are not animals in corporate egg farms they are machines. They have no lives to speak of… they sit in cages eating and laying eggs. When their useful life is over they are destroyed. These birds are not free to do anything other than sit, eat, and lay eggs. They are packed in extremely high density environments and for every clean farm there are those that are not well managed and the chickens rest in their own filth. You see you can not produce eggs on the cheap by running chicken friendly farms where they actually have room to roam and exercise. In these high density environments it’s very easy for one infected chicken to contaminate the entire lot. Personally I choose to by eggs from “cage free” farmers, but ultimately my trust is placed not in the farm but what is printed on the package. Don’t look for American Corporate farming practices to change.
Now lets look at the numbers behind the recall. The recent egg recall supposedly affects half a billion eggs – 500 million of them. If you take those half billion eggs and divide the eggs by the 1,300 people who have fallen ill you get an interesting number.
And that number is less than 1/5th of 1% of the eggs caused illness.
Looking at this another way… lets say that your company made $500 million in cash but somehow $1,300 of that money came from illegal drug trafficking. Because of this the Government had decided that you need to hand back over all $500 million to them to “be safe”. Doesn’t make much sense does it?
The Shelf Life of Eggs
Think of this for a moment… by the time the source farms are tracked down the shelf life of the contaminated eggs will have nearly expired. So what is the point in pulling the existing eggs? Sure we need/want to know where the problem is but will pulling the eggs off the shelf make any real difference? I say this for one simple reason. There is a fool proof way to determine without doubt that no one else gets sick while the investigation continues. And that is to simply cook the eggs completely. Complete cooking will destroy the pathogenic salmonella bacteria. That’s right a contaminated egg will not make you sick if you cook it completely.
The Economics of returning all those Eggs
Seriously Grocers and Distributors may return the eggs but how many of us are going to get in our car and return to the store for $1.29? And unless we are already going to the store this will cost us more money and time than just throwing them out or making sure to cook them completely.
Government Regulation to the Rescue!
Every time a story like this pops up – and they do happen every couple of years – suddenly the media criticizes the Federal Government and there is a movement to require more inspections and regulations.
Sadly more Government is not the answer. There is no way that 500 million eggs can all be Government inspected. It’s just not going to happen. And more regulation is going to do what? It’s going to drive the price of eggs up so much that people will consume fewer eggs and the industry will suffer. We don’t need more Government. The simple solution is to address our methods of farming BEFORE these crisis happen. Regulation after the fact (After the Chicken has laid the egg) may increase the prevention rate by a small margin… but it will never stop the problem.
Healthy chickens lay healthy eggs. And until Corporate Farmers decide it’s time to stop treating birds like machines and start developing methods that allow the birds to live natural lives we will continue to have these issues. Want to see something really disgusting look at Corporate Beef Farming… cows ankle deep in their own feces. Downed cattle dragged off to market.
Regulation will never take the place of animal friendly farming. That’s my 2 cents. Think about what you eat and where it comes from. Support local farmers. Only 2% of Americans now work in Agriculture, but all of us depend upon it. And if consumers do not demand quality they will never get it.
Actual Egg Farm
More by this Author
Whether you are an executive or office worker or small business owner you owe it to your health and your spine to invest in the best ergonomic office chair for your body! If you work in front of a computer for long...
Of 115 published animal studies, 81 percent found signiﬁcant effects from even low-level exposure to BPA. While none of the 11 industry-funded studies found signiﬁcant effects, over 90 percent of government-funded...
Costco TV purchasing information: why buy a big screen TV from Costco? Find out if Amazon or Costco is the best place for you to buy your next big TV